November 21, 2026

Bangladesh at the crossroads

I fear that Bangladesh might revert to its pre-1991 condition in which even the peaceful transfer of power after credible elections was not possible. If democracy were to fail in the world's fourth largest Muslim country it would be a setback everywhere in the Islamic world

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 27 May 2007, 02:29 PM

Updated : 17 Aug 2022, 03:15 PM

William B Milam Daily Times January 10, 2007 I fear that Bangladesh might revert to its pre-1991 condition in which even the peaceful transfer of power after credible elections was not possible. If democracy were to fail in the world's fourth largest Muslim country it would be a setback everywhere in the Islamic world My trip to Bangladesh to be an observer of the January 22 election is off. In the past ten days, the legitimacy of that election has been severely compromised by the withdrawal of the entire opposition, which is boycotting the election claiming that the playing field is much tilted towards the other side. Confusion reigns, and widespread violence will almost certainly follow as the opposition clearly means not just to sit out the election but to stop it. So observer organisations from the US and EU have ruled out sending teams. Some working-level teams already there may remain. It is not just the security considerations, though these are not trivial, that concern these organisations. Given the likelihood of serious violence, observers would surely not be able to observe anyway. They would probably be stuck in their hotel rooms, which would be a waste of scarce taxpayer resources. In addition, some are concerned that sending observers would convey an unofficial sanction to an election that will be clearly wanting in legitimacy This impasse has serious implications not only for Bangladesh but also for the South Asian region and the Islamic world. Most considered that the political innovation that Bangladeshis created in 1991 and institutionalised in 1996 — a neutral, non-party, caretaker government which oversees elections — could be a model for other countries that are also plagued by the dog-eat-dog, zero-sum-game politics that have characterised Bangladesh politics since its independence. Instead the Bangladeshi political parties have proved that any attempt to create a mechanism to ensure free and fair elections must by tightly bound by checks and balances. Otherwise poisonous political cultures — and the Bangladeshi political culture is among the worst in that respect — will overwhelm the best of intentions. It is another argument for tightly constructed constitutions to keep human nature in check. The Bangladesh opposition has coalesced into a 14-party alliance that ranges from the right of centre Jatiya Party (JP) of former President Ershad to some marginal leftwing parties — the small remnants of the strong and militant (also dangerous) leftwing revolutionary elements that emerged from the war of separation in 1971. These days, the left as a significant national movement, is basically dead in Bangladesh, having been relentlessly marginalised over the past 30 years by the military governments of Ziaur Rahman and Ershad, and the insidious growth of Islamism in Bangladeshi society. The Awami League (AL), the main party of the 14-party alliance, is basically from the centre-left (the moderates) of the Bangladesh political spectrum. The AL has moved steadily from the left towards the centre since the heady days when it led the nation to independence. Several Alliance parties or politicians, however, found the centre-right alliance led by the Bangladesh National Party (BNP) of Begum Kaleda Zia and the Jama'at-e Islami (JI) just as comfortable not too long ago. It is a mixed bag as alliances go. The Alliance has complained that the caretaker government is neither non-party nor neutral as required by the constitution. On the face of it their complaint looks legitimate. When the parties could not agree on someone to lead the caretaker government, the president, who had been elected from the BNP, appointed himself as its head. Half of the advisors he appointed soon quit claiming that he would not consult with or listen to them. The Election Commission's (EC) neutrality was also questioned and that was compounded by the news that the voters' list — which will determine who can vote — is seriously flawed with at least 13 million more names than there should be. The courts ordered that the list be rectified, but the EC seems to have been done little to get it right. The 14-party alliance pushed hard for a 45-60 day postponement of the election while the list was being repaired. But it did not decide definitively to boycott until ex-president Ershad was ruled ineligible to contest the election after he was suddenly (out of nowhere it seemed) convicted in a case that had lain fallow for almost 15 years. This caused his Jatiya Party to declare that it would not participate in the election. With the JP's sure 15 seats suddenly problematic, the 14-party alliance also decided to boycott. But that may not be the entire story. Many observers believe that the underlying reason was disarray in the 14-party ranks. Many of the nominations of the AL have made the party's followers unhappy. Perhaps more importantly, out of the blue, the AL signed a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) last week with an Islamist party, which is perceived to commit it — AL has always prided itself on being the moderate, secular party — to some aspects of the Islamist agenda. The crescendo of criticism for that action was deafening. Thus the AL may need a postponement to rearrange its nominations and abrogate the MOU. The truth is probably somewhere in between. The caretaker government leader has not acted as impartially as the opposition should expect it to during an election campaign. The Election Commission has been inept, at the very least. There was ample room for the opposition to complain. On the other hand, the AL, and some of its partners have seemed pretty amateurish in their preparations. And the inexplicable AL decision to sign that MOU with Islamists three weeks before the election, no matter what electoral practicalities motivated it, leads one to ask if its leaders have any understanding of the historical role and vision of their own party. Though Bangladesh has been often cited at the forefront of democratic growth in the Islamic world, it has seemed to me for some time that its democratic development stalled in midstream after the hopeful breakthrough of 1991. In that election, and in three out of the four subsequent elections, Bangladesh met one of the two criteria for a working democracy — power passed peacefully from a government to the opposition after credible elections. But it has not met the second test: effective governance in an atmosphere of constructive democratic debate and compromise, leaving the verdict on policy choices up to the voters at elections. I fear that Bangladesh might revert to its pre-1991 condition in which even the peaceful transfer of power after credible elections was not possible. If democracy were to fail in the world's fourth largest Muslim country it would be a setback everywhere in the Islamic world. With their own election just around the corner, Pakistanis should pay great heed as this drama unfolds in the other Muslim homeland of South Asia. William Milam is a former US ambassador to Pakistan and Bangladesh. He is currently at the Woodrow Wilson Center in Washington DC bdnews24.com/ask/ad/2024 hours
Related Stories