Another The Economist dig at Dhaka
A week after inviting the government's ire, The Economist has now come up with two more articles on Bangladesh. Full story
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
12 Aug 2011, 02:35 PM
Updated :
10 Aug 2022, 05:16 PM
Dhaka, Aug 12 (bdnews24.com)—A week after inviting the government's ire, The Economist has now come up with two more articles on Bangladesh.
This time, however, there is no mention of "bags of Indian cash and advice" in either article, appearing in the London-based magazine's Aug 13 edition and also uploaded on its website on Friday.
The globally acclaimed magazine in its July 30 edition in a report titled 'India and Bangladesh: Embraceable You' narrated the growing geopolitical interests of India that force the country to seek better relations closer home.
The government, however, binned the report and on Aug 4 sent a rejoinder saying that it was "disappointed as the report is less than well-researched and contains elements of misinformation and misrepresentation of facts."
"It seems a 'Smear Bangladesh' campaign is going on against the country," foreign minister Dipu Moni told bdnews24.com.
The latest reports on Banyan, a regular column on Asia, focuses on Bangladesh's politics with the headline "In the name of the father: An obsession with Bangladesh's past may explain its prime minister's growing intolerance".
The other report, titled "The poisonous politics of Bangladesh" indicates from the outset that it is not going to be admiring.
The Banyan starts with commending the country's state of economy. "The economy, with annual output of around $100 billion, grows by nearly 7 percent a year and is fuelled by the world's third-largest clothes-export industry. Aid money gushes in, and good things are done against poverty."
This stability in economy, the write-up points out, is hardly reflected in the state of the country's politics with new corruption cases filed against opposition chief Khaleda Zia and moves against her sons.
The relationship between Hasina and Khaleda is termed as one of 'legendary mutual animosity'.
With a general election in a few years, the article says that Sheikh Hasina could have tried to embed democracy to become the first person to be re-elected to the office of Bangladesh's prime minister.
"Sadly, judging by her recent behaviour, she seems to seek instead to crush the opposition and provoke an election boycott, silencing pesky critics as she goes."
Referring to rumours, The Economist article says Nobel Peace laureate Muhammad Yunus was "resented for his high international profile, which threatened to eclipse the sacred memory of Sheikh Hasina's father, Sheikh Mujibur Rahman, who led Bangladesh to independence".
According to the article, Yunus's other sins included his accepting the Nobel peace prize that 'Sheikh Hasina felt should have been hers, failing to commiserate after an assassination attempt on her in 2004, and being ungrateful for the help she gave Grameen'.
Mentioning a new constitutional requirement declaring Sheikh Mujib the Father of the Nation and ordering all offices in the country to display his portrait, the well-respected magazine says, "Hasina wants her father to be revered".
"Public debate is also constrained by the growing personality cult that Hasina is building around Sheikh Mujib… It is not healthy when one party identifies itself so closely with the nation," it observes.
The article says Hasina's dream for Bangladesh "differs profoundly from that cherished by her countrymen".
"She hopes to emulate not Indonesia or India today, but the country imagined by her father before his murder in 1975."
It questions the Awami League government's move to try war crime suspects, saying that the government has made a 'mess' of it. "Even sympathetic outsiders say it has bungled forthcoming war crimes trials of seven men over their alleged role in the war and massacres of 1971."
The magazine, however, did not place any argument over the trial but points at the bar on British lawyer Toby Cadman who was denied visa. Cadman has been engaged as an 'international consultant' by the lawyers of the war-crimes accused Jamaat-e-Islami leaders, including its chief Matiur Rahman Nizami.
Jamaat was snubbed after it had appealed on July 23 that the Bangladesh Bar Council appoint foreign lawyers as it was authorised to provide certificate to anyone but Bangladeshi lawyers.
Law minister Shafique Ahmed on July 19, however, said that suspects cannot apply for appointing foreign lawyers, "but a foreign lawyer can move on his or her own volition for any accused".
The magazine also criticises that the repeal of the caretaker government system in a hasty rewriting of the constitution. "Sheikh Hasina herself had insisted on the arrangement when in opposition. In office, she heedlessly went ahead and junked it. That bodes ill for fair and peaceful polls in 2013."
The Supreme Court in a verdict on May 10 suggested keeping the provision for two more elections, to avoid provoking social strife.
The columns termed the amendment process 'scandalous'. "Like Sri Lanka's president, Mahinda Rajapaksa, did last year, Sheikh Hasina has used the forms of parliamentary democracy to undermine the substance."
The Economist also says that its fear that Hasina could come down hard on the opposition, just two years ahead of the general elections, with a view to be re-elected comes true as "this week yet more corruption charges were filed against Sheikh Hasina's nemesis, the BNP's leader, Khaleda Zia, and an arrest warrant issued for her exiled son, Tarique Rahman".
On the other hand, the courts have quashed corruption cases against Awami League figures, the first article says.
"The fear was that she would use its huge mandate for partisan advantage," the Economist further says.
The magazine mentioned that as prime minister, most recently from 2001-06, "Mrs Zia presided over a brutal kleptocracy. But Sheikh Hasina, too, faced 13 charges, including extortion and conspiracy to murder, from one of her previous stints in power".
About the visit of Indian prime minister Manmohan Singh in September, The Economist says, a series of agreements formalising closer co-operation would be signed during the visit."
"It would be good if he and Bangladesh's many other friends abroad could show that their friendship is with the country, not just one party, and make clear that allowing democratic freedoms to flourish is a source not of weakness, but of strength," the magazine concludes.
bdnews24.com/ost/pks/bd/2354h