Published : 30 Aug 2021, 01:07 AM
Updated : 21 Jun 2022, 08:16 PM
I still remember the day I returned to Kabul for reporting in war-torn Afghanistan, exactly a year after covering the start of the Afghan-American war in 2001. But it was a different experience. On the second day of my arrival in Kabul from Islamabad on a small plane named Ariana, the flag carrier of Afghanistan, I was detained by some young men at a crowded street in Kabul, an experience completely different from my capture by the Taliban during the war in Kandahar on suspicion of me being an American spy. This time, the captors all belonged to the Taliban's opponents – supporters of the Northern Alliance. After the regime change, Kabul became their territory.
They thought I was a Pakistani and asked me in Urdu why I was in Kabul. I knew a mishmash of Hindi and Urdu , but didn't find it wise to use it. The warning from my journalist friends in Islamabad was always in my mind. Using Urdu in conversation might make people suspect me to be a Pakistani. For my release, some asked me, "Hindi, Hindi…" indicating that I was an Indian. I showed my passport, but they didn't recognise it, let alone read it. With great difficulty, I finally persuaded them to take me to the nearest police station where the police got my identity and let me go.
The purpose of telling this story is to remind all of the dominance of the Indians in US-occupied Afghanistan after the fall of the Taliban. Soon after the end of the Taliban rule, Pakistan became the enemy state of Afghanistan and India became its close ally. From Hamid Karzai to Ashraf Ghani, Pakistan's relations with anyone were not good because of India's influence over the Afghan government. Pakistan even accused India of using Afghan soil to incite separatist groups in Pakistan.
After the US agreement with the Taliban on Feb 29, 2020, it became clear that over time the Taliban leadership has been able to convince the world that they cannot be excluded from Afghanistan's development, formation, and the peace process. Neighbouring Iran, China, Russia, Central Asian countries, and Pakistan agree that the Taliban have a future role in nation-building. India's diplomacy and role have failed there miserably, and they have not sided with the US and Russia in their anti-Taliban stance. It was also clear that India's aspirations would turn to despair, and the Sino-Pakistani presence in Afghanistan would further shake India's ambitions for regional hegemony. India did not find a foothold during the deal negotiation process between the US and Taliban, although it played the role of guarding American interests in South Asia.
The lion's share of India's trade with Afghanistan is through Pakistan. Export and import in Afghanistan are also done through Pakistani seaports. But due to Pakistan's objections, the trade between India and Afghanistan had to be stopped at various times. Therefore, India is considering using the Chabahar seaport of Iran as an alternative route. Actually, by making Chabahar a gateway, India wants to be connected not only with Afghanistan but also with Central Asia, including Turkmenistan.
India also signed a tripartite transit agreement to trade with Afghanistan through Iran. It has signed a bilateral agreement with Iran for the development of the Chabahar port. India invested $3 billion in developing Chabahar, as the seaport is unsuitable for handling heavy cargo. Following the agreement, Iran will build a highway from Chabahar port to the Afghan border, and India took responsibility for making 200 km of roads inland from the Afghan border. Many Indian construction workers were killed by the Taliban during the construction of that road.
Iran also signed a 25-year deal with China on Mar 27, 2021 for $400 billion investment in the Chabahar port and port-related communication projects. That again disappoints India, even though they are investing in Chabahar at a slow pace.
The Indian government and Indian media's anxieties over the Taliban's capture of Kabul are palpable. Prime Minister Narendra Modi discussed Afghanistan's situation with world leaders, including Russia and Germany. India also convened a special meeting of the UN Security Council on the situation in Afghanistan as it chairs the Council currently. The South block has fallen into disrepair since the Taliban came to power. They fear that if the Taliban government intervenes, its entire labour in Afghanistan and total investment in Chabahar port would be wasted.
One of the most significant concerns for India is the potential rise in terrorist activities in the subcontinent, especially in Kashmir. The way India's Hindu fundamentalist government stripped Kashmir of autonomy and is violating human rights there, it appears they are inviting trouble there. The Taliban takeover of power has raised the possibility of further unrest in Kashmir, although the Taliban have promised that their soil will not be used for terrorist activities against any country. But the big question is whether the Kashmir independence movement is a terrorist act in the eyes of the Taliban.
India cannot forget the hijacking of the Indian Airlines Flight 814 by five masked terrorists on Dec 24, 1999, when the Taliban were still in power in Afghanistan. The plane was diverted to various cities and finally landed at Kandahar airport. The incident is still fresh in the memory of Ajit Doval, India's national security adviser who went to Kandahar as a negotiator to rescue passengers in exchange for releasing three leaders of the Kashmir separatist movement- Mushtaq Ahmed Jargar, Ahmed Omar Saeed Sheikh, and Masood Azhar. As a result, it is not uncommon for organisations such as the Haqqani Network, Lashkar-e-Taiba, and Jaish-e-Mohammed to increase their threat in Kashmir when the Taliban gain political legitimacy.
The recent Taliban takeover will throw India's relations with neighbouring Pakistan and China at risk. Now both countries are keen to recognise the Taliban government; here, India is cautious despite sheltering the Taliban opponents on its soil. However, the Taliban government will not go into a sweet relationship with India at the moment by sidelining China and Pakistan. It is unknown at this time how they will diplomatically deal the Taliban after losing their presence in Afghanistan. It seems, no doubt, they have no other choice but to engage themselves with this Taliban government.