Published : 29 Sep 2010, 05:12 PM
Updated : 21 Jun 2022, 08:38 PM
As Bangladesh tries once more to try Ghulam Azam, it is better to remember that it is not a person who is being tried but an idea. He represents the forces that united against the birth of the Bangladesh state on behalf of his homeland, Pakistan. It was this sense of his loyalty to his state that pushed him and his supporters to go on a murderous spree in 1971. Although he is about to go on trial for crimes against humanity, a process which still lacks confidence, it is also possible that he may be tried and found guilty and given this or that sentence. However, if one remembers the last days of December 1971 and the killing spree of the Al-Badr, Jamaat's killer boys in a mad attempt to cripple the emerging state and wreak revenge, one should see that it was an unnecessary effort because we on ourselves are quite capable of producing our own disasters.
That is why Ghulam Azam has won till now and must be smiling as he awaits a possible trial with his objectives met.
* * *
Anyone old enough to remember the days of early 1972 will remember the search for booty by the victorious as they went on every possible forms of celebration including looting and occasionally rape and murder. It was not state sanctioned as 1971 acts of the Pakistan army was but it was no less brutal where it was perpetrated and it was mostly accepted by society. The state that had emerged was in no shape or desire to put an end to that. It was not so much that society took its revenge which is condemnable but understandable but that the state and its ruling elite participated in that irrespective of every consideration and the privileged few drew their power and immunity from the state itself.
The process of constructing who we are had began.
* * *
If BKSAL was cynical, the acts by Zia including the rehab of Jamaat-e-Islami are at least the same. If BKSAL was an attempt to hang on to power through whatever means including the brutal and despotic, the coalition of anti-1971 elements to prop Zia up was no less. One wonders how Zia had talked, discussed and considered that this was a fine price to pay for staying in power. He had seen everything in Chittagong and later in 1971 so what kind of a man allows all of that to disappear from his mind including the fact that he had personally fought them as he decides to pursue power.
Mujib had destroyed any trust people could have in the political process that people want by subverting them. He had displayed the adage that politics in the delta can often be driven by the instincts of a village that is unable to understand modernity. By failing to do that Mujib condemned Bangladesh to an endless spiral down.
He is always the first cause.
* * *
If Mujib was the platform Zia was the closer who initiated a process that destroyed whatever chance there may have been left of meaningful democratic governance. He legitimised political hatred and opportunism as a formula for staying in power. His lasting legacy has been the system of politics that accepts that to defeat one's enemy anything is justified. He fought for the birth of Bangladesh but in the process became one of its greatest destroyers. He was not the first cause only because he came after Mujib but in terms of his impact on the state, he is no less than anyone.
* * *
What was Ghulam Azam doing all this time? Well. He must have had some anxiety in the early days of Bangladesh but once it got going and the main themes of the new state were exposed he must have relaxed. Not only was Bangladesh cruel to the poor but it was corrupt as well. It was not only mean about power sharing but despotic too. BKSAL made his smile wider and Zia's welcome speech must have drawn his laughter.
Is he embarrassed when the greatest political debate of the country is about a non-existent theme such as who declared the independence when the state itself is a fait accompli? This debate does refer to the notion of entitlement beyond accountability. The declarer can claim the state in full.
After all, they have both come to power numerous times so seeking power can't be a point. It is about how much one can seek if the declarer's rights are undisputed.
* * *
As Ghulam Azam smiles, he must wonder if they will be able to prove the much more difficult process of trying him and colleagues for crimes against humanity given that they failed to cancel his citizenship in court and that too by the same government. It is going to be difficult because the prospect of an acquittal is too traumatic to contemplate for everyone including the government while a bad trial will draw global condemnation and payback prices. When there was time and history with them, nothing was done.
* * *
Ghulam Azam smiles but it is also good for him to remember that he is loyal to a state which is the greatest failure in state making ever. It exists in the imagination of a small group, in Pakistan and the US, more about the need to fight the Taliban. It exists because the extremists do and not because it serves the people. The army is the guarantor of the state of Pakistan, not its people. You can't get worse than that.
Pakistan in each of the narratives is the most failed state ever. Perhaps, believing that the state can solve society's problems by coming into existence is a false notion that the two siblings, now know. Bangladesh, by following the Pakistan model too has failed to deliver.
The tragedy lies in the misbegotten idea that a whimsical state can also function, without figuring out the price as it happened in 1947.
History's great tragedy is that our destinies are laid out long before tragedy strikes.