Published : 03 Oct 2010, 07:35 PM
Updated : 21 Jun 2022, 08:38 PM
Bangladesh politics is not exactly modern. A quick glance shows that the culture of power grabbing is close to that of the 'char dakhal' or land grabbing mode rather than a political process. The environment is more reminiscent of two groups in a village fighting for a char. The result is what we have got in the name of national politics. If one tries to understand it through the lenses of a modern nation-state one will be totally puzzled. However, drawing parallels with village political pattern makes understanding possible.
* * *
The imagination of a village as a paradise haunts us. Writers and myth makers always refer to the villages as a bountiful beautiful rural environment where there is peace, plenty and happiness; nowadays they cite the reference of sanitary toilets as well. No wonder that Jibanando Das and his iconic 'Rupashi bangla' which hymns in praise of an idyllic village life is the epitome of this thinking.
Tagore's poems are all about rural/village life and even the national anthem is constructed around an ideal that is not about values or beliefs but a rural fantasy. We hug it so deeply because in the end, we feel comfortable in village memories, of our own or that of our ancestors. The city is always imagined as negative, cruel, heartless and full of apartments instead of huts, kunre ghar.
No wonder so many go to the villages during Eid.
* * *
Anxiety about the city has played a profound role in imaging our politics. Cities demand accommodation, acceptance and a system that is evolved to ensure mutual survival of the many forces that come to live in the urban space and fight each other.
The villages need no such mechanism. They are full of people of one kind, mostly one's relatives and kinsmen. There are of course the other people and they are the enemies, the hated ones. They are the ones with whom no connections 'sammondho' can be made, there can be nothing good about them and any chance of killing them is never lost.
It doesn't matter if that animosity hurts everyone in the village. Sounds familiar?
* * *
Our national politics follows this pattern. Our political parties behave like village factions and the leaders talk and behave like matbars. Faction leaders in villages never rebuke their followers because they may turn against them or worse, join the other faction. Nor does our leaders to their own kind.
The shalish functions as the judiciary and the composition of the shalish is made up of factions and is not merit based.
There are no parliaments in a village and the closest one has to it is the tea-stall.
The village chowkidar is the village's principal public servant or executive functions at the will of the shalish and not the villagers.
The identity of villagers is subsumed into the village factions and tarafs, not the village.
This is how villages are run. How is Bangladesh run?
* * *
Without stretching the point too far, is there any difference with the national scene? Our national leaders were mostly village bred and they carried their culture into the national scene. The children of our leaders are also constructed around the same value bases and have continued that village mentality into national politics.
If our parliament has failed to function since 1972, the answer is not in the lack of intent of politicians but their lack of familiarity with institutions that doesn't exist in a village. So how can our politicians function within that? The idea that two parties/factions can work together is not a rural or village concept which is why as soon as one group comes to power, the other refuses to cooperate. The hostility notion is thousand years old.
The participation dynamics of a village is different from an urban construct. How can a parliament or legislature function in a dominantly rural environment like ours? Unlike the city where engagement with the 'enemy' is part of the modern culture of survival and development, villages never forget shotruta.
* * *
Villagers are more familiar with the shalish which may be why so many of our politicians are lawyers too. In the imagination of the villagers, a lawyer knows so much, can negotiate with the outside world and is absolutely essential to make chor or jomi dakhal halal. He is the one who manipulates in the best interest of the leader. The villagers both fear him and need him.
Which is why the politicians are keener about going to courts than establish a rule of law regime. Law in villages don't exist to further a legal regime. They exist to ensure supremacy. This is one reason why the obsession with judges and their appointment and not the upholding the law.
* * *
The chowkidar is not loyal to the village but to the leaders in most cases. Like our executive, he is a prisoner of adesh. Bureaucrats are criticised as being pro one faction or another. Leading factions in a village are happy only when someone from their group holds this post.
To the chowkidar has been added the village mastan. He exists to establish the rule of the matbar.
Our executive is expected to be a part chowkidar and a part mastan. In the larger village there is no large scale executive and that is why our politicians can't relate to the idea of a neutral bureaucratic structure.
How can our politicians handle such an institution and even more so, an idea that is so foreign to a rural mind?
* * *
In practice no modern nation-state has been born as Bangladesh — a large cluster of villages put under a common flag. The concept of jati and samaj is common in villages which is why our nation is so stridently elusive.
As long as the village mentality reigns there will not be any sign of modern governance quite simply because this is not a modern state. It's a modern village state.
Which is why it's so grossly unfair to expect our politicians to behave as modern rulers when they have managed to retain their prime identity of geramer manush.