November 20, 2026

What if Jill was Jack?

Published : 04 Jun 2014, 09:13 PM

Updated : 21 Jun 2022, 08:30 PM

Image
Photo: Reuters

In my childhood as I sang along to the popular verses from the classic nursery rhyme "Jack and Jill," I could sense that Jack is favoured over Jill, by their mother. In those innocent lyrics, there was an underlying bias against Jill. When Jack went up the hill, he fell all the way down, and Jill came tumbling after. Consequently their mother whipped Jill's knee as she was laughing at Jack's disaster. I thought it was rather unfair that Jill got punished just for laughing. Today's big story is not about the reverse roles of the imaginary Jack and Jill. It is about one real life Jill, and her very discriminatory treatment and humiliation, which were orchestrated by her male boss that became very public. The question many people are asking is: what if Jill was Jack? Would he have faced such fate?

I am of course referring to Jill Abramson, the recently ousted first female executive editor of The New York Times.

As many of you have read, Jill did not fall down as she was taking the stairs of her office building.  Rather she was pushed out from her office by Arthur Sulzberger Jr., publisher and the chairman of The New York Times Company. After her long and storied career at the Times, within hours of her firing, her name was taken off the masthead of NY Times. All the years of service, that won four Pulitzers under her editorship, were erased with a single key stroke.

Why was Jill really given the pink slip, just after serving three years as the Times' executive editor?

Many reports have emerged and insightful pieces were written, since the announcement came, about how and why she could be fired from a job that she loved. The preliminary reports focused on gender and many other workplace issues, and why she wasn't loved by her co-workers. In many media reports she was called to be "bossy," "brusque," "condescending," and "polarizing." Some reports said Abramson made it very difficult to work with her in the newsroom; her strictness drove some of the journalists crazy. Some found her unpleasant, and the junior editors were afraid to talk to her fearing rebuff. A few of her staffers even complained about the sound of her voice which they found irritating.

The matter of her unpopularity further escalated when Jill asked her lawyer to inquire about her pay and pension disparity. She found out that her salary was less than that of several male predecessors. Naturally she raised questions about such double standards, and the boss man didn't like that. In the midst of all the complaints, and Jill's demand for pay raise, were seen by Sulzberger as fireable offences.

Two days prior to her dismissal, Sulzberger had dinner with Dean Baquet, the paper's managing editor. There Baquet told his publisher that it was becoming increasingly difficult to work with Jill, and informed him of a job offer by Bloomberg News. To avoid negative publicity by losing Baquet to another news agency, Sulzberger took a huge gamble. Perhaps he decided it is better to get rid of Abramson, and appoint Baquet as her replacement, so that it doesn't reflect too badly on him.

During her tenure at the Times, all of Jill Abramson's attributes were magnified because she was the first female editor of the Times, a position so far held by men only. A lot of senior male editors like Baquet, saw her as a rival. Some of Jill supporters, mainly the female journalists at the Times looked up to Jill as a role model. They feel that it was Sulzberger himself, who failed to uphold the high standards of the paper by being a bad manager. In their protest they are justified in labelling him as "gross," and "sexist."

Though I didn't know Jill Abramson in a professional setting — how can the media portrayal of her be so different from the person I knew a few years back?

I first saw Abramson at Sidwell Friends School in Washington, DC, in a fall afternoon of 1997. She came into the office of the academic dean holding hands with her daughter, to try out for one of the four spaces that were open for the next academic year. We were a small group of parents waiting in the hallway, as our children were called one after another for the high school entrance interview. Except for the shared collective anxiety, and friendly nods, most of us were thinking whether our children will impress the teachers enough to secure one of the spots.

Since that day, I had seen Jill many times, over the course of the next four years, as we attended the same school functions, and athletic events. There we were just two mothers, who shared a common goal-pushing our daughters to be high achievers. Whenever I saw her, we had exchanged simple pleasantries about our kids; we complimented one another for a job well done, in guiding our children. At the time Jill was working for the NY Times in its Washington bureau. She however, only struck me as a typical loving and caring mother, unpretentious, unassuming, without any air of arrogance about her.

Last I saw Jill was in 2001, on the day of the high school graduation ceremony, sipping fruit punch, with all the other parents. After that I along with everyone else, heard that she got a promotion and moved to the head office, in New York City. Later I had read that she sued some Limousine company, after one of the cars almost ran her over while crossing the street. Then news came that she has become the first female executive editor of the NY Times.

Up until now, I was totally oblivious to the fact that thirteen years on, I will be dedicating a column to her.

Abramson, a highly educated veteran journalist in her own rights, "who brought gender parity to the NYT masthead," is worthy of applause for caring about good old fashioned journalism. She built her name, "as a smart and tough editor," with a "deep passion for the institution and deep appreciation of why it mattered."  She was unwilling to compromise her journalistic principles, much like Katherine Graham (publisher of the Washington Post.)  Jill's ideas started to clash with NY Times' management mainly with CEO Mark Thompson, over "business side versus edit." She ended NY Times.com as an independent operation, and "made all the reporting through print," which the digital people found objectionable. She wanted to keep journalism in its purest form but they saw it as her refusal to change with the modern era. Her "stubbornness," and not wanting to adapt to the change of time, made her very unpopular in the Times family.

Sometimes for questioning her editors about "why the Times did not have certain stories," were taken as a sign of her being too "pushy," and "demanding," by her colleagues. It is a fair question to ask: if it was one Jack calling the shots, would he be considered tough? Or would he be considered an assertive and a very successful boss? Do people think that Abramson should have downplayed her confidence to please others? Perhaps if she should have acted nicer, she might have been perceived as too nice.  Either way the cards were stacked high against her. For example, take last year's vicious Politico article which detailed an altercation between her and Dean Baquet. In that article she was described as "bitchy" and "very unpopular." I had read the report shook her to the core, and made her cry.

In running a news enterprise like The New York Times, lately Abramson mostly got criticisms instead of effusive praise for a job well done. No surprise there- as it often happens with women in high position. They regularly become targets of unfair decisions that are gender, and race based. Conflict of personalities with a highly prejudiced management, was the reason for her unfortunate and untimely departure from the Times. Abramson, a highly ethical journalist, with enormous integrity and self-awareness, will not vanish into thin air, just because Arthur Sulzberger banished her from the Times premises. He acted like a tyrant, and failed to show Jill any decorum, only saying, "It is time for change." Suffice it to say if Jill was Jack, then the story would have a different ending.

————————————–

Zeenat Khan writes from Maryland, USA

Related Stories