Published : 10 Aug 2021, 05:48 PM
Updated : 21 Jun 2022, 08:16 PM
Home in the World;
A Memoir
Amartya Sen
Allen Lane
An imprint of Penguin Books
Amartya Sen takes us on journeys all the way to an intellectually endowed horizon. For people who belong to his generation as also the one which followed his, Home in the World is a recapitulation of the ideas which dominated the world in the 1940s and all the way to the decades which followed. In a very broad sense, the work is a wallowing in nostalgia. At another and more significant level, it is Sen's own world, as he recaptures it in memory land. He speaks of the vibrant place of rivers in the Bengali imagination, in the literature of Bengal. His schooling in Dhaka, at the remarkable institution which St Gregory's School has always been, is an emphasis which the writer carefully and certainly deliberately throws the reader's way.
Of course, all of that is prior to the cataclysm of partition that would rend India asunder. The essence of the work is simple: it is a tour de force, moving as it does in ways that cannot but portray Sen as a citizen of the world. He has always held on to his Indian passport, has never been tempted to seek citizenship of the countries he has taught and worked in; and through his roots in India he has observed the world in expansive terms. There are the years he spends in the liberality of Santiniketan, where his young mind expanded into a landscape of thoughts that has always been the definition of the scholar in Amartya Sen. On the day Rabindranath Tagore dies, Sen's mother is emotionally shaken; and he explains to his sister, younger than him, that the poet is gone. The girl, in all her innocence, reassures him that Rabindranath will come back.
The memoir is evocative of Bengali life, be it Hindu or Muslim, which has traditionally underpinned heritage in Bengal, both parts of it, with all the linkages between the generations. Grandparents and parents form the core, or series of images which, to go back to Eliot, are the roots that clutch. Sen focuses on the intellectual aspects of his family, informing readers of the academic his father was at Dhaka University, of the influence of his grandfather Kshiti Mohan on his young life and which was to be a lasting experience for him.
At Presidency College in Calcutta, Sen does what generations of young Bengalis, straddling academic life and intellectual wanderings, have always done best. That was the search for politics, for Marxism as such in more instances than one. At the nearby coffee house, conversation interspersed with debate followed, with Sen's being a vital presence. It would of course be prudent to argue that he did not see Marxism the way others among his friends saw it, but that those discussions had a crucial role in the formulation of his economic prognostications is a factor not to be ignored.
Economics and Marxism apart, politics forms a necessary component of the work. Sen dwells, as his generation pretty regularly has, on the Bengal famine of 1943 and its grave fallout. He does not forget the sheer callousness with which the Churchill government in distant London kept news of the tragedy from his people in the United Kingdom. Worse, the manner in which the media in colonial India stayed clear of reporting on the crisis comes in for condemnation. Sen is scathing in his criticism of The Statesman and the role of its editor Ian Stephens, who 'voluntarily chose a policy of not discussing the famine in the interest of solidarity for the war effort — though it did publish some sad photos of starving people, without commentary or explanation.' Not until October 1943 would Stephens, with a troubled conscience, revolt and go for an exposure of the reality.
The images of famished people would spur Amartya Sen into serious reflections and later concrete formulations of ideas on the means through which hunger would not have to be part of life. As he puts it: 'The nightmare of the Bengal famine began to generate a determination in me to do what I could to prevent famines from occurring ever again.' It was to be in the 1970s that Sen would go for analyses of famines. But that academic journey would be undertaken long after a tragedy unfolding before the Sen family. The scene is Dhaka, the setting is Jagat Kutir, the Sen residence, the time is 1944. A poverty-stricken Muslim day labourer, Kader Mia, knifed in the back and front by communal elements on his way home after he had done some work in a neighbouring house, ran for safety into the Sen home. He asked for water. Rushed to hospital by the writer's father, Kader Mia did not survive. The experience was searing for the eleven year-old Amartya Sen.
The trajectory of Sen's life is of an individual grounded in a secular philosophy, the philosophy again being a set of values nurtured and handed down by his family. He recalls the friendships he made with Muslims in Dhaka, Calcutta and at Santinketan, ties that would deepen as he travelled abroad in the 1950s. At Trinity, Cambridge, he made his acquaintance with Rehman Sobhan, subsequently a leading economist and participant in Bangladesh's War of Liberation. Anecdotes about Sen's interactions with his fellow students and teachers abound in Home. He and Rehman Sobhan engage in a Cambridge-Oxford debate with Kamal Hossain, a future Bangladesh foreign minister, at Oxford (Sen is mistaken in referring to Hossain as Bangladesh's first foreign minister, though). On his way to England from Calcutta to pursue studies at Cambridge, Sen spots the young and graceful Romila Thapar on the ship they were both travelling on. Thapar, destined to be one of the foremost of historians in India, was for Sen a picture of beauty in the easy way in which she danced. Observe Sen reflecting on Thapar: 'She combined her rapidly growing intellectual reputation with other talents: her elegant lifestyle, including her skillful ballroom dancing.'
At Cambridge, Sen's friendships were all a foretelling of the years to be. His early meetings with Mahbub ul Haq, who would play an important role in shaping Pakistan's economy as well as formulating a globally acclaimed human development report, were the beginning of a lifelong friendship. And then there was the suave Kaiser Murshed, who too was on that ship bound for England and Oxbridge. A Bengali from East Pakistan who would subsequently serve as a diplomat in Pakistan and in post-1971 Bangladesh, Murshed rather surprised Sen on the ship with the question, 'Would you care for some chocolate?' That set Sen thinking. 'Care for' was a turn of phrase he was not used to, for after Bengali and Sanskrit, as he notes, English was his third language. He was not sure if Murshed wanted his opinion of the chocolate or he was being offered a piece of it. But that was how a deep friendship commenced on a ship making its way to English shores.
At Cambridge, Sen's world expands into an ever-widening universe of possibilities. James Meade, Dennis Robertson, Maurice Dobb, Piero Sraffa, Clare Royce and Lal Jayawardena people his canvas and with time these links and friendships branch out into critical analyses of economic realities or evolving foundations of economic perspectives on the part of a creative generation that would have an instrumental role in the times to be. Poignant is the way in which Sen reflects on the student intake of 1955, with special focus on the brilliant Dharma Kumar, the economic historian then doing research on Indian agrarian history. Sen saw Kumar for the last time in 2001, by which time a brain tumour had left her physically and mentally impaired. Kumar stared at Sen with what seemed like recognition, but no words came from the individual whose ability to make quick judgments as also her brashness in her younger days had deeply impressed Sen.
The memoir is replete with recollections of the openings, in terms of writing for journals, that education in India and England was to give the young Sen. They would all be the touchstones to an acclaimed career, early on inaugurated through Sen's return to Calcutta and taking up a teaching assignment at Jadavpur University. There would be Harvard and MIT and the Delhi School of Economics; there would be his interactions with philosophers, a prominent one being C.D. Broad at Trinity. Impressed by Broad's The Mind and Its Place in Nature, Sen wondered if Broad could advise him on what he could read and also take a look at some of his essays. Broad's positive response cheered Sen, whose study of Isaiah Berlin's writings too found a place in his philosophical repertoire.
Sen's reflections on Nabaneeta Dev, to whom he became engaged in 1959, gladden the soul. They married in 1960, but, as Sen states, the 'marriage sadly ended in divorce in 1973.' That the marriage was a profoundly intellectual partnership, that they were a power couple is the image that has dominated the public mind. Amartya Sen gives readers an insight into Nabaneeta Dev's scholarly background: in 1956, when Sen taught at Jadavpur University, Dev was into studies of comparative literature at the same institution. Awarded a Fellowship by Indiana University in 1959, she stopped over in England, visiting Oxford and Cambridge with Sen. Subsequently they would spend the year 1960-61 in the United States pursuing their separate courses, with Sen teaching and Dev working on oral epic poetry under Professor A.B. Lord.
Amartya Sen's thoughts on Gautama Buddha, Karl Marx, Adam Smith and Rabindranath Tagore along with his observations on Keynesian economics are food for reflection on the part of the reader. He stresses Smith's humanitarian approach to life, quoting the economic philosopher:
'There is not a negro from the coast of Africa who does not, in this respect, possess a degree of magnanimity which the soul of his sordid master is too often scarce capable of conceiving.'
In a world where the divide between affluence and poverty widens, where politics is seemingly incapable of ensuring the welfare of humankind as Sen obviously sees it, it is Tagore he goes back to as a supplement to Adam Smith. Sen recalls Tagore's last public lecture, delivered in 1941:
'The best and noblest gifts of humanity cannot be the monopoly of a particular race or country; its scope may not be limited nor may it be regarded as the miser's hoard buried underground.'
Home in the World is the world Amartya Sen constructs within the home of the mind, for his readers. It is a reassuring world, despite the crass mediocrity of the times we happen to be plodding through.