Democratic U.S. presidential nominee Hillary Clinton walks off the debate stage as Republican U.S. presidential nominee Donald Trump remains at his podium after the conclusion of their third and final 2016 presidential campaign debate at UNLV in Las Vegas, Nevada, U.S., October 19, 2016. REUTERS/Rick Wilking
Published : 09 Nov 2016, 11:00 AM
Updated : 21 Jun 2022, 08:26 PM
Irony has been a staple of American politics for as long as one can remember. As you wait for the final results of the 2016 presidential elections to come in – as you read this, the votes are still being counted and both the Clinton and Trump camps bite their nails in anxious waiting – you cannot but reflect on all the moments of irony which have defined this year's campaign.
The first irony is one of an experienced nominee, in this case Hillary Clinton, being pitted against an absolutely non-political and one would say naïve candidate, the candidate being Donald Trump, in the race for the White House. Again, for the very first time in American history, it is a woman who seeks the presidency. She battles a man who has in these past eighteen months done everything he could to denigrate women in a variety of ways.
Think back on the presidential election of 2004. Senator John Kerry sought the Democratic nomination for President against President George W. Bush, the Republican incumbent. He got it and then went on to lose to Bush. In the second Obama administration, Kerry came in as Secretary of State. Today, we have Hillary Clinton, who did the reverse: she moved from being Secretary of State to being the Democratic presidential nominee.
For Clinton, the irony does not quite end here. She is, in living memory, the first Secretary of State who has won the nomination of a major political party for presidential office. In our times, we have been witness to presidential candidates who have, prior to taking up their parties' banners at the election, been Governors of states, Senators, Vice Presidents, former Vice Presidents and former Governors. Hillary Clinton has thus set a new record for herself. She has broken the glass ceiling in more ways than one.
Not that all instances of irony have been strange or unexpected, though. Think back on Abraham Lincoln. His election to the White House in 1860 was preceded by some of the harshest attacks made on a candidate in US history up to that point in time. And many of the men who were trying to do him in were politicians from his own party. Yet – and here is the good side of irony – once Lincoln won the election, he roped those men into being part of his cabinet. It was a team of rivals, something that Obama emulated somewhat when he brought Hillary Clinton into his administration as Secretary of State in 2009.
Observe all the other ironies. In 1956, John F. Kennedy, the young Senator from Massachusetts, desperately wished to be Adlai Stevenson's running mate on the Democratic ticket. In the event, it was Senator Estes Kefauver who got the slot. Then the Stevenson-Kefauver team went on to lose to the Republican ticket of Eisenhower-Nixon. Here is the irony: once Kennedy himself was elected President in 1960, Stevenson hoped that he would be appointed Secretary of State in the new administration. Kennedy did not oblige him. It was Dean Rusk who got the job. Stevenson was sent off to the United Nations as America's Permanent Representative in the global organisation. Stevenson stayed in that job till 1965, when he collapsed on a London street and died.
Some of the more prominent of ironies have come to be associated with Richard Nixon. After eight years as Vice President under President Dwight Eisenhower, he sought the White House in 1960 but went on to lose narrowly, by a mere 500,000 votes, to John F. Kennedy. In 1962, he was the Republican nominee for Governor of California. He needed to stay in the political limelight. But misfortune was once more his. He lost to incumbent Governor Edmund G. 'Pat' Brown and then angrily told the media that he was bidding farewell to politics. Well, of course, he did not do that. He wrote a book called 'Six Crises', penned articles on foreign policy, travelled around the world and met heads of government and in 1966 played a major role in helping Republicans win seats in Congress. By late 1968, in an America exhausted by the war in Vietnam, Nixon, once more the Republican nominee for President, had beaten the Democrats' candidate, Vice President Hubert Humphrey, by a thin margin to enter the White House. Nixon won re-election by a landslide against Senator George McGovern in 1972. Ironically, less than two years later, he was forced to resign in the wake of the Watergate scandal. He spent the remaining twenty years of his life travelling and writing well-acclaimed books on diplomacy.
And, yes, irony was part of Humphrey's political life too. In 1960, he sought the Democratic presidential nomination but opted out of the race after losing to John Kennedy in the primaries. In 1964, President Lyndon Johnson, who had been Vice President under Kennedy, chose him as his running mate. The two men achieved a whopping victory over the Republican team of Senator Barry Goldwater and Congressman William Miller. Goldwater went back to the Senate and served as a distinguished lawmaker for years. Ten years later, the responsibility of giving President Nixon the bad news that he had to quit the White House or face impeachment over Watergate was entrusted to Goldwater by his colleagues. A significant irony around Goldwater was that he was accused in the 1964 campaign by Democrats as a man who would lead America into trouble around the globe; and yet it would ironically be Johnson who would take the country down the road to disaster in Vietnam through his escalation of the war.
No one expected Harry Truman, when he became Vice President under Franklin Delano Roosevelt at the 1944 election, to take over as President. But Roosevelt died in April 1945, only weeks into his fourth term in the White House. Truman, as his successor, dropped the atomic bomb over Hiroshima and Nagasaki. In 1948, new irony was played out when almost everyone expected New York Governor Thomas Dewey, who had earlier lost to Roosevelt in 1944, to beat Truman at the election. Dewey went to sleep convinced he would wake up the next morning as America's new President. When dawn broke, it was a reversal of fortunes Dewey was confronted with. Truman had defeated him. Speaking of fortunes, Gerald Ford certainly harboured no ambitions of being President. But in the increasingly sleazy politics of the America of the early 1970s, when he was House Minority leader, he was named Vice President by President Nixon in succession to a disgraced Spiro Agnew. Only months later, in August 1974, Ford had another promotion: this time he took over as President from a badly burnt Nixon. He lost the White House to former Georgia Governor Jimmy Carter at the 1976 election and in 1980 was keen on being Ronald Reagan's running mate against the Carter-Mondale team. The former Governor of California rebuffed him and chose George H.W. Bush as his number two.
Irony abounds in American politics. Both Michigan Governor George Romney, in 1968, and his son Mitt Romney, the former Governor of Massachusetts, in 2012, sought the presidency. Neither achieved his ambition. The older Romney, a clear Republican frontrunner in late 1967, went visiting US troops in Vietnam and came back home gushing about their positive role in combating communism. Weeks later, he went public with his comment that senior US military officers had brainwashed him on his Vietnam trip. He now thought the war was not going well for America. His poll ratings plummeted fast. He was later to serve in Richard Nixon's cabinet as Housing and Urban Development Secretary. Gaffes have destroyed the presidential aspirations of other men as well. In 1972, Senator Edmund Muskie was the man Democrats looked to as the candidate who could beat Nixon. But then Muskie, upset at adverse comments on his wife Jane in the media, broke down in tears in public (though he later said it was the snow melting down his face). His presidential ambitions went up in smoke. He would, years later, serve as Secretary of State in the final phase of Jimmy Carter's presidency.
Senator Eugene McCarthy's strong showing in the New Hampshire primary in early 1968 compelled President Lyndon Johnson to forgo a second term in the White House. McCarthy's performance led to Senator Robert F. Kennedy's jumping into the fray and quickly overtaking McCarthy in a number of primaries. In June 1968, when Kennedy was assassinated in Los Angeles moments after winning the California primary, Vice President Humphrey waded into the race. McCarthy fought on, but to little avail. Humphrey got the Democratic nomination. And, yes, in 1964, Robert Kennedy, who had served as Attorney General in his brother's cabinet, expected to be Lyndon Johnson's running mate. When his hopes did not materialize, he sought and won election to the US Senate from New York. It was a seat that was later to be held by Hillary Clinton.
Finally, there are all those men who in the past set their sights on the White House but did not actually gain the right to occupy it. Joe Biden, today Vice President under Obama, sought the Democratic presidential nomination in 1988. He quit the race after allegations of plagiarism surfaced against him. His speeches up to that point on the campaign trail had been purloined from the late Robert Kennedy.
As America prepares to elect its next President today, indeed in a matter of hours, the names of William Scranton, Nelson Rockefeller, Harold Stassen, Stuart Symington, George Wallace, Jesse Jackson and Gary Hart come to mind. They were all men of ambition who wished to be President. America's voters had other thoughts, though.