November 20, 2026

Genocide – thoughts about 1971 and 2019

Published : 25 Oct 2019, 05:03 AM

Updated : 21 Jun 2022, 09:52 PM

I always feel emotional whenever I write about genocide and Bangladesh's Liberation War. It brings back many memories of the period when I was a young man in Calcutta in 1971!

As far as genocide is concerned, I grew up in London during the years immediately after the end of the Second World War and learnt about the genocide which Hitler of Nazi Germany ordered in his attempt to exterminate the Jewish people. My father had been at university with a number of Jewish friends, so many graphic details emerged about the Holocaust when I was quite young. However, until 2016, I had never been asked to specifically speak or write about genocide. In a way, for many years I did not talk about my 1971 experiences at all. They were so painful; I had kept them hidden away. It was only in 2007 during a chance visit to the Liberation War Museum that I felt able to talk about my experiences of 1971.

A couple of years ago I attended a Planning Commission seminar about Extreme Poverty and in the address by one of the officials; I learnt, then, that 76% of the current population are less than 40 years old and may not know the accurate history regarding the formation of this country. I am regularly asked to write about my memories of 1971 and when I have expressed that I found it difficult to write the same things year after year, Bangladeshis of my age and older tell me that I must keep on writing as it is important that the people of this country are reminded again and again about the true history of the period before, during and after the Liberation War.

For someone who witnessed the birth of Bangladesh, it is painful and difficult to understand there are some who deny that any genocide took place. Whenever, someone tells me this or I read this, I become very angry indeed and also incredulous. I remember families of Bangladeshis – Hindus and Muslims – coming in a traumatized state across the border to access some of the over 900 refugee camps. Men, women and children of all ages, struck dumb by the horror of seeing some of their loved ones murdered before they managed to escape. I remember being in a hospital in Krishnanagar, West Bengal, in June 1971 at the same time as an international reporter from, I believe, Newsweek. I remember this young girl in a colourful dress and this is how the reporter recorded our meeting with this girl who was about 10 years old:

The story of one shy little girl in a torn pink dress with red and green bows has a peculiar horror. She could not have been a danger to anyone. Yet I met her in a hospital in Krishnanagar, hanging nervously back among the other patients, her hand covering the livid scar on her neck where a Pakistani soldier had cut her throat with his bayonet. "I am Ismatar, the daughter of the late Ishaque Ali," she said formally. "My father was a businessman in Kushtia. About two months ago he left our house and went to his shop and I never saw him again. That same night after I went to bed, I heard shouts and screaming, and when I went to see what was happening, the Punjabi soldiers were there. My four sisters were lying dead on the floor, and I saw that they had killed my mother. While I was there they shot my brother – he was a bachelor of science. Then a soldier saw me and stabbed me with his knife. I fell to the floor and played dead. When the soldiers left I ran and a man picked me up on his bicycle and I was brought here." Suddenly, as if she could no longer bear to think about her ordeal, the girl left the room. The hospital doctor was explaining to me that she was brought to the hospital literally soaked in her own blood, when she pushed her way back through the patients and stood directly in front of me. "What am I to do?" she asked. "Once I had five sisters and a brother and a father and mother. Now I have no family. I am an orphan. Where can I go? What will happen to me?

Perhaps it is necessary to remind people about what happened in 1971 and for the members of the younger generation it is important to accurately inform them of the genocide unleashed by the Pakistani army and their collaborators. Because of 'Operation Searchlight', 10 million refugees came to India, most of them living in appalling conditions in the refugee camps. I cannot forget seeing 10 children fight for one chapati. I cannot forget the child queuing for milk, vomiting, collapsing and dying of cholera. I cannot forget the woman lying in the mud, groaning and giving birth.

We had heard of the genocide from the night of Mar 25. A bloodbath followed of hideous proportions. Thousands and upon thousands, including women and children, were rounded up and shot, machine-gunned or bayoneted and the women were raped. From Mar 25 to 31, it was estimated that about 200,000 Bengalis had been killed. An Italian priest living in Jessore at the time told me that in Jessore itself about 10,000 had been killed in the 10 days after Mar 25.

An example of the genocide was described by Dan Coggin of Time magazine. He wrote, "One couple tells how soldiers took their two grown sons outside the house, bayoneted them in the stomach and refused to allow anyone to go near the bleeding boys, who died hours later."

However, what about the actual numbers? By end of May 1971, I remember a Dhaka University professor, Samir Paul, who was, as a refugee, helping us to organize camp activities, telling me that, till then, it was estimated that one million Bengalis had been killed inside Bangladesh until that time (May 1971).

It is very clear to me that many Bangladeshis died on their way to India and many more died after coming to the refugee camps as a result of the injuries and wounds suffered on the way. I saw people with bullet wounds and bayonet wounds and some of them did not manage to survive.

It is also important also to record the different forms of genocide. I heard of an incident at Haluaghat, Sherpur which was also recorded by one of the Newsweek correspondents at the time. "Young men of the village were called together by a Pakistani Army major and he said that his wounded soldiers urgently needed blood. Would they be donors? The young men lay down on makeshift cots, needles were inserted in their veins-and then slowly the blood was drained from their bodies and they died."  Newsweek's Tony Clifton, a recipient of the 'Friends of Liberation War Honour', wrote "The refugees stand patiently, calf deep in stagnant water, eager to tell me their stories so I can tell others. I collect a notebook of horror-rape and murder and kidnapping. They tell me how they saw their children stabbed, their husbands or brothers executed, their wives collapse with fatigue or sickness. The stories are all new, and all the same."

Now, 47 years after the emergence of Bangladesh, it is vitally important that the world authorities officially accept and recognize that what happened in Bangladesh in 1971 was genocide. There are many eye witness accounts that have

been documented. For example, the powerful writing of Anthony Mascarenhas who visited East Pakistan in April 1971 (his writing, entitled 'GENOCIDE', published June 13, 1971 by The Sunday Times).

The May 22, 1971 editorial of US publication, 'Saturday Review' entitled 'Genocide in East Pakistan'. And the British magazine, 'The Spectator' in its issue of June 19, 1971, in an article entitled, 'Another Final Solution' had the following:

"We, in this country, like to think that among the reasons why we fought the Germans in the last war was to rid the world of the evil of Hitler and his gang and their genocidal, 'final solution.' It is easier to imagine Germany's gas chambers than Pakistan's cholearic slaughter in the Bengal Plain, but it remains the case and it ought to be declared that the Pakistani crime now matches the Hitlerian in dimension and horror and threatens monstrously to exceed it. Difficult and unpleasant though it may be, each one of us ought to endeavour to the best of his ability to imagine the enormity of the Pakistani crime."

John Pilger, in 1971 with the Daily Mirror, wrote, while explaining the attitude of the West to the genocide in Bangladesh:

"Usually we in the West, who are rich, can dismiss or rationalize famine, unexpected disaster and even mass extermination by simply noting that the poor, who are characterized by the people of Bangladesh, are numerous and ought to be pruned. If only, we say, they could organize their own resources and subscribe to decent, Western politics. Surely they are expendable. We even allow ourselves a good snigger at places crying out against odds we cannot comprehend; places like the Congo and the ravaged republic of the Americas. None has followed the Western wisdom of democracy; and so they must suffer. A pity.

Bangla Desh has called our bluff. The people of what was East Pakistan, who represented the majority of the state of Pakistan, voted to be a democracy and to be led by moderate middle-class Western-styled politicians. Foolishly perhaps, they chose our way in their pursuit of freedom, in spite of problems we have never had to face.

And for this reason alone, they are being exterminated and enslaved in a manner reminiscent of Adolf Hitler, over whom the world went to war. But, of course, he was exterminating Europeans.

We in the West have no intention of going to war over Bangladesh. Instead through our elected government, we have contributed what amounts to one week's survival pocket money to the refugees of Bangladesh, now petrified in India. India must provide the rest."

Fast Forward to Rohingya Refugees of 2019

I write these few lines not long after the 2nd anniversary of the beginning of the arrival of hundreds of Rohingya refugees from Rakhine State of Myanmar. Having been responsible, in 1971, for the humanitarian needs of about 600,000 Bangladeshi refugees, in over 50 Oxfam-supported refugee camps in all the States bordering India and Bangladesh and having visited the Rohingya Refugee Camps in Cox's Bazar District, I am often asked about my extensive feelings, what I think should be done and how I see the future for these people from the Rakhine State.

In 1971 we knew that all the refugees from Bangladesh wished to return to their homes in Bangladesh after the fighting ceased. They wanted to return home. In actual fact they returned home much quicker than we expected and all the refugees had returned to Bangladesh by the end of February 1972. The Rohingyas do not feel the same way at all. They have been systematically attacked, tortured and suffered humiliating discrimination on a regular basis since the independence from the British in 1948. There is a record of 21 such genocidal armed 'Clearance Operations' since that year. Why would they want to return 'home' to the Rakhine State without a lot of assurances? They know the situation and they will not consider going back until they have cast iron commitments and internationally guaranteed assurances.

Image
Fleeing Rohingyas watch from Bangladesh as their houses at Maungdaw in Rakhine State are set on fire allegedly by the Myanmar Army and other security forces on Sept 11, 2017. Photo: Mostafigur Rahman

I was very angry that when people (especially foreigners) started writing about the crisis two years ago, most of them did not do any proper historical research, even recent history. In early 1992, I attended a UNHCR meeting in Dhaka about a Rohingya influx at that time. 20 years ago, while working with the Red Cross, I had oversight of the Red Cross/Red Crescent work among about 30,000 refugees in Kutapalong and Nayapara camps. However, to understand things much more, one needs to go back many centuries at which time eastern Bengal had become a cauldron in which a mixture of different races had bubbled, boiled over, and occasionally quietly simmered.

Although Islam had touched the coastal areas of Bengal between the 8th and 12th centuries, it was in the 13th century when Muhammad Bakhtiyar established a Muslim ruled state, the first of many dominated by non-Bengalis, including Turks, North Indians, Afghans, Arakanese and Ethiopians.

In the 16th century Portuguese freebooters from Goa secured a foothold but, failing to found an empire, either entered service of the rajahs of Arakan as mercenaries or turned pirate. The struggle for supremacy between the Muslims and Buddhists came to a head in 1661 when the rajah of Arakan put to death the Mogul viceroy of Bengal who had sought refuge with him, leading to a punitive expedition which resulted in the whole Arakan district becoming a province of the Mogul empire. Chittagong for some time was known as Islamabad. And for a while the cauldron simmered, Muslim, Buddhist, Hindu and Catholic living an uneasy peace with one another.

The Burmese conquered Arakan in the 1780s which led to the arrival of refugees including many militants who then used the British territory as a base from which to launch counter-attacks against the Burmese occupying Arakan. When some sort of peace treaty had been agreed, Captain Cox had the task of looking after thirty to forty thousand refugees.

British policy encouraged Bengali inhabitants from adjacent regions to migrate into the then lightly populated and fertile valleys of Arakan as farm labourers. The East India Company extended the Bengal Presidency to Arakan. There was no international boundary between Bengal and Arakan and no restrictions on migration between the regions. In the early 19th century, thousands of Bengalis from the Chittagong region settled in Arakan seeking work. It is difficult to know whether these new Bengal migrants were the same population that was deported by force to Bengal's Chittagong during the Burmese conquest in the 18th century and later returned to Arakan as a result of British policy or they were a new migrant population with no ancestral roots to Arakan.

A great uncle of mine who lived and worked in Rangoon in the 1930s said that although a few Rohingya trace their ancestry to Muslims who lived in Arakan in the 15th and 16th centuries, most Rohingyas arrived with the British colonialists in the 19th and 20th centuries. I wonder how many people have taken the trouble to understand that for centuries the Burmese have wanted the Arakan Muslims out of Burma. It is not just something that has festered since Independence in 1948. Now, it seems, Chinese connected commercial interests are pushing state sponsored land-grabbing at a fast rate.

In late 2017, as a member of a Bangladesh 'Citizens' Commission for Investigating Genocide and Terrorism in Burma ', I visited the Kutapulong and Balukhali refugee camps at Teknaf. Collecting evidence that could be used in any submission to the International Criminal Court, we interviewed a number of refugees who had recently arrived in Cox's Bazar District. I remember that one man told us that:

– no new mosques could be built for the last 20 years

– they had not been able to pray in existing mosques for the last 5 years

– even in a village with 100 Muslim families and 5 Buddhist families, the village leader always has to be Buddhist

– children have not been able/allowed to go to school since August 25, 2017

– married couples are not allowed to have more than two children

– birth registration has not been done for the last few years

– the nearest health facility is 1.75 miles away but only Burmese Buddhists are seen there from 2015

– in 2010, he and his father were forced to vote (to give a semblance of 'democracy')

Although the Rohingya from Rakhine have no status, many of the Rohingya with whom I talked said they would go back to their homes in Rakhine State if they were convinced it would be safe, their land was restored to them and ownership was guaranteed and they were given Myanmar citizenship. A number of them said that they had brought their land documents with them and so could prove ownership. However, one old woman told me that this was the third time she had escaped persecution and certain death and come to Bangladesh as a refugee, and that this time she would refuse to go back to Rakhine State. It will, indeed, be very difficult to persuade many Rohingya to return to Rakhine State.

As demanded by the refugees, the pre-requisites for repatriation are:

– Recognition of the Rohingya as an indigenous ethnic minority of Myanmar

– Issuance of national identity cards to all Rohingya

– Lift all form of restrictions and harassments such as travel ban, marriage restriction, land and property confiscation, extortion, arbitrary arrest, forced ration collection for army etc.

– Stop building model villages and send back all model villagers to their original villages

– Return all confiscated lands and properties to the original owners

– Give assurance for religious freedom

– Give access for higher education and provide enough hospitals and medical facilities in northern Arakan.

The International Community has neglected the Rohingya problem for decades and now, with some countries blocking negotiations, the way ahead is uncertain to say the least. Severe sanctions should have been clamped down on Myanmar a long time ago. The Bangladesh Government has, in my opinion, been too polite in their negotiations with Myanmar. After the recent unsatisfactory UNHRC vote at the United Nations when China opposed the Bangladesh Prime Minister's resolution and Japan and India abstained, the Bangladesh Government and the International Community need to very seriously increase the pressure on Myanmar and internationally to ensure that the recommendations of the Kofi Annan report are accepted and implemented as quickly as possible.

Related Stories