Published : 06 Sep 2021, 05:39 AM
Updated : 21 Jun 2022, 08:16 PM
There could have been another option. We could have waited a couple of months more. Given that the rate of infection — never mind that deaths from the coronavirus pandemic have been on the decline — is yet to go down to a satisfactory level, we are not quite sure how schools and colleges in the country will tackle the situation. The authorities have made their decision known, of course. All schools and colleges will reopen on Sept 12, which in a way is understandable. For more than a year and a half, students have been staying away from the classroom because of this terrible malady the world is afflicted with. Nothing can be more debilitating for a society than a long period of learning being lost or simply not being there. Therefore, the sooner our young people in schools and colleges and universities trek back to the classroom the better for all of us. Ideally, that is.
And yet there are the worries which accompany this move by the government to have schools and colleges reopen. Take a look at what we have before us. All SSC and HSC candidates will be attending classes, beginning on Sept 12, six days a week. The same goes for students of Class Five in the schools. We have 40 million-plus students currently in school and college. If we look to the SSC and HSC students first, the initial question is one of how all these students will be accommodated in the classroom in conditions where the pandemic is yet to die down. Assuming that in a class of forty students, no more than twenty are accommodated at one time, with the remaining twenty to have their chance in the later part of the day or the next day. How will their teachers deal with them and with the subjects they are expected to teach?
In all this long and yet on-going period of the pandemic, a good number of teachers at different educational institutions have remained excruciatingly busy in online teaching. One cannot deny that online teaching is hard and taxes the patience, physical as well as mental, of both teachers and students. Now compare that with what is on the way. If a teacher, either in a school or a college, is for safety reasons expected to instruct half a class, he or she will also need to do the same with the remaining half. That will mean a teacher going over the same chapter or subject twice, perhaps even thrice. In effect, both students and teachers will be hamstrung, for such a method will result in an inevitable delay in the teaching of all subjects in all the classrooms.
The dilemma only gets to be thicker with the suggestion that, except for students of Class Five, all pupils from the primary to the higher levels will attend classes in-person once a week. How does that minimise the losses the young have till now gone through? It is hard to understand why Class Five will be in the classroom for six days in a row and the others just a single day. Where is the reassurance that these one-day students will keep in touch with their studies on the remaining days of the week, that online teaching will approximate real classroom teaching? Add to that the immense pressure that will be brought to bear on teachers, juggling as they would between being in the classroom and being before their laptops, constantly focused on their students.
The reopening of schools and colleges raises another worry, that of hygiene and health rules being maintained at the institutions. Our recent experience of strict lockdowns not being strict at all does little to instil confidence in us about health rules being properly maintained by students and teachers. Here is a peek into this problem: all teachers and all guardians (let us remember the concerns of the latter too) will have been vaccinated, hopefully, by Sept 12, but how many of the young people we are drawing back into the classroom have had their vaccinations till now? The minister for education has informed the country that young people between the ages of 12 and 18 may — notice 'may' — come by the Moderna or Pfizer vaccines in line with the recommendations of the World Health Organization.
That is worrying, for the statement is not one of reassurance. And with that comes the statement from the Directorate General of Health Services that it has had no word yet on the subject from the relevant authorities. How then are we to ensure that these school and college students, even if they wear masks and have their hands disinfected before entering the classroom, will not be infected or will not carry the virus home from the classroom at some point?
But, yes, we have also been informed that if the rate of infection goes up once the educational institutions have reopened, the schools and colleges which are laid low by such infections will be shut down again. That will take us back to square one. Just in case we did not know, a fairly good number of schools, having reopened in the United States, have had to close down again because of renewed or rising infections. We will hope that a similar condition does not occur in Bangladesh, but how can we be so sure it will not, in light of the warnings health experts have voiced about newer pandemic dangers that might lie ahead for the country?
A decision on a reopening of schools and colleges ought to have taken into account the opinions of principals, head teachers, teachers and guardians before the kind of public announcement that has already been made. Were these stakeholders at all consulted by the education authorities before the latter zeroed in on Sept 12? Besides, there are all the educational institutions in the rural areas, in many segments of which the pandemic has of late become a cause for fear. The headmasters and headmistresses of schools in such areas should have been consulted. In plain terms, since we in Bangladesh are yet in the pandemic straitjacket, broad public opinion should have informed the issue of whether or not schools and colleges should be reopened at this point.
Which takes us back to our initial thought — this reopening could have been undertaken a couple of months later, when the picture of the pandemic might have become a lot less hazy than it is now. We certainly will not relish a third wave of the coronavirus, but what do we do if it is upon us? Our children have lost much in terms of learning, true. But should we not guarantee, first, that they stay safe before they cheerfully rush back — all of them together — into the classroom?