Published : 10 Feb 2022, 04:20 AM
Updated : 22 Jul 2022, 03:03 AM
Chandran Nair , the founder of The Global Institute for Tomorrow, an independent think-tank based in Hong Kong, has hit hard at the West for perpetuating what he chooses to call "white privilege".
His latest book "Dismantling Global White Privilege: Equity for a Post-Western World" flashes the red light on the West and challenges its continued domination on the global distribution of power that it seeks to perpetuate by means fair and foul.
Nair is a member of the World Economic Forum Global Agenda Council for Sustainability and has argued at numerous forums, including the WEF, APEC and OECD, about the need for radical reforms to the current economic model and strict limits on consumption. Nair was previously chairman of Environmental Resources Management (ERM), building the company to be the leading environmental consultancy in the Asia-Pacific.
As I read through Nair's interview with The Diplomat's chief editor Shannon Tiezzi, I felt tempted to examine how his brilliant exposition was relevant for the contemporary Bangladesh context (Chandran Nair on White Privilege in International Relations – The Diplomat, Feb 2, 2022).
Nair says in the interview :
"The presumption that all positive social changes are spawned in the West and must be spread to the rest of the world is a white supremacist's point of view. Social movements exist within countries and move at their own cultural pace with discussions that are appropriate for them …..The West must move beyond weaponising social causes to further the belief in the moral superiority of the West while diminishing the social values, political structures, and cultural norms of other countries."
The US sanctions on seven top Bangladesh security officials, preceded by not inviting Bangladesh to the Democracy Summit in December, is a classic case of "weaponsing" the human rights issue in the context of Bangladesh.
Gregory Meeks, who is chairman of the US House of Representatives Foreign Affairs Committee, had made it clear that he did not "believe wholesale sanctions on Bangladesh are currently warranted." That is exactly what many in the Biden administration and the lobbyists for Bangladesh's Islamist opposition parties and groups want to happen — "wholesale sanctions" against the Sheikh Hasina government. The opposition parties like the BNP are happy to play along as "fifth column" because they have banked on undemocratic interventions, be it from the US or the country's military, to grab power.
Nair defines "white privilege" as a right which the West believes is its "sole prerogative and masked in narratives about upholding the rules-based order and therefore global peace and prosperity."
In the Bangladesh context, the "mask of narratives" is a historical phenomenon. The British colonialists crushed Bengal revolutionary movements (covering East Bengal, now Bangladesh) with extreme brutality. Chittagong revolutionary leader Masterda Surya Sen had all his teeth smashed by a hammer and all his nails extracted painfully before he was hanged. He had not merely challenged the British but hurt their imperial ego by keeping Chittagong free for a few days before resuming guerrilla-style attacks. Why does any civilised race try to physically disfigure someone already convicted to hang!
The British were responsible for a series of famines that impoverished the once-rich province of Bengal, culminating in the Great Famine during the Second World War. Madhusree Mukherjee in her "Churchill's Secret War" asserts that if Hitler is a mass murderer for killing ten million Jews, Churchill is one as well for being directly responsible for the death of three million Bengalis.
During the 1971 Bangladesh war of independence, the US stood solidly behind the brutal Pakistani military junta of Yayha Khan which was responsible for the massacre of three million Bengalis and dishonouring a quarter of a million Bengali women.
Pakistan was a Western colonial project, conceived as a post-colonial client state in the underbelly of the Soviet Union (all American U2 spy planes flew out of Peshwar). The fall of China to communism later increased Pakistan's importance to the West.
Richard Nixon and Henry Kissinger could never come to terms with an independent Bangladesh and the latter described it as a "bottomless basket." The real irony of the matter lies in the US and other Western elements questioning the legal edifice of the war crimes trials which got underway after Hasina led the Awami League to a huge electoral victory in December 2008.
The likes of Toby Cadman, the upholders of "white privilege" in Bangladesh, swung into action, determined to take the bottom out of the war crimes trials and protect the heinous elements who had helped the Pakistan Army kill and rape with gay abandon.
In a way, Bangladesh seems to be the ultimate victim of the "white privilege." A free nation born swimming through an "ocean of blood" is not even supposed to have the sovereign right to try mass murderers who killed Bengalis like flies and sought to perpetuate a culture of impunity that was strengthened by the US-backed military coup in 1975. And this is the West that talks of natural justice and a rules-based order. And human rights after the waterboardings and other unique torture techniques at Guantanomo Bay.
Nair is apt in his observation when he says: "The West harbors an anachronistic sense of superiority over others and retains privileges from its colonial exploits and setting up the 'international rules-based system."
So the US has the right to invade Iraq and Afghanistan to fight terror but sovereign Bangladesh does not have the right to "tough policing" to fight similar versions of homegrown Islamist terror. While the FBI has praised Bangladesh's success in the counterterrorism campaign, the country has now become a victim of US sanctions directed at its top security officials. This is a ploy to demoralise the Bangladesh security forces so that they don't hit back hard at violent Islamist street protests.
The ultimate US game is to bring about regime change in Bangladesh through an orchestrated social media disinformation campaign that whips up political unrest and keeps security forces at bay. But it is masked in the "violation of human rights" narrative, played up to fever pitch by the drumbeaters of regime change.