November 21, 2026

India's CPI (M) support cow slaughter on economic grounds

While the Hindutva brigade pulverises India with its frenetic campaign against cow slaughter and the Congress defends its record in banning it in many states, the Communist Party of India (Marxist) has finally taken a stand supporting it.

bdnews24.com

India Correspondent

bdnews24.com

Published : 24 Oct 2015, 10:23 AM

Updated : 23 Apr 2022, 01:13 PM

The CPI(M), which ruled West Bengal and Kerala for long years and now runs the tiny North-eastern state of Tripura, has justified cow slaughter on 'purely economic grounds'.

An editorial in the forthcoming issue of its weekly organ ‘People's Democracy’ says India's rural economy will have to bear the burden of sustaining 5.3 million unproductive cattle a year if there is a comprehensive ban on cow slaughter and exports.

"That will cost the country Rs 20,000 crores (200 billion). That will badly affect India's rural economy," the editorial says.

The article also emphasised the need for a campaign against those using the cow to incite hatred against Muslims, and castigated the government for failing to protect religious minorities against attacks.

The People's Democracy editorial quotes the 2012 Indian Cattle Census, which says the country has 5.3 million stray cattle, including cows, buffaloes and bulls.

TK Datta of the National Dairy Research Institute says that one-fourth of all cows in India were old and unproductive—as were tens of thousands of bullocks.

"Sustaining unproductive cattle is costly," Datta said.

According to the People's Democracy editorial, the cow protection campaign of the Hindutva organisations seeks to divert public attention from the failures of the BJP-led government in checking rising prices of agricultural commodities like pulses, crop failures and shrinking job opportunities.

The editorial lashes out at murder of Muslims for allegedly consuming beef or transporting cows and demands action against BJP ministers who have pandered to these extremists.

West Bengal or Tripura are some of the Indian states where cow slaughter is not banned.

Much of the illegal export of cattle to Bangladesh happens through these states.

Former BSF chief Ashis Mitra had pitched for legalising the export of cattle to Bangladesh, saying that would spare the border guards much trouble and help them concentrate on bigger priorities like checking smuggling of weapons and drugs.

He had said it was impossible to stop this trade and it would be better for the government to legalise it.

But Indian Home Minister Rajnath Singh of the BJP has recently pandered to the Hindutva brigade by saying that he has asked BSF personnel to check illegal smuggling of cattle to Bangladesh.

But that, many say, is a wrong step because it leaves India's rural economy with the burden to sustain huge numbers of unproductive cattle.

Also Read:

Bangladesh proposes including cattle trade at the ‘border haats’

Also Read:

Indian seminar advocate cattle trade legalisation with Bangladesh

Also Read:

The ‘unofficial’ cow trade

Also Read:

BSF chief for legalising cattle trade
Related Stories