US told to "shape up or ship out"
As things heat up in the climate change talks of the Conference of Parties (COP17) meet in Durban, approaching conclusion this Friday, the gloves are coming off with Greenpeace, the World Wildlife Fund (WWF), and Oxfam telling the US to "shape up or ship out."
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
06 Dec 2011, 10:25 AM
Updated :
10 Aug 2022, 05:54 PM
Sayed Talat Kamal
From Durban, South Africa
Durban, Dec 06 (bdnews24.com)—As things heat up in the climate change talks of the Conference of Parties (COP17) meet in Durban, approaching conclusion this Friday, the gloves are coming off with Greenpeace, the World Wildlife Fund (WWF), and Oxfam telling the US to "shape up or ship out."
Greenpeace International's executive director Kumi Naidoo has asked the US to "move aside and let the rest of the world move forward if you cannot get with the programme."
Echoing the sentiment Oxfam advocacy and campaigns director Celine Chaveriat has said that if the US could not be part of the solution they should rather step aside and not "harm" the efforts of other countries.
The US has been perceived as dragging its feet on issues that would see the extension of the Kyoto protocol restrictions, which expire in the end of 2012.
Instead of a binding agreement the US has said that it favoured voluntary pledges by countries to do as much as they could to control emissions. The US has promised to cut its emissions by 17 percent from 2005 levels by 2020; a pledge that the US delegation leader Jonathan Pershing said that he did not believe would change in the near future.
Naidoo stressed that "the world was held hostage to eight years of climate denialism by President George W Bush's administration… we expected better from the administration of President Obama."
Climate change is a result of greenhouse gases trapping the sun's heat in the earth's atmosphere. The trapped heat raises global temperatures, which in turn trigger changes in weather conditions, leading to stronger and more frequent cyclones and floods, rising seas, drought, erosion and increased salinity.
It is widely accepted that a rise of global temperatures over 2 degrees Celsius would cause irreversible climate change. Global studies, endorsed by the UN and the scientific community indicate that in order to arrest the temperature rise within 1.5 degrees, global emissions must reduced to 40 percent of what they were in 1990 by the year 2020 and to 95 percent of 1990-levels by 2050. Furthermore emissions must not peak after 2015.
The US, as well as a few other large economies, have only just begun to suggest that time now was to negotiate a new multi-lateral agreement to update and replace the 1997 Kyoto Protocol. They are suggesting even that they need not make so many decisions in Durban and that they needed "more time to think."
EU climate change commissioner Connie Hedegaard categorically dismissed any suggestions for more time to maul the issues further. Pointing out that the legally binding Kyoto treaty was signed 14 years ago, she asked "if we start (talking) again now, how long would it take the world to get its act together again?"
While it raised hopes in certain quarters, it now appears that China's announcement of its willing to accept legal bindings on its greenhouse gas emissions has its share of cautious advocates.
China, the world's largest climate polluter, with 24 percent of global greenhouse gas emissions, has said it was ready to consider legal obligations under the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC), subject to at least five strict pre-conditions. Previously China had insisted on exemption as a "developing" country.
Todd Stern, the chief US negotiator in the talks, was quick to reflect that talk of a legally binding agreement premised on conditions meant that China was not willing "to do the kind of legally binding agreement we're talking of."
Suggesting that China was not "ready for complete legal parity," he confirmed that if China did not adopt complete legal parity in a deal, the US would not be part of it.
Hedgegaard was equally cautious of China's position. "China has always been in favour of a legally-binding outcome. (But) does that mean that China will also be legally-bound? I think that still needs a lot of clarification," she said.
Among the conditions Chinese chief negotiator Xie Zhenhua, who first signalled his country's intent to consider legally binding emission restrictions, stipulated were that the UN remain the primary negotiating forum and that developed nations, particularly the US, shoulder a larger slice of the cuts because of a nearly "200 year" head start on industrialisation.
Xie also spoke of technology transfer and funding for developing nations, and expressed his country's concern there be a "win-win" balance between responding to climate change and tackling economic development.
Amidst real fears that climate change would slow down already depressed economies and delay recovery, which could be a reason for some countries to take the 'go-slow' approach one would imagine, UK climate change economist Lord Nicholas Stern concluded that tackling climate and developing the economy were mutually dependent. "There is no horse race between climate responsibility and development," he said, "if we fail in the one sphere, it will fail in the other."
The Oxfam advocacy director pointed out that the world was on the path to a 3-4 degree temperature increase if negotiations continued at the same pace; such a increase would be "devastating" for poorer countries, Chaveriat added.
The numbers on climate change are clear - even for a 50/50 chance of keeping average global temperatures below a 2 degree celsius threshold, anything over which would be considered disastrous, the world would have to cut greenhouse gas emissions radically from 50 billion tons to just 20 billion a year.
bdnews24.com/tk/bd/1618h