November 21, 2026

Outcome of Cancún climate talks still unclear

Bangladesh's environment state minster Hasan Mahmud summed up the outcome of the Cancún climate summit saying that although the talks had entered the final day, the outcome was still "unclear".

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 11 Dec 2010, 07:36 AM

Updated : 24 Apr 2022, 05:50 PM

Cancún, Dec 10 (bdnews24.com) — Bangladesh's environment state minster Hasan Mahmud summed up the outcome of the Cancún climate summit saying that although the talks had entered the final day, the outcome was still "unclear". "It stands on both 'good and bad options' on the table," he told reporters at a briefing on the morning of the last day of the climate summiton Friday. Mahmud was indeed referring to one of the most baffling elements of the typical negotiation texts which are found in the form of [brackets] and 'options'. These indicate differences of opinion and are open to debate and further negotiations before adoption of a decision. It is imperative that any 'outcome' from Cancún would have to remove all these ambiguities to be accepted by all parties, he explained. Much of the criticism from activists milling about at the conference venue has been that negotiators were wasting time dragging their feet while the threat of climate change continued to stare on the face of nations. That appeared to have struck a chord with Mahmud when he suggested that instead of the yearly jamboree, as he had suggested on a previous occasion, there should be two ministerial summits before the next session of the UN climate convention scheduled in Durban, South Africa, next year. Often the different proposals regarding contentious issues, such as — finance, technology transfer and capacity building — are put down as different options, while different numbers and particular details that parties do not agree with are incorporated in brackets. Lamenting the slow and tedious process of international negotiations, Mahmud told the briefing on Friday that instead of completing the tasks that had been set out in Bali two years ago, negotiators took another year and "have just decided to take the talks up to Durban." The 13th instalment of the UN climate summit in Bali, Indonesia in 2007, had decided to complete the new round of negotiations by 2009 in Copenhagen, which of course failed spectacularly despite behind the scenes manoeuvring particularly by United States, India, China, Brazil and South Africa. "If the current trend of negotiation goes on as before I doubt if Durban will deliver the desired level of results," Mahmud said. He said that it was high time for political decisions to guide the technical negotiations at Cancún and beyond. Mahmud suggested two ministerial level meetings in 2011 before the the Durban climate summit. With little progress to show after two weeks of discussions among about 190 countries, Mahmud reiterated his previous points at the press conference and once again drew attention of all the parties that the poor and vulnerable parties should be given preferential treatment for funding. These funds, he pointed out, should equally prioritise helping the vulnerable people to adapt to climate change and reduction of greenhouse gas emissions. Greenhouse gases trap the sun's heat in the atmosphere which raises temperatures leading to climate change through what are called extreme climate events like more frequent and intense floods and cyclones, rising sea level and persistent droughts. Experts say that a temperature rise of over 2 degrees Celsius would result in 'catastrophic' climate change which may not be reversed. The poorest group of countries, which includes Bangladesh, island states and African countries that are said to be at the most risk, have consistently demanded that this temperature rise must remain below 1.5 degrees by the turn of the century. According to surveys, global temperatures have already risen by 0.8 degrees in the last century, which has brought the earth closer to catastrophe. Mahmud went to challenge another basic tenet of the climate negotiations, which entrusts itself almost entirely to market-based financing mechanisms meaning that climate funds would be generated through the open market. But the Bangladesh junior minister said, "We are afraid that if market mechanism is left uncontrolled and unguided" then it may not benefit the poor countries. He suggested that this was too serious an issue to remain beyond the ambit of government involvement, while the private sector may be explored as and when considered appropriate. To a question regarding his call for all major polluters to accept reduction commitments, Mahmud stood by it and said that in order to achieve what parties were negotiating for, all major polluters would have to reduce their emissions. bdnews24.com/ta/ec/1243h
Related Stories