November 20, 2026

Gig worker rule comes at bad time for gig economy

Workers are already scarce, and inflation is squeezing consumers while higher costs threaten long-awaited earnings, writes Jennifer Saba

Gig worker rule comes at bad time for gig economy
A bicycle courier from Uber Eats rides his bicycle during the heatwave in Utrecht, Netherlands August 10, 2022.

Reuters

Published : 12 Oct 2022, 09:56 AM

Updated : 12 Oct 2022, 09:56 AM

The road ahead could get even rougher for the champions of the gig economy. President Joe Biden’s administration is seeking to turn some independent contractors into employees. Workers are already scarce, and inflation is squeezing consumers. Higher costs threaten long-awaited earnings at companies like Uber Technologies, Lyft and DoorDash.

The US Department of Labour on Tuesday issued a new proposal that provides guidance on classifying workers. The rule could require some companies that rely on independent contractors to treat them as employees, giving them additional benefits, a minimum wage, overtime pay and legal protections.

The proposal, which will likely take many months to finalise, would replace a previous rule under former President Donald Trump’s administration that loosened the status of contractors. Lyft said in a blog post it is “just the first step” but that the company would not have to change its business model. DoorDash and Uber issued similar statements.

Nonetheless, even the prospect of a shift spooked investors. Shares of Uber, Lyft and DoorDash were down approximately 7% by noon in New York. That’s on top of a broader sector selloff: This year Uber has shed about 40% of its market capitalisation while the equity values of Lyft and DoorDash are down around 70% each.

That’s because ridesharing and food-delivery are tough businesses even in good times. Analysts expect Uber, DoorDash and Lyft to earn EBITDA margins of just 5% to 7% of revenue this year, according to Refinitiv. That hard won progress after years of painful losses could go into reverse. Wedbush analysts figure that Uber and Lyft’s costs could spike by 20% to 30% if they have to put workers on the payroll, forcing the companies to hike charges.

Casual labour allows the gig-dependent companies to adapt their workforces to peaks and troughs in demand. Maintaining permanent employees could therefore mean higher expenses and slower services in busy times.

Gig economy firms are already grappling with the tight US labour market, while the rising cost of goods and services is weighing on budgets. The New York Federal Reserve’s survey of consumers published on Tuesday found that household spending expectations fell sharply in September, posting their largest one month decline since the series’ inception in June 2013. Discretionary spending on items like taxis and takeout food is at risk. A gig worker rule comes at the worst possible time for America’s gig economy.

Related Stories