November 23, 2026

Norway goes neither way in Yunus-GP row

Norway's international development minister, Erik Solheim, has said his government will not intervene to resolve the conflict between Muhammad Yunus and Telenor regarding the control over grameenphone."Telenor is an independent company and Muhammad Yunus is a businessman," he told the Bangladeshi journalists visiting Oslo to cover the Nobel Peace Prize awarding ceremony recently.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 19 Dec 2006, 06:00 PM

Updated : 17 Aug 2022, 07:04 PM

Abu Saeed Khan bdnews24.com Technology Editor Dhaka, Dec 20 (bdnews24.com) - Norway's international development minister, Erik Solheim, has said his government will not intervene to resolve the conflict between Muhammad Yunus and Telenor regarding the control over grameenphone. "Telenor is an independent company and Muhammad Yunus is a businessman," he told the Bangladeshi journalists visiting Oslo to cover the Nobel Peace Prize awarding ceremony recently. Erik Solheim said that disputes were natural in any successful company and "grameenphone is a successful venture". The dispute over ownership was to be resolved by Yunus and Telenor, he said. Norway's telecoms major, Telenor, owns 62 percent of grameenphone while Grameen Telecom of Yunus enjoys 38 percent ownership. On December 5, the microcredit lending chief slammed Telenor in an interview with Fortune magazine. He claimed Telenor "agreed to give us majority ownership within six years." "We have never committed to reducing our share in the company," Telenor CEO Jon Fredrik Baksaas refuted to Fortune. He also dumped Yunus' idea for a board meeting in Oslo to review the ownership issues before the Nobel Prize ceremony. "We believe that on the questions of the future ownership of grameenphone, there should be other occasions for those topics to be discussed," Baksaas said. Norway's national TV channel, NRK, headlined this conflict. On December 7, its news program called "NRK Dagsrevyen 21" questioned the laureate's aspiration to dwarf Telenor in grameenphone. Investment firm Enskilda analyst Ole Petter Kjerkreit said in that program, "I think it is a bit unreasonable that now, after Telenor has made the great effort and invested for many years, one claims that the values are not belonging to Telenor." Jo Henriksen, CEO of Norway's Microcredit outfit Kolibri Kapital, was another participant. He said, "Here one has made an agreement in a private limited company where Telenor and Grameen Bank are joint owners, and this will be contrary to the laws of both Bangladesh and Norway." On December 9, Yunus visited Telenor headquarter in Oslo's outskirts. The next day he ceremoniously received the award. Norway's 136-year old national daily, Aftenposten, printed a picture of Yunus and Baksaas smiling at each other while shaking hands. "It's not common for the winner of the Nobel Peace Prize to start his first day in Oslo with a meeting aimed at resolving a business conflict with none other than a Norwegian company," Aftenposten commented. The newspaper said several Norwegian politicians had called the conflict "embarrassing" and that the secretary of the Norwegian Nobel Committee had tried to keep it off of the agenda at a press conference on December 9. But Yunus stipulated his claim over grameenphone in the Nobel lecture on December 10. "Our vision was to ultimately convert this company into a social business by giving majority ownership to the poor women of Grameen Bank. We are working towards that goal. Someday grameenphone will become another example of a big enterprise owned by the poor." It humiliated Telenor. "Only the day before, the Peace Prize Laureate had met with Telenor at Fornebu, thanking us for our efforts in making grameenphone what it is today. When we heard Telenor's name brought up during the Nobel lecture, we realised that this would not turn out the way we had hoped and expected," said Telenor Senior Vice President and Head of Corporate Communications Anne-Sissel Skånvik to Aftenposten. Aftenposten reported Monday that Telenor had informed the Norwegian Government that the company would not seek to address these issues at this time, because it would not let anything interfere with the Peace Prize celebrations. Most of the 77-entourage of Yunus were not pleased as it did not snow, during the first-ever overseas trip to Oslo, for many of them. Now the laureate is perhaps displeased, nothing doing with unnatural Nordic climate, but the Norwegians' cold shoulder to his highly publicised claim over grameenphone. bdnews24.com/ask/rm/1729 hours
Related Stories