Member to quit if agency engaged
A member of the panel of economists for Bangladesh's sixth five-year plan has threatened to resign over a government decision to sub-contract a private agency to formulate the plan. Tanim Ahmed writes.
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
01 Jul 2010, 10:03 AM
Updated :
11 Aug 2022, 02:22 PM
Dhaka, July 1 (bdnews24.com) — A member of the panel of economists for Bangladesh's sixth five-year plan has threatened to resign over a government decision to sub-contract a private agency to formulate the plan.
Dr Muinul Islam, an economics professor of Chittagong University, told a discussion on Wednesday that he was disappointed with the decision to appoint Policy Research Initiative of Bangladesh (PRI) to design the plan of such magnitude.
He told a public discussion, organised by an NGO Nagorik Shanghati, marking the closure of Adamjee Jute Mills eight years ago, that the economists' panel had not been consulted before contracting out the job.
Dr Islam, also a former president of the Bangladesh Economic Association, said he would tender his resignation if it turned out to be true that PRI had indeed been tasked to tailor the country's primary development plan.
"Such a move would mean that the five-year plan would necessarily reflect the kind of policies and recommendations that the World Bank hands out."
He said the neoliberal polices that focussed solely on growth could never address disparity. "And unless the long-term plan envisions 'inequality alleviating growth' there is no chance of development."
Dr Islam pointed out that the research organisation PRI was essentially run by former employees and consultants of the World Bank and its Bretton Woods twin the International Monetary Fund (IMF).
PRI chairman Zaidi Sattar acknowledged working on formulation of the five-year plan but declined to elaborate on the scope of work when contacted by bdnews24.com.
Sattar evaded a direct answer when asked if the firm was not at liberty to speak about its work related to an open public document.
The PRI chairman served the World Bank for 11 years between 1996 and 2007.
Ahsan H Mansur, PRI executive director, has had a long career with the IMF and worked in Middle Eastern, Asian, African and Central American countries.
Vice chairman of the research organisation Sadiq Ahmed served the World Bank in several key positions including country director of Pakistan and Afghanistan Program, and chief economist for South Asia.
Sattar would not comment on the apprehensions expressed about the PRI's effectiveness for the key job.
When pointed out that the economy had for years been gradually nudged towards an increasingly free market orientation, Dr Islam referred to the government's commitment to revert to the original constitution of 1972 that held 'socialism' as one of its pillars.
However, he also cautioned that it did not mean a fully government-run Soviet Union-like system as the principles of ownership, prioritising government ownership and cooperative ownership, prescribed in the constitution, might suggest.
"But there must be a balance of socialist system."
He admitted that he had announced to resign his position from the economists' panel depending upon what he would find in the meeting on Thursday.
The last meeting of the panel was held about two and a half months earlier, he said.
When asked about his announcement at the public discussion in the morning, Islam admitted, saying, "I have announced that if the news is confirmed in the meeting, I would resign as a note of protest."
The sixth five-year plan was set to restore the government's long term planning exercise since it was discarded for the shorter and 'rolling' Poverty Reduction Strategy Paper at the behest of the World Bank since 2001.
But Islam apprehends that the new exercise, that had raised high hopes initially, would go in vain if such WB-IMF-driven institutions are involved in formulating the country's five-year plan.
"It is because of the prescriptions of the World Bank that Bangladesh still has such high levels of poverty and disparity."
He said it was high time that Bangladesh stopped pandering to the dictats handed down from the lending agencies.
bdnews24.com/ta/bd/0859 hrs.