Published :
28 Nov 2012, 06:54 PM
Updated :
09 Aug 2022, 04:33 PM
Sheikh Abdullah
bdnews24.com correspondent
Dhaka, Nov 29 (bdnews24.com)—A firm that had contracted out Wal-Mart's garment-manufacturing orders to Tazreen Fashions Limited scrapped the order on finding the sloppy condition there even though the industry lobby BGMEA had labelled the factory as 'compliant'.
At least 110 people were reportedly killed in the worst case of factory fire in Bangladesh that swept through the multi-storey factory in Ashulia, on the outskirts of capital Dhaka on Saturday.
The US media raised questions about working conditions and payments of workers in readymade garment sector which contributes around 80 percent to Bangladesh's export income. Questions were also raised about how a company that had long been rated in the 'Orange' category got orders from Wal-Mart.
On Monday, just a day after the devastating fire, while foreign buyers were apparently unhappy with Tazreen Fashions' safety measures, the President of the Bangladesh Garment Manufacturers and Exporters Association claimed the factory was a compliant one.
"It is a large, ultra-modern, compliant factory," Shafiul Islam Mohiuddin had told a press conference.
He indicated the fire at Tazreen could be 'an act of sabotage' and declined comment on media reports that said the factory did not have any emergency exits.
Industry insiders say Tazreen Fashions got the Wal-Mart contract to manufacture clothes for children through Simco Bangladesh.
"I did not give Tazreen Fashions any work; I gave it to Tuba Garments knowing it was on the list of one of Wal-Mart's compliant companies," Simco Bangladesh Chairman Muzaffar Uddin Siddique told bdnews24.com by telephone on Wednesday night.
He said Tuba Garment owner Delwar Hossain gave his work to Tazreen Fashions and went to the factory on hearing about it.
"I saw threads lying on the floor and stairs leading to the warehouse," Siddique said of the factory's working condition.
The Simco chief said he had asked Hossain to return the clothes and sent for them twice. "But" Siddique continued, "he did not return the clothes."
Siddique further said Hossain had started cutting clothes without making any entry or informing him which prompted him to take the issue up with one of the BGMEA directors. Hossain returned him 17,500 pieces of clothes after the Director spoke to him and kept another 7,500 pieces which he had cut, he added.
When asked whether he had informed Wal-Mart of subcontracting the work to Tuba Group, Siddique said, "I did not get the order from Wal-Mart, I got it from an American agent with whom I have bond-transfer agreement."
"I know one of Wal-Mart's listed companies can do the job of another listed company," he argued, apparently defending his move to engage Tuba Group.
He said he had given Tuba Group the work as it was enlisted under the US retail giant's 'Yellow' rating.
The Wal-Mart categorises the factory's compliance with colours: 'Green', 'Yellow', 'Orange' and 'Red'. If a factory remains in 'Orange' category in three assessments for two consecutive years, it automatically goes to 'Red', leading to cancellation of business deal for a year.
The 'Green' ones are the most compliant factories.
Tuba Group, which owns Tazreen Fashions, claimed on its website that the factory saw an improvement in Wal-Mart rating only in two months after it was ranked 'Orange' in 2011 and that Tazreen now fell in the 'Yellow' category.
However, the website has been inaccessible since the fire tore through Tazreen.
A few days after the devastating fire, Wal-Mart in a statement claimed it was 'troubled' over the whole affair as a supplier had subcontracted work to Tazreen in "direct violation" of the retailer's policies. The US giant, however, refrained from naming the supplier.
"The fact that this occurred is extremely troubling to us, and we will continue to work across the apparel industry to improve fire safety education and training in Bangladesh," the firm had said in a statement.
When Tazreen Fashions owner Delwar Hossain was asked about the Wall-Mart statement, he told bdnews24.com: "I got the work from Simco Bangladesh through Uttara's Faisal Tex buying house. They gave me the work after rating my factory."
"As far as I know, the main company (Wal-Mart) is aware of it," he added.
Five panels from the government, administration, police and fire department are probing the fire incident.
On Monday, Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina told Parliament that the fire at the factory was set in a 'pre-planned way'.
Several survivors alleged the factory's main gate had been locked from outside when the fire started spreading to upper floors.
The trade unions have termed the incident 'an act of mass murder' and blamed the owners for it.
bdnews24.com/sa/zk/bd/0047h