Published : 14 Nov 2012, 07:25 PM
Updated : 09 Aug 2022, 04:30 PM
Two former central bank Governors have suggested full autonomy for Bangladesh Bank into to ensure a more efficient banking system.
The suggestion came from Mohammed Farashuddin and Salehuddin Ahmed at a seminar on Wednesday amid recent tit-for-tat statements between the central bank and the Ministry of Finance over the loan scam involving apparel firm Hall-Mark Group.
Farashuddin, who headed the central bank during the Awami League first stint in office, and Ahmed, who served during the last BNP-led government's term, were speaking at a seminar on 'State of Banking Sector and Macroeconomic Challenges'.
The seminar was organised by Economic Reporters' Forum (ERF) at the capital's National Press Club.
Both believed Bangladesh Bank needed operational autonomy to regulate the financial and banking sector, and ensure proper implementation of the Bank Company Act and rules and regulations.
Farashuddin said, "I think operational autonomy is needed for the central bank to operate more efficiently."
Ahmed said, "Even with all the rules and regulations, benefits from all of those will not be gained if Bangladesh Bank has no autonomy."
The Federation of Bangladesh Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FBCCI) President AK Azad, Bangladesh Bank Deputy Governor SK Sur Chowdhury, central bank's Chief economist Hasan Zaman, BRAC Bank Deputy Managing Director Mohammad Mamdudur Rashid also spoke at the seminar.
A large number of ERF members attended the programme, presided over by its President Khawza Mainuddin while General Secretary Abdur Rahim Harmachi gave the welcome address and vote of thanks.
After the incident of loan disbursement by Sonali Bank to Hall-Mark Group against phoney documents came to light recently, Bangladesh Bank had recommended dissolving the state-owned bank's Board of Directors.
Finance Minister Abul Maal Abdul Muhith however retorted by questioning the central bank's authority to make the suggestion. Later, Bangladesh Bank released a statement explaining the legal arguments in favour of its recommendation.
The Hall-Mark loan fiasco prompted businesses, among others, to harshly criticise the banking system. Cases over the matter have already been lodged to get into the bottom of the scam.
Farashuddin on Wednesday said, "Had Bangladesh Bank been pro-active by not being reactive, the recent financial sector scandals could have been stopped."
The former Governor recommended taking effective measures right away after these kinds of incident surface. He also suggested increasing the central bank's supervision system for the state-owned banks.
He said capping the deposit interest rate after freeing the lending rate is not consistent with the free market economy. "This was a suicidal decision."
Farashuddin said the central bank should not be too happy with the foreign reserve crossing the mark of $12 billion.
"The logic behind building an additional foreign reserve to pay the import cost is really not acceptable. The extra foreign reserve instead triggers inflation."
He said, "For that, investment of foreign currency must be increased and the opportunity created in the global market shall be seized."
Salehuddin Ahmed said the Bangladesh Bank could become more effective in increasing credit disbursement in the productive sectors while it must closely supervise whether the credit was used in the right sector.
He alleged that a part of the private sector credit was diverted to some other areas where it was not meant to go.
Ahmed said, "I conducted a study on 18 branches in Cox's Bazaar, Netrokona and other areas recently and I found some businessmen took SME loan but it was diverted."
"A branch manager told me that he lent Tk 100,000 and he did not know if the money was spent for the purpose it was taken for."
The former Governor observed that quality of credit was more important than how much credit is disbursed.
"It may be 19 percent or 20 percent (of credit disbursement target) but proper borrowers should get them."
Ahmed said, "Building a prevention system beforehand is better than taking measures after something happens. The Hall-Mark incident has spread like an infection to other places too."
FBCCI President AK Azad also recommended increasing the central bank's scrutiny. "It should be checked to whom the private banks are giving loans and how even though the credit disbursement in the private sector has increased."
"The way banks are making profits, other sectors are unable to make profit the same way. The Board of Directors of the banks sets the profit margin beforehand. Bankers are charging extra on interest and service to reach that margin. Bangladesh Bank is trying but failing to prevent that."
"There was a media report that 100 big borrowers owed Tk 200 billion and so the money was being occupied by a section of people."
"General borrowers should also get a pie of the share," he added.
The chief of apex trade body said the growth rate would be even higher if the lending went to proper borrowers.
Azad suggested increasing credit growth from 25 percent to 30 percent to expand the sector. "This may escalate inflation, but will create job opportunities and will make it possible to achieve 8 percent growth."
He said about two million people enter job market every year and the private sector creates job opportunities for them.
"If you fear that inflation would shoot up due to private sector credit growth, then cut down the government borrowing."
Azad alleged that the commercial banks were charging higher interests after the Bangladesh Bank had lifted the cap on lending rate.
He advised the central bank to take some strict measures to make the growth situation better.
Deputy Governor Sur Chowdhury explained the central bank's reform programmes and new rules and regulations made in the recent times. He said pre-emptive measures would also be strengthened in the future.
He said the Bank Company Act would be amended soon and draft amendment of Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1947 is at final stages.
About the move to licence new banks that has drawn flak, he said the decision to introduce nine new banks was made to provide banking service to the people who are not getting it.
The Deputy Governor, however, said, "But Bangladesh Bank will not issue licence for the new banks until it is certain that the sponsors are not tax defaulters or Tk 4 billion for paid-up capital is not black money."
Bangladesh Bank's Chief Economist Hasan Zaman touched upon the overall economic situation, which he said is better than any other time.
"The rate of import fell while that of export increased. Credit growth in the private sector is more than what the monetary policy set out to achieve."
Zaman also presented five challenges for the Bangladesh Bank. Those include decreasing the interest rate of commercial banks, controlling inflation, taking control of the credit growth in private sector and stabilising the foreign currency exchange rate.
He said private sector credit growth of 20 percent was enough to cater to the need of trade and business but the real challenge is channelling money to all of them.
"In India the private sector credit growth rate was 15 percent and they had 8 percent growth and in Bangladesh it is now about 20 percent and it should be enough to reach the growth target."
"The main challenge is that the credit should not concentrate in a couple of hands; rather it should be disbursed across the private sector and to do this supervision and regulation are needed," he said.
Zaman said commercial banks should lower their lending rates as it would reduce the cost of borrowing.
About remittance, he said Bangladesh Bank introduced BB bills to withdraw excess money from the banks.
"Remittance flow increased by about 25 percent due to Eid and Puja combined and the excess money would be withdrawn from the market," he added.
Meanwhile, BRAC Bank Deputy Managing Director Mohammad Mamdudur Rashid said there was pros and cons of technology.
"Proper supervision and regulation are needed to face the negative impact of technology."