Bungling BTRC out to 'ruin' mobile business
Mobile phone companies are threatening to abandon their future investment plans after a move they say will ruin their business. Mobile CEOs, who met last week and drafted a stern warning to regulators, are angry that the government is allowing fixed phone companies to launch mobile service. Technology Editor Abu Saeed Khan reports. Updated with PSTN quotes.
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
09 Sep 2006, 06:00 PM
Updated :
17 Aug 2022, 06:37 PM
Advisory: Updated with quotes from PSTN Association chief Abu Saeed Khan bdnews24.com Technology Editor Dhaka, Sept 10 (bdnews24.com) - Mobile phone companies in Bangladesh have issued a stern warning to authorities that their future plans to invest hundreds of millions of dollars look "enormously risky" because of a regulatory move.
CEOs of five mobile operating companies sat in an emergency meeting
last week to decide their course of action in the wake of BTRC plans to
allow fixed phone companies to go mobile too.
"Allowing private PSTN operators (with comparatively insignificant
investment) to undermine the existing stable regulatory regime will
create an enormous risk for the mobile operation that has gained momentum and strength by huge investment over the years," they said in a letter to the regulatory chief Muhamad Omar Farooq.
"This will in turn make the operators lose interest and confidence in
making further investment in roll-out of networks and services and hence a reduction in expected growth in the industry," mobile operators' group ATOB said in the letter.
BTRC chiefs apparently remain prejudiced and clueless about the logic
and consequences of adding mobility to the fixed phones.
Speaking to bdnews24.com last week, Chairman Omar Farooq, flanked by
several of his colleagues, argued that the huge gap in the volume of business by the two types of operators would protect the existing mobile operators.
"The fixed operators will handle a small number of customers while the
mobile companies register millions of clients every month," the
chairman said.
Mobile company chiefs have a different view, however. "If permission of
SIM/RUIM for PSTN subscribers is accorded, the private PSTN operators
will definitely disrupt the initiative and operation of the legal mobile operators," the ATOB letter to the Chairman said.
Mobile operators are objecting to the move because of the fact that
RUIM or Removable User Identity Module is similar to SIM or Subscriber's Identity Module that GSM operators use.
To say in simpler terms, the regulators want to allow the PSTN
operators to sell this RUIM, the pre-programmed smart card that goes with CDMA technology. It will allow a PSTN subscriber to use any fixed or mobile handset that is compatible with CDMA.
The country's only CDMA mobile service provider, CityCell, will be the
prime victim.
CityCell connects its customers through RUIM cards. That's why the
mobile phone operators are wary that the PSTN companies will gain an unfair access to their mobile business.
Fixed telephone or PSTN operates similar wireless technology that runs
the mobile phone networks. The PSTN operators, however, sell each
subscription with a pre-programmed wireless desktop telephone set. These bulky gadgets limit the subscribers' outdoor mobility, one of the fundamentals that govern PSTN license regime.
The CEOs pointed out that the PSTN companies were given licences to
sell fixed phone service only and that the latest move would "violate"
previous "instructions".
Farooq, however, went on to argue for his move: "Manufacturing of
programmable handsets will be stopped throughout the world from this
December."
Attempts by bdnews24.com to verify this claim have so far yielded to
substantiate the BTRC chief's statements. This means BTRC has failed to
handle the matter professionally, industry analysts say.
Farooq, during the interview with bdnews24.com, also failed to come up
with any example of allowing mobility to PSTN anywhere in the world. The BTRC chief insisted: "Let others follow us. Why do we have to follow others all the time?"
And in considering giving mobile facility to the fixed operators, the
chairman reasoned, he had been guided by the fact that these PSTN
companies were all local companies.
This is exactly the point the PSTN companies are also trying to make. "We are local companies. We would like to be given the opportunity to grow," argues Abu Md. Sayeed, the President of PSTN Association.
Sayeed, speaking to bdnews24.com, admitted that people would be able to be mobile "but not as mobile as with the cell phones".
But how much have these companies invested? Farooq has no answers to
the question, nor does the public.
A top industry spokesman says this decision will be sending wrong
signals to the investors.
"The signals are more pronounced for the new ones such as Warid Telecom
that paid US$ 50 million to buy the mobile license," says Mehboob Chowdhury, chairman of the operators' regional forum GSM Asia-Pacific.
The UAE-based operator boasts being the highest license fee payer so
far, but now faces uncertainty in terms of return on their initial
investment in Bangladesh of more than two hundred million dollars or 14 billion taka.
bdnews24.com/1845 hrs.