BB sees 'tacit collusion' among banks
Banks earn high fees and profit and maintain high interest spreads from a 'regime of tacit collusion', the central bank said.
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
14 Sep 2006, 06:00 PM
Updated :
17 Aug 2022, 06:38 PM
Dhaka, Sep 15 (bdnews24.com) – Banks earn high fees and profit and maintain high interest spreads from a 'regime of tacit collusion', the central bank said.
Bankers opposed Bangladesh Bank's view. There is no collusion, but scope of uneven competition remains because of the government's intervention in the policies of nationalised commercial banks, they said.
The central bank's observation came in its Financial Sector Review (FSR) where it analysed the extent of spreads between lending and deposit rates, net interest margin and higher profit in the banking sector.
The BB said the market is segmented for NCBs, private commercial banks (PCBs) and foreign commercial banks (FCBs). High profit figures demonstrate that there is not a great deal of competition, it said.
According to FSR, returns of equity for NCBs, PCBs and FCBs were -605 percent, 16.56 percent and 18.59 percent respectively in 2005.
Return on assets (net profit after tax per taka of asset) for NCBs, PCBs and FCBs were 1.36 percent, 1.06 percent and 3.09 percent in the same year.
A high interest spread persists in the banking sector, the BB said. For FCBs, it was in the 8 percent range and about 6 percent for PCBs and NCBs until January.
"This long sustained high spread and high profit indicate that the market is segmented, and this trend would continue further," said an economic adviser to the BB
"If competition had really prevailed, the trend of high profit would have discontinued."
He said competition would be difficult to attain unless non-performing loans are eliminated.
The BB said: "The recent FCB behaviour is supportive of market segmentation. This part of the market not only displays much more higher spread than the rest, rather the difference seems astounding. Competition would have brought about the opposite trend."
On spread between PCBs and NCBs, it said NCBs will not be allowed to exit the market simply on grounds of loss and it would permit one to assume the observed spread between them as the minimum necessary to meet cash flow requirements of NCBs to keep the latter functioning.
"It is thus plausible that the more efficient firms (typically PCBs) enjoy some market power, and they exploit advantages by adhering to the spread below which NCBs simply cannot operate," it said.
"These better-run banks do not play competitive game by paring the spread in order to win the market share. So the overall behaviour may be dubbed as tacit collusion," it added.
Khondkar Ibrahim Khaled, managing director of Pubali Bank, said: "I don't agree with such assertion. Rather there is a competitive convergence as interest rates are rallying in the same direction."
The government's control on NCBs created space for other banks to maximise profit, Sonali Bank Managing Director Tahmilur Rahman said.
"Scope remains for uneven competition. In other words, there is no competition in the ideal sense as interest rates are not declining though there are a number of competitors," he said.
bdnews24.com/1607hrs