Published :
02 Mar 2007, 10:11 AM
Updated :
17 Aug 2022, 02:34 PM
Muhammad Jahangir of Yunus Secretariat has sent a rejoinder to the bdnews24.com story headlined "Yunus is building digital muscle" of February 27. Here is the full statement:
>>Official RFP of Yunus Secretariat project
"There was never an official invitation for bids to set up a digital communications centre. Instead what you sent a copy to us of is an initial draft prepared by Vidar Jorgensen, a friend of Grameen, soon after the announcement of Nobel Prize, for an idea developed by young Bangladesh IT specialists in Japan and Silicon Valley to establish a digital communications centre.
The purpose of the centre would be to disseminate Professor Yunus ideas about microcredit, poverty alleviation and social business. The idea for the communications centre was conceptualised many months ago. There is no intention, if this centre materialises, to use this in support of Professor Yunus' political career.
Jorgensen does not belong to Yunus Secretariat, since such an entity does not exist in the US. You will see in the text of the draft that it states, "the planned Yunus Secretariat".
You state that Lamiya Morshed said that donors have been approached to support this digital communications centre, and that she refused to reveal the donors' identity. What was said is that once the project was developed, donors, who still have not been identified, would be approached to support this."
Our reply
Jahangir said, "There is no intention, if this centre materialises, to use this in support of Professor Yunus' political career."
We have duly captured this forward-looking statement at the beginning of our report.
The first sentence of Jahangir's statement "There was never an official invitation for bids to set up a digital communications centre" is incorrect.
Christopher Clark, coordinator of "Connect the World Initiative" of Geneva-based International Telecommunication Union (ITU), has formally invited the request for proposal (RFP) in February.
"I have attached a proposal from Grameen to build a communications centre at their Headquarters in Bangladesh. They are looking for partners to help implement this proposal," Clark said in the email while circulating the RFP.
Therefore, Jahangir's claim of "never" inviting "an official invitation for bids" is wrong.
Jahangir also said, "Jorgensen does not belong to Yunus Secretariat, since such an entity does not exist in the US."
But Clark's email says, "Please do not hesitate to contact the Grameen focal points directly if you have very specific questions. The Grameen focal points are listed in the attached note (RFP)."
The RFP that Clark has attached says: "Please send information and suggestions to: Vidar Jorgensen, Yunus Secretariat, 500 West Cummings Park, Suite 5200, Woburn, Massachusetts 01801 with a copy to: Jacki Lippman, Communications Officer, Grameen America."
Evidently, Vidar Jorgensen and Jacki Lippman are the only "Grameen focal points" of the ambitious project. Therefore, Jahangir's claim of Jorgensen not belonging to Yunus Secretariat and the entity's nonexistence in the US is also incorrect.
"The planned Yunus Secretariat" as stated in the RFP is attributed to the proposed project rather than its existence.
Otherwise it could not have a street address in the US.
Besides, a nonexistent entity cannot have a CEO either.
Lamiya Morshed has claimed to be the "CEO of Yunus Secretariat" and gave her statements to bdnews24.com accordingly.
If Lamiya Morshed is the CEO of Yunus Secretariat, Jahangir's claim of the organisation's non-existence is inconsistent.
We have covered Lamiya Morshed's statements verbatim in our report, but we did not record the telephone interview for further reference, out of courtesy.
bdnews24.com/ask/ad/1533 hours