November 21, 2026

Yunus has to go, rules HC

The High Court dismisses Muhammad Yunus's challenge to a central bank order sacking him as the Grameen Bank managing director, saying he was working in violation of the retirement laws. UPDATES 1

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 08 Mar 2011, 09:17 AM

Updated : 10 Aug 2022, 04:27 PM

Dhaka, Mar 8 (bdnews24.com) — The High Court has dismissed the challenge of Muhammad Yunus to a central bank order firing him as the Grameen Bank managing director. However, his counsels have announced to continue the legal battle. The court said Yunus, 70, was working long past the mandatory retirement age. The Nobel laureate lost the legal battle to retain his job in the bank set up in 1983, after hearing on Thursday, Sunday and Monday. The bench of justices Muhammed Mamtaz Uddin Ahmed and Gobinda Chandra Tagore rejected two writ petitions against the Bangladesh Bank's Mar 2 order and observed that the Grameen Bank founder had been improperly reappointed. It started delivering the verdict at 2pm on Tuesday. Justice Ahmed contended that the Grameen Bank founder had been continuing in his office with no legal basis. Yunus was unceremoniously relieved of his duties last Wednesday through a central bank letter sent to Grameen Bank chairman Khondoker Muzammel Huq. The central bank said Yunus failed to seek its approval when he was reappointed as the managing director in 1999, violating one of the statutes of the partly state-owned Grameen Bank. A high-profile international campaign spurred him on to defy the order, continue working at Grameen Bank headquarters and contest his sacking in court the day next. Nine of the 12 directors of the microlending behemoth also appealed to the same bench challenging the removal, claiming that Yunus' reappointment in 1999 as the managing director did not require prior approval of the central bank. The wider international community showed its displeasure at the way the 2006 Nobel Peace Prize winner for Bangladesh was treated. After the judgment, Yunus' counsel Sara Hossain said, "Today is a sad day for Bangladesh. "The court has given today legitimacy to an illegal order of Bangladesh Bank. The dismissal of the writ petitions has proved correct what we had apprehended at the hearings over the last few days." The next decision would be made in consultation with Yunus, she said, adding, "Yunus has the right of appeal to the Supreme Court." Another counsel Roknuddin Mahmud said, "We had expressed our apprehension of not getting justice from the court." "The order rejecting the writ will not harm Yunus, but the image of the judiciary has been lowered," he added. YUNUS' REAPPOINTMENT ILLEGAL The court observed that the decision of the Grameen Bank board that year to appoint Yunus managing director for an indefinite period had no legal basis either. "The managing director of the Grameen Bank is an officer, who cannot hold the office for an unlimited time," the court said. In the order, the court legitimised the Bangladesh Bank order removing Yunus. The order said according to the Bank Companies Act, the central bank reserved the right to issue such orders. The court said the Nobel laureate's serving as the MD of Grameen Bank since 1999 was illegal as he had crossed mandatory retirement age of 60 years by then. The Bangladesh Service Rules 1993, which made retirement age of 60 years mandatory, was applicable to all, it added. "The service rules passed in 2001for managing directors is beyond legal jurisdiction. It is not harmonised with the main law — the ordinance that created Grameen Bank. It was passed without amending the Bangladesh Service Rules 1993 in order to legitimate the activities of the managing director." "The petitioner's lawyers told the court that the Bangladesh Service Rules 1993 will not be applicable for the time before it was passed but the service rules passed in 2001 for managing directors will be applicable for the time before it was passed in order to legitimise the resolution passed in 1999." The court termed these stances of Yunus' counsels contradictory. The retirement age limit for managing directors was weakened in the resolution passed in 1999. The court stated, "It was mentioned in the appointment approval letter in 1990 that new approval of the Bangladesh Bank will be needed if there is any change in the conditions of the service." It maintained, "Though a new condition about Yunus' age was brought in 1999, it was not approved by the Bangladesh Bank." "His (Yunus) age of service expired in 1999. It was illegal for him to be in the service as it is now," the court ruled. It mentioned that the central bank was given the authority to take steps in this regard according to the Clause 45 of the Bank Company Act. The order includes that Yunus, in line with the Clause 45(2) of the Bank Company Act, had the opportunity to appeal to the central bank against the order to remove him. "He did not take the opportunity." NO CONNECTION WITH NOBEL PRIZE The court observed that services are fixed in line with the Bangladesh Services Rule and other relevant laws. "There is no connection of his service with the Nobel prize," it added. Talking to the media, attorney general Mahbubey Alam said the High Court declared legal the two letters of the central bank ordering removal of Yunus from his position in Grameen Bank. Citing that Yunus did not get Nobel prize as the managing director of Grameen Bank, Alam said the High Court order has no connection with the Nobel prize. bdnews24.com/sn/ach/ost/nir/2043h
Related Stories