Published :
03 Sep 2011, 01:07 PM
Updated :
10 Aug 2022, 05:22 PM
Dhaka, Sept 3 (bdnews24.com) — Muhammad Yunus was expecting a mediator would resolve issues with the government to keep his control over Grameen Bank and the US was soliciting the case, according to leaked US diplomatic cables.
Prime minister Sheikh Hasina and foreign minister Dipu Moni had made clear about their distrust on Yunus and claimed he had been engaged in corrupt practices at Grameen Bank, Chargé d'Affaires of the US embassy in Dhaka Nicholas Dean said in a cable sent in November 2009 and leaked by whistleblower WikiLeaks on Aug 30.
Dean reasoned Yunus' ties to the military-backed recent caretaker government and his brief contemplation of a role in Bangladesh politics behind the Awami League disdain.
"A prophet has no honor in his own country, at least as far as Nobel Peace Laureate Muhammad Yunus and Bangladesh's Awami League government is concerned," the cable reads.
He said some of the military-backed caretaker government approached Yunus about setting up a political party as an alternative to two major parties —the Awami League and the Bangladesh Nationalist Party (BNP).
"Yunus briefly flirted with a political bid, but quickly decided he, and Grameen Bank, were better off remaining outside politics," Dean cabled.
He said the prime minister's refusal to ratify an ordinance that transferred the power to appoint Grameen Bank chairman from the government to bank's board of directors made it clear that 'the Awami League government was not interested in helping professor Yunus or Grameen Bank'.
The US embassy official said the government was planning to reclaim 1,000 ponds leased to the Grameen Fisheries that said 'it transformed the poorly-run, government-owned fish ponds into viable operations that support more than 10,000 families'.
Fearing that the government's displeasure with him would endanger the bank, Yunus requested the US ambassador to mediate the issue on behalf of him and the bank, he said.
Hasina, however, expressed 'her estrangement from Yunus and nodded her agreement when an advisor in a Nov5 meeting with ambassador James F Moriarty characterised Yunus as ungrateful for the Grameenphone deal that she had made possible', Dean said.
He also said that the prime minister 'theatrically rolled her eyes and shook her head' when she heard that US Ambassador-at-Large for Global Women's Issues Melanne Verveer would meet Yunus.
Dean said that Hasina felt 'Yunus had exercised poor judgment by courting military officers who had presented Yunus the possibility of coming to power through military backing in early 2007'.
"Perhaps we don't work together. But we don't stop him. When I was in Sweden (recently), Yunus was there and we exchanged hands. It is our family tradition," Dean quoted Hasina as saying in the meeting.
When Verveer on Nov 11 noted Grameen's good work and Yunus' plans to start a nursing school in Bangladesh, the prime minister said her government was ready to help anyone for the cause.
The foreign minister had a litany of complaints against Yunus in another meeting the next day.
She complained about the high interest rates Grameen Bank charges its clients and alleged that the bank used "vicious practices" to recruit clients and obtain loan payments.
On the same day, ambassadors Verveer and Moriarty relayed the government complaints to Yunus, 'who said they echoed much of what he was hearing from his sources'.
He disputed all the allegations, noting that Grameen had nearly 8 million borrowers and had disbursed $8 billion in loans since its inception, more than 95 percent of which had been repaid.
He said he and Grameen Bank complied with all laws, including annual audits, but he was ousted this year for that he had been re-appointed illegally.
About the politics in Bangladesh during the caretaker government's regime, Yunus told the ambassadors that Hasina's attitude was, "you're either with me or against me'.
Dean noted that BNP chairperson Khaleda Zia adopted a much friendlier tone towards Yunus.
For 'both Hasina and Dipu were not willing to meet him', Yunus said he had hoped someone would be able to help him getting licences or government approval to launch new business.
Dean commented that Yunus' connection with politics was the biggest problem to Hasina and Dipu with him.
"The unwillingness of the prime minister and the foreign minister to accept positive statements about Yunus from us means that for the time being we must find other ways to support the work of Grameen. Perhaps our efforts are best directed at specific Grameen projects, many of which include US companies or organisations as partners," he said.
"We will also continue to work with potential mediators such as PM Foreign Policy Advisor and longtime Yunus confidante Dr. Gowher Rizvi," he added.
bdnews24.com/ost/jr/bd/1808h.