Dhaka, Sep 2 (bdnews24.com)—Whistle-blowing website WikiLeaks has accused London-based daily The Guardian of 'recklessly' leaking thousands of unedited US diplomatic cables on the Internet.
Founded by Julian Assange, the website that caused a stir by releasing US diplomatic cables on the Internet suffered a security breach and said it was preparing to take legal action.
"A Guardian journalist has, in a previously undetected act of gross negligence or malice, and in violation of a signed security agreement with the Guardian's editor-in-chief Alan Rusbridger, disclosed top secret decryption passwords to the entire, unredacted, WikiLeaks Cablegate archive," WikiLeaks said in a statement on Thursday released via Twitter.
It said investigative reporter David Leigh had revealed a password needed to unlock the files in a book about WikiLeaks published by the Guardian earlier this year.
The Guardian, in a statement, dismissed the allegations, pointing out that the book was published last February.
Ian Katz, Deputy Editor of the Guardian, however, had admitted in December 2010 meeting that this condition was not being followed by the Guardian, according to the WikiLeaks statement.
Thousands of the cables had previously been published, but many of those cables had been carefully redacted to protect the names of individuals who consulted with American diplomats and who could, US officials said, be put at risk in their home countries if their involvement with the Americans became known.
German daily Der Spiegel was among the first news organisations to acquire the cables last year, and as a result, claims to know exactly how "a series of mistakes made by several different people" add up to "a catastrophe."
According to the account, those people include not only Assange and Guardian reporter David Leigh, but also the head of a breakaway faction of WikiLeaks, Daniel Domscheit-Berg, who took a dataset off a WikiLeaks server that, unknown to him, included the cables.
Assange should have removed the dataset from the server, Der Spiegel suggests, but apparently failed to do so.
It is not clear exactly when WikiLeaks discovered the security breach. But in the last week, WikiLeaks has dramatically sped up the publication of the diplomatic cables. Before last week, the website had released less than 10 percent of the entire cache. As of Wednesday evening, more than 140,000 had been released, more than half of the entire cache.
In a statement explaining the sudden rush to publish, WikiLeaks said it was part of its "commitment to maximising impact, and making information available to all" -- inviting the public to "crowdsource" the files and post their findings on Twitter as a form of public journalism.
WikiLeaks denies it is responsible for the security breach. In an earlier Twitter posting, WikiLeaks said: "There has been no 'leak at WikiLeaks'. The issue relates to a mainstream media partner and a malicious individual."
GUARDIAN REFUTES CHARGES
The Guardian has described this information as meaningless, because by the time the book was published, the password had long since expired.
"It's nonsense to suggest the Guardian's WikiLeaks book has compromised security in any way," the newspaper said. "It contained a password, but no details of the location of the files, and we were told it was a temporary password which would expire and be deleted in a matter of hours.
"If anyone at WikiLeaks had thought this compromised security, they have had seven months to remove the files," it argued.
Leigh described the accusations as nonsense in an e-mail to the AP news agency. "I don't see how a member of the public could access such a file anyway, unless a WikiLeaks or ex-WikiLeaks person tells them where it is located and what the file was called."
Little detail is known about the unnamed German, except that WikiLeaks has accused this individual of spreading the password for monetary gain.
PROTECT THE INNOCENT
Until this leak, WikiLeaks had worked with a number of partner media organisations and human rights groups to release files that had been edited to remove information that it believed could endanger innocent individuals.
Still, the release of redacted filed was criticised by US officials in particular when WikiLeaks began doing so nine months ago. Now Washington says it greatest fears about this practice have been realised.
From there, the tale gets even more tangled after WikiLeaks disseminated a compressed version of the dataset using a file-sharing program known as BitTorrent. Says Der Spiegel:
BitTorrent is decentralized. Data which ends up on several other computers via the site can essentially no longer be recalled. As a result, WikiLeaks supporters had in their possession the entire dataset that Domscheit-Berg took off the WikiLeaks server, including the hidden data file. Presumably thousands of WikiLeaks sympathizers -- and, one supposes, numerous secret service agents -- now had copies of all previous WikiLeaks publications on their hard drives. At that point, it was only a matter of time before a user realized that the dataset included the cables.
And while the data remained encrypted, they could be decrypted with the password.
That password could be found in the Guardian's book.
"The Guardian disclosure is a violation of the confidentiality agreement between WikiLeaks and Alan Rusbridger, editor-in-chief of the London-based newspaper, signed July 30, 2010.
David Leigh is also Alan Rusbridger's brother in law, which has caused other Guardian journalists to claim that David Leigh has been unfairly protected from the fallout. It is not the first time the WikiLeaks security agreement has been violated by the Guardian," WikiLeaks said.
In its Twitter feed, the group asked supporters whether it should release all the cables itself at this point, making it easier for them to be found.
EMERGENCY MEASURES
Two weeks ago, when it was discovered that information about the Leigh book had spread so much that it was about to be published in the German weekly Freitag, WikiLeaks took emergency action, asking the editor not allude to the Leigh book, and tasked its lawyers to demand those maliciously spreading its details about the Leigh book stop, the statement said.
The whistleblower also says it contacted the US State Department to warn it of the breach. According to the statement, WikiLeaks personnel spoke for 75 minutes with a State Department legal advisor by phone, in the hope that the US government would be able to warn any sources that may be put in danger by the now-public cables.
State Department spokesperson Victoria Nuland said on Thursday that "WikiLeaks did advise us of the impending release of information and of its intention to continue to release classified documents."
"We have made clear our views and concerns about illegally disclosed classified information and the continuing risk to individuals and national security that such releases cause," Nuland said.
"WikiLeaks has, however, ignored our requests not to release or disseminate any US documents it may possess and has continued its well-established pattern of irresponsible, reckless, and frankly dangerous actions. We are not cooperating with them," he added.
bdnews24.com/pks/bd/0100h
WIKILEAKS EXPOSÉ: Bangladesh