Published :
08 Jul 2013, 07:00 PM
Updated :
09 Aug 2022, 10:53 AM
A Parliament Secretariat press release on Monday said Rejwan Ahmed Toufiq won the Kishoreganj-4 by-election by bagging 153,000 votes, while his lone rival Syed Muhitul Islam got 59,070 votes.
The Secretariat furnished this data in its statement on the oath-taking of the new MP.
However, according to the returning officer for the parliamentary by-polls, Rejwan got 99,933 votes and Mohitul 59,224 ballots.
Election Commission Deputy Secretary Mihir Sarwar Morshed, who was monitoring the by-poll results, said a few TV channels showed that the winning candidate had picked up 150,000 votes.
“Later, the TV channel said informed that he got 100,051 or 100,053 votes. Again, some TV channels showed that the winning candidate in the Gazipur (City Corporation) polls had got over 400,000 votes, which had no consistency with the information given by the returning officer,” he said.
The Election Commission fears that any quarter can raise questions over the poll results in future because of such varying information.
According to the returning officer for the Gazipur civil polls, ‘television’ symbol of 18-Party alliance-backed candidate M A Mannan secured 365,444 votes, while ‘inkpot-pen’ of 14-party combine-picked contestant Azmat Ullah Khan got 258,867.
TV journalist Tushar Abdullah told bdnews24.com: “After midnight, it was seen that, suddenly, Ekattor Television started informing the viewers that inkpot-pen bagged 312,000 votes in (all) 392 centres and ‘television’ 468,000 votes. Desh Television and Independent Television ran the same figures in breaking news.”
He said: “Quoting unconfirmed sources, different TV channels showed different results. There was hardly any consistency among them in stating the number of centres and votes.”
Bashing TV channels for showing confusing results, Returning Officer for Kishoreganj-4 by-polls Zahid Hossain said: “(We) announced the unofficial results of all centres around 3am. (But we) heard various media outlets were saying from the evening that the winning candidate bagged 156,000 votes and the defeated one 60,000 votes.”
The official is embarrassed by such varying results quoting ‘unconfirmed sources’. Election Commissioner Md Zabed Ali sought explanation from him over differences in poll results.
Zahid said: “The media should not use any result without verification. The Election Commission has to take measures over the matter considering its future impact.”
Urging the media to present only the results announced by the returning officer, he said: “Otherwise, there may be row over any future election in the country. And we’ll be at risk.”
Former Chief Election Commissioner ATM Shamsul Huda stressed the need for investigation into the publication of such varying results in Kishoreganj.
He said: “The media can collect results from polling centres as results are published from there. It takes some time for the results to reach the returning officer, and they need to carry out some formalities. But the media should not publish any result based on assumption or without verification.”
The former top election official said: “Presiding officers announced centre-based results. And returning officer’s information is final. Then why hasn’t counting been correct. Investigation is needed to find out how results from the returning officer and that used by the media vary.”
Huda initiated a move to formulate a guideline for the media in light of the election code of conduct but gave it up midway amid opposition from media professionals.
Following the latest use of varying results in the Gazipur civic polls, reporters on Sunday asked incumbent Chief Election Commissioner Kazi Rakibuddin Ahmad if the EC would formulate any guideline on presenting election results. He said: “There is guideline on publishing election results. The commission will not do anything separately.”
Returning officer for the Gazipur polls Matiar Rahman denied comments on the use of different results by the media.
He, however, said: “We get in trouble if there is any error in information. It creates distrust among the candidates and the people.”
‘It’s media’s failure’
Journalism teacher and Dhaka University Vice Chancellor AASM Arefin Siddique said it was the failure of the media if they presented confusing results of the polls.
He said: “Competition in the media is universal. But presenting correct information is also important apart from promptness in delivering information.”