UP reps cynical about capacity-building
They say they are 'caught between parliamentarians and bureaucrats' and have been 'stripped of their power'.
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
04 Jun 2012, 01:52 PM
Updated :
09 Aug 2022, 03:51 PM
Dhaka, June 4 (bdnews24.com) – After nearly two and a half years of the Upazilla Parishad elections, the Local Government Division has undertaken a project with support of development partners to strengthen the much-talked about institutional capacities.
The government sees the Upazilla Governance Project 'instrumental' in transforming Upazilla Parishads into 'fully functional, democratic and transparent' entities, but the public representatives remain skeptical.
They allege they are 'caught between parliamentarians and bureaucrats' and cannot act as they have been 'stripped of their power' by the amended Upazilla Parishad Act 2011.
Local Government and Rural Development Minister Syed Ashraful Islam said they would like to see the local government system strengthened, but admitted 'it's difficult'.
"We don't have the history. We don't have the expertise," the Minister who is also the General Secretary of the ruling Awami League, said while opening the new project in the capital on Sunday.
He blamed the military governments and military-backed governments' dominance in the government for 'crippling' Upazilla system, introduced by General H M Ershad's regime in the 1980s.
He alleged that the last military-backed caretaker government used local government to what he said 'perpetrate their illegal activities'.
"We are trying to overcome the history and the legacy," he said.
The past military-backed caretaker government led by Fakhruddin Ahmed revised the 1998 Upazila Parishad Act, doing away with the provision that required the upazila chairmen to consult local MPs in running the councils.
Coming into power, Awami League instead of ratifying the 2008 ordinance revived the 1998 Act and revised it in 2011, drawing flaks from local government experts.
One of the key debates of the 2011 revised Act was making Upazilla Nirbahi Officers (UNOs) chief executives of the Upazila Parishads. Earlier, UNOs played the role of secretaries at the local councils, but the 2011 Act annulled the post without clarifying who will be the secretary.
It mentioned that UNO would provide secretarial assistance to Upazilla Parishads, but experts say the Act did not define secretarial support.
The LGRD Minister said they had changed the law as they wanted to empower local government bodies. "And every level of government has a very effective role in this regard," he maintained.
He emphasised financial independence of local government bodies that he believed 'would guarantee the real independence of local government.' He stressed on their generating own budgets and spend it effectively.
As councilors at Union Parishads, the lowest tier of the local government, demanded magistracy power recently, Syed Ashraf questioned their knowledge about it.
"How can they ask for it? Are there any public representatives with magistracy power? I don't have that. The Prime Minister does not have. Public representatives cannot have magistracy power."
"I hope they would place a revised demand," he said.
The $ 19.31 million five-year Upazilla Governance Project will be funded by the European Union, Swiss Agency for Development and Cooperation, UNDP and UNCDF.
The project aims at strengthening capacities of Upazilla Parishads, ensuring governance, helping in poor-friendly services and achieving targets of Millennium Development Goals and helping the councils to make transparent and participatory budget and plans.
The project will work in all 485 Upazilas or sub-districts to strengthen their capacities while 14 piloted Upazilla Parishads will get special allocations to formulate their own budget.
A steering committee headed by the Secretary to Local Government Division will oversee the project that will also received advices from civil society representatives.
"Our goal is to transform results and to make (Upazila Parishads) more functional and democratically transparent," Stefan Priesner, Country Director of UNDP said.
He suggested full implementation of local government-related laws and said the secretarial role in Upazila Parishad needed to be defined.
Local Government Division Secretary Abu Alam Md Shahid Khan said the government let local leadership flourish through the Jan 2010 Upazilla Parishad elections.
"Now we have started a project to strengthen it. I would not say it will be a smooth journey. As we started, you will see what we can do."
Vice-chairman of Gobindaganj Upazilla under Gaibandha, Mohammad Hossain Foku who came to attend the first workshop, however, does not see much in the new project.
"We are caught between MPs and bureaucrats," he told bdnews24.com.
"Even if you follow the Minister's (Syed Ashraf) speech today, what message he really wanted to send across? Public representatives have no minimum knowledge. They don't know what they want?
Foku criticised Syed Ashraf for talking about the Union Parishad Councilors' demand of magistracy in the Upazilla Parishad forum.
He alleged that they were facing obstacles during execution.
"We are not getting what we need and even what the law entitled us. The government always tries to please bureaucrats. They think it will only help them," he said
bdnews24.com/nih/bd/1901h