November 21, 2026

Tricked into talking, but not for free

Deception is the name of the game, or so it seems. Take "My Choice", the latest Grameen Phone product, and do some simple arithmetic.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 01 Mar 2005, 06:00 PM

Updated : 17 Aug 2022, 08:15 PM

Advisory .. intro and headline changed Dhaka, March 2 (BDNEWS) – Deception is the name of the game, or so it seems. Take "My Choice", the latest Grameen Phone product, and do some simple arithmetic. Subscribers say the mobile phone giant has resorted to just another unfair marketing trick. Yes, a subscriber can enjoy more talk time using a Tk 300 pre-paid card of the old system than availing the call charge advantages offered in newly introduced My Choice . Though Grameen Phone has highly publicised the reduced call charge benefits, the GP will deduct Tk 25 from the new card as soon as a subscriber sends an SMS to GP meaning he is willing to avail "My Choice" even before he starts enjoying the reduced call charge benefits offered in the new programme. After that the subscriber can make phone calls at a rate of Tk 4.50 per minute from any Grameen mobile for a month. But these elements of deal have been kept secret. It is learnt that there is a jugglery in the calculation made by the GP. In the new 'My Choice' offer the GP charges Tk 25 for 'My Choice' Registration in addition to Tk two for sending SMS while Tk 4.50 is charged as value added tax (VAT). All these are deducted simultaneously. According to this calculation, to benefit from 'My Choice' a subscriber has to pay a total of Tk 31.50 (Tk 25 + Tk 2 + Tk 4.50) per month. It means a Tk 300 card is left with Tk 268.50 from which again Tk .675 is taken as value added tax. Thus the call rate in reality stands at Tk Tk 5.175 (4.50 + .Tk .675). With Tk 268.50 a subscriber can talk for a maximum of 51.40 minutes. A comparative analysis between "My Choice" and existing Grameen tariffs show that earlier the call charge stood at Tk 6.90 including VAT. A subscriber could talk for 43.47 minutes using a Tk 300 card (Tk 300 divided by Tk 6.90). But in all 15 additional calls could be made every month even if a subscriber makes only two calls a day. If the subscriber talks for one minute in each call the charge stands at Tk 45. It means in the previous system a subscriber could talk for 58.47 minutes using a Tk 300 card but in "My Choice" programme he can talk for 51.40 minutes. When contacted by BDNEWS, Grameen Phone General Manager (Public Relations) Yamin Bakht said he would get back with his company's version but eventually did not return the call. zn/br/mir/eh/1702 hrs
Related Stories