Published : 14 Nov 2012, 07:18 PM
Updated : 09 Aug 2022, 04:30 PM
A prosecution witness against BNP MP Salauddin Quader Chowdhury on Wednesday said he had heard that the BNP leader, along with an accomplice, had tortured one Mahbubul Alam virtually to death during the Liberation War in 1971.
The 16th prosecution witness against the six-time Chittagong MP said the victim had been made to lie down on a bed of nails and thereafter tortured.
Faiz Ahmed Siddiqui told the three-judge International Crimes Tribunal-1 that the BNP policymaker and one Syed Wahidul Alam had led the torture at Salauddin Quader's ancestral home of Goods Hill that eventually led to Mahbub's death.
The tribunal, set up to deal with crimes against humanity during the War of Independence, indicted Salauddin Quader on Apr 4 for 23 war crimes charges.
The witness explained that Wahidul Alam was a former leader of the ruling Awami League's student front Chhatra League and had joined the Convention Muslim League — led by Salauddin's father Fazlul Quader Chowdhury, also a former Speaker of Pakistan and acting President — when the war broke out on Mar 25, 1971.
Siddiqui said that Salauddin Quader was said to have become a leader of the Muslim League faction led by his father, and controlled affairs at Goods Hill. Mahbubul Alam, the victim, on the other hand was a member of the Communist Party's student wing Chhatra Union in Chittagong.
The witness said citing a deceased acquaintance that Mahbubul Alam, a Vice President of Rangunia College, was abducted from a tea stall near the end of July and taken to Goods Hill where he was tortured to death.
The witness said, "I had heard all this from Harun Contractor — named after what his profession— a leader of the Convention Muslim League."
The witness said that this Muslim Leaguer used to visit the Goods Hill daily and that was how he had apparently come to know about innocent people being tortured there as well as Mahbub's death.
'I am sorry!'
Once done with the deposition, Prosecutor Sultan Mahmud proceeded to have the witness identify Salauddin Quader Chowdhury.
"Do you recognise this Salauddin Quader you spoke of?" the prosecutor asked.
Faiz Ahmed Siddiqui lowered his head a little, as it transpired later, to make eye contact with the accused sitting in the dock.
He first raised his hand greeting the BNP leader and said with a meek smile, "I am sorry!"
"Why are you sorry?" bellowed Salauddin Quader. "You did not have to come here and lie!"
The defence lawyers sitting close to the witness box were also heard mumbling to the witness, at which the witness suddenly said, "Not a single word is a lie."
There was an appeal to the tribunal that it was getting out of hand and the tribunal asked the defence to restrain themselves, at which the accused said in his booming voice indicating the witness, "Well, he started it."
Witness dignity
Defence counsel Ahsanul Huq proceeded to cross-examine the witness but his opening volley was blocked by the tribunal.
"How many times have you married?" the SQ Chowdhury's lawyer had asked.
The witness looked at the tribunal and said, "I don't think this has any relevance with my deposition."
The tribunal agreed and said the question would not be allowed.
This would not be the last time that the counsel asked questions of a personal nature.
Obviously referring to witness' claim of being in private service, the counsel suggested that Siddiqui had never told the investigator that he had a job.
The witness began to say, "But that does not mean that…" and the tribunal was quick to draw the implication and took down his answer.
"What is your TIN number?" asked the counsel meaning the individual tax identification numbers given to taxpayers. The witness said he did not have a TIN.
The counsel then suggested that the witness did not go to school with the victim, Mahbubul Alam at any time, to which the witness said he did not.
But when the counsel that the witness did not even know Mahbub, Siddiqui retorted, "I did indeed!" and proceeded to say how and where they had been together but the court did not record them.
Siddiqui said he knew Mahbub rather well. The counsel then asked how many siblings Mahbub had, and the witness said, "I don't know."
When asked, the witness admitted that he did not see Mahbub being hauled up to the Goods Hill or being brought down from there.
The witness also admitted that he never saw that table with nails on which Mahbub was tortured.
Ahsanul Huq asked whether there were any papers or documents substantiating the claim that Harun Contractor paid daily visit to the Goods Hill and the witness said he did not know.
Siddiqui went on to point out, "I have already said in my deposition that I had heard all that I stated."
"It was all hearsay," the counsel repeated for the benefit of the tribunal.
He then went on to suggest that there was no such Rangunia College VP by the name of Mahbub, which the witness said was not true.
The defence counsel went on to suggest that this Mahbub had in fact stood against the liberation struggle and fled to Pakistan soon after the war ended. "He has gotten married and lives happily with his family in Karachi," suggested Ahsanul Huq.
The witness began to protest and the tribunal noted that he had disagreed with the defence proposition.
When the defence counsel suggested that no such Mahbub, as the one mentioned by the witness, existed and was merely a figment of imagination, Siddiqui said, "Of course not!"
SQ Chy in ICT
The prosecution submitted formal charges against Salauddin Quader on Nov 14, 2011 and the tribunal took them into cognisance three days later.
A former prime ministerial adviser on parliamentary affairs when BNP chief Khaleda Zia was in office, the Chittagong MP was shown arrested for war crimes charges on Dec 20, 2010, five days after his arrest.
The investigating agency submitted a 119-page report with around 8,000-page data to the chief prosecutor on Oct 3 in a bid to prove allegations of war crimes during the 1971 Liberation War.
The BNP leader was indicted on Apr 4 on 23 counts of war crimes.