Speaker's offence tantamount to sedition: HC
A High Court justice has stated that the parliament speaker has committed an offence tantamount to 'sedition' by passing 'negative' remarks against a High Court verdict during the ongoing House session.
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
05 Jun 2012, 05:23 PM
Updated :
09 Aug 2022, 03:51 PM
Dhaka, Jun 5 (dbnews24.com) — A High Court justice has stated that the parliament speaker has committed an offence tantamount to 'sedition' by passing 'negative' remarks against a High Court verdict during the ongoing House session.
Judge AHM Shamsuddin Chowdhury made the statement during the hearing of a petition on Tuesday when lawyer Manzil Morshed drew the court's attention to a news report containing a comment of Speaker Abdul Hamid.
The court of judges Chowdhury and Jahangir Hossain was hearing the petition regarding handing over of land by Roads and Highways Department.
Regarding a High Court order given to Roads and Highways Department to return land to the Supreme Court, the speaker on May 29 had said: "People may stand against the judiciary if they become aggrieved by court orders."
The speaker had made the comment following a statement made by lawmaker from Rajshahi-6 constituency Shahriar Alam about the High Court order.
Criticising the statement, the justice said: "He (the speaker) is instigating the people against the Supreme Court and the government. It's tantamount to sedition."
The justice questioned the speaker's possession of certificate as a lawyer even after making 'degrading' statement about judiciary.
"He (the speaker) had not sent any rejoinder to the report published in a newspaper," he said.
The aggrieved judge continued: "Speaker had said he would have asked the law minister for taking measures had he (the minister) been present in parliament. It means he (the speaker) wants to chain the court."
"The Supreme Court is not controlled by any minister or authority," the justice added.
"If a court can accuse someone with sedition just because he had written about rising of a third power, he (the speaker) has committed an offence more grievous than that," the justice said.
"He (the speaker) had talked in an unparliamentary language. How can he make such a statement being the third powerful man of a country? He has brought parliament and court into confrontation. He should have understood that it would be harmful for the state."
"He (the speaker) has failed to uphold his dignity. He has undermined parliament by breaking its rules."
Justice Chowdhury also questioned whether the speaker had 'knowledge' about the constitution.
"He who cannot uphold the dignity of his position does not have the merit to hold the post. We are surprised at the role of the speaker."
Commenting on the role of a court, the justice said: "There is no scope for discussing a case under trial. The Supreme Court is the third pillar of the constitution. The constitution has given the court the role of guardianship. The High Court will never take a decision that may put the constitution and the state in danger."
At this stage, the justice asked lawyer Amir Khasru and ruling AL MP Nur Islam Sujan, "Can a minister punish us?"
They replied in the negative.
The court, however, refrained from passing an order in this regard following the lawmaker's request and for the sake of 'speaker's honour'.
bdnews24.com/aha/mmr/eh/ssr/nir/2321h