November 21, 2026

SIXTH FIVE-YEAR PLANOutsourcing decision was 'not fully transparent'

A meeting of the panel of economists on the government's five-year plan held the view that the decision to contract a private research organisation to formulate the plan's draft was not taken in a fully transparent manner.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 01 Jul 2010, 05:47 PM

Updated : 11 Aug 2022, 02:20 PM

Abdullah Al Muyid Dhaka, July 01 (bdnews24.com) —A meeting of the panel of economists on the government's five-year plan held the view that the decision to contract a private research organisation to formulate the plan's draft was not taken in a fully transparent manner. While one economist had threatened to quit over the matter, others said that the panel was not consulted about this decision of the Planning Commission. The commission, which is the government agency dealing with the matter, contracted the Police Research Institute (PRI) of Bangladesh to in May to draw up a draft of the sixth five-year strategy. Dr Wahiduddin Mahmud, the chair of the panel, told bdnews24.com, "We were not involved in the decision to contract this firm." Earlier on Wednesday, a member of the panel threatened to resign over this decision. Dr Muinul Islam, an economics professor of Chittagong University, told at a discussion that he was disappointed with the decision to appoint PRI. On Thursday, the panel of economists met at the Planning Commission and discussed this issue. "We will look into the draft and put forward our opinion independently," he told bdnews24.com Thursday. When asked if there is any discontent over the government decision to sub-contract a private institute, Dr Mahmud said, "The panel will give its opinion and advice in every step of the process and will do so independently." However, Muinul Islam told bdnews24.com, "Most of the panel members are unhappy about the decision." "The panel decided to take a collective stand if their advice were not reflected in the plan formulated by the PRI." He also criticised the way the contract has been awarded. "The contract was given in a non-transparent manner", said Islam. According to sources present at the meeting, the panel members had lengthy discussion on the issue and eventually managed to keep Islam from resigning. The sources had said that the panel had one point decided to wait until the draft was actually submitted and would act as they saw fit and at one point of the discussion it was even fleetingly mentioned that the entire panel would resign together, if need be. Shamsul Alam, member secretary of the panel, also a member of the General Economics Division under the Planning Commission, did not take well to Muinul Islam's position. He told bdnews24.com that the contract was awarded in accordance with the procurement act and law of the government. "There is no scope for ambiguity." Referring to professors Islam's comments, Alam said, "Such remarks seriously jeopardise our work and create misunderstanding among the different quarters involved in the process." "The respectable member should have raised that point in the panel meeting." Without mentioning Islam's name, he said, "The way one member has expressed his discontent was not appropriate." "The panel of economists has been appointed to assist, advise and give direction, not to spread confusion." But Islam questioned the neutrality of the research organisation and told bdnews24.com that PRI was closely connected with the World Bank and International Monitory Fund. "I don't think they will be able to deliver anything beyond another extended PRSP," he said, referring to the controversial policy tool imposed upon poor countries by the World Bank. "This is for the first time that an institute has been sub-contracted for the drafting of a five-year plan." Earlier, consultants would work at the Planning Commission under supervision and constant monitoring, he said. But Alam defended the government position. "The work has been awarded to the most capable organisation." When asked about any possibility of a conflict of interest given his involvement, Dr Mahmud, who perceptibly has much influence, pointed to his ignorance of the issue and thus having no role. Although the PRI website (http://pri-bd.org/about.php) lists the economist as a member of its advisory panel, Mahmud denied holding any such position at PRI. In fact, Dr Mahmud asked the bdnews24.com correspondent to describe where exactly on the PRI website he was mentioned and in what nature while denying any strong links with the firm. By way of illustrating potential conflict of interest, quarters have also, however, pointed to the fact that PRI vice-chairman Sadiq Ahmed, a former chief economist for World Bank's South Asia region, happens to be the son-in-law of H T Imam, an adviser to the prime minister. According to a Planning Commission sources, PRI will produce the outline of the plan by Jul 05 and by December this year, the final plan will be ready for review. Bangladesh Institute of Development Studies has been contracted for 18 background studies and ministries are expected to produce reports on their activities and programmes, which will all contribute to the planning process. bdnews24.com/aam/ta/2238h
Related Stories