SC seeks Alems' opinion on fatwa
The apex court wants to hear from Islamic scholars on fatwa to bury the controversy surrounding the issue, once and for all.
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
10 Mar 2011, 11:50 AM
Updated :
10 Aug 2022, 04:27 PM
Dhaka, Mar 10 (bdnews24.com) – The Supreme Court wants to have the opinion of the country's prominent alems (Islamic scholars) on fatwa (religious edict).
The apex court on Thursday directed the Islamic Foundation Bangladesh director general to forward the names of five Alems, who would place their statements either in writing by Mar 21 or by appearing before it on the day.
The hearing was adjourned until Mar 21.
Barrister Abul Kalam Azad appeared for the petitioners against the High Court ban on fatwa, while attorney general Mahbubey Alam represented the state.
Razzak said Islamic scholars were now of the same opinion that the Islamic panel code was not practicable in the present situation. "An Islamic state is essential in this regard."
He mentioned that Hazrat Omar (Ra) had stayed the application of Islamic panel code in special cases.
Citing various instances from the Indian and British Supreme Courts, he said Islamic scholars could pronounce fatwa as per sections 39 and 41 of the Constitution of Bangladesh.
However, the attorney general said the situation in Bangladesh was not the same as in the UK and India.
"One can personally take Alems' opinion for his or her own purpose, but any fatwa which has an impact on society should not be delivered."
In a landmark verdict on Jan 1, 2001, the High Court declared all punishments imposed in the name of fatwa illegal.
The verdict came following a hearing on a suo motu rule issued earlier by the court after a newspaper report on Hilla marriage. (Hilla dictates that a divorced couple cannot remarry before the woman is married to a third person and he divorces her).
Mufti Mohammad Toyeeb and Abul Kalam Azad appealed against the HC verdict with the Supreme Court the same year.
On Feb 14, the High Court appointed 9 senior lawyers as amicus curie to take part in the hearing on the appeal. They are T H Khan, Rafiq-ul-Huq, Rokanuddin Mahmud, Mahmudul Islam, M Zahir, A B M Nurul Islam, A F Hassan Arif, M I Faruqi and Rabeya Bhuiyan.
The apex court started hearing on the appeal on Mar 1 this year.
In the past three days, Dr Kamal Hossain has taken part in the hearing on behalf of Ain O Salish Kendra, while Nazrul Islam participated on behalf of the petitioners, as the court asked both parties to present their arguments.
Fatwa has instigated recurrence of violence, especially against women, in the past. These extrajudicial edicts have included corporal punishments that have resulted in deaths.
Hena, a rape victim, died seven days after being administered 101 lashes in line with fatwa pronounced by an unauthorised village court at Chamta village on Jan 24.
On Feb 26, Islamist leader Fazlul Huq Amini, claimed that no court can ban fatwa. Chairman of a faction of Islami Oikya Jote, Amini threatened a vigorous movement if fatwa was banned.
bdnews24.com/sn/mi/skb/sht/mr/1725h