November 21, 2026

SC backpedals on candidate info verdict

A high drama played out in court Tuesday. The Supreme Court issued an order only to cancel it later in the day. It reversed the verdict that ended the obligation of election candidates to submit personal details and wealth statements to the Election Commission. The court changed its mind after Dr Kamal Hossain weighed in. Dr M Zahir said he had never seen a court give an order in the morning and cancel it in the afternoon.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 20 Feb 2007, 08:11 AM

Updated : 17 Aug 2022, 02:28 PM

Dhaka, Feb 20 (bdnews24.com) – In a rare move, the Appellate Division Tuesday backpedalled on its earlier decision that election candidates do not have to submit personal details and wealth statements to the Election Commission. It all happened in three hours. On May 24, 2005, the High Court ordered the EC to collect information from the candidates for parliamentary polls after public interest litigation by three Supreme Court lawyers, including Abdul Momen Chowdhury. The HC made the provision mandatory to bring transparency to the election process. Dr Kamal Hossain appeared for the writ petitioners. On December 19, vacation chamber judge Joynul Abedin stayed the HC verdict after a petitioner, Abu Safa, appealed against it. In line with rules, the regular bench of the Appellate Division must hear the case after a chamber judge stayed any HC order. The Appellate Division Tuesday accepted the appeal against the HC verdict at 9:45am that made it mandatory for the candidates to submit personal details and wealth statements to the EC. In a dramatic development, the same bench led by chief justice Syed JR Mudassir Husain cancelled its unwritten verdict shortly before 1pm, after Supreme Court lawyers led by Dr Kamal Hossain appealed for the withdrawal of the verdict. Dr Kamal argued that such a verdict would undermine the constitution. After the judges left the courtroom, Dr Kamal, counsel for the three petitioners of public interest litigation, refused to leave the courtroom until the verdict was reviewed. The judges did not come to the courtroom for two and a half hours. Police were called in, expecting tensions on the court premises. COURT DRAMA A high drama played out in court. When the Appellate Division rejected the HC verdict, Dr Kamal weighed in and said the hearing did not touch on the main issue. The court said: "The verdict was to be delivered today and we did it." Dr Kamal said: "A state of emergency is in force. The court cannot hear or give a verdict on an appeal that involves fundamental rights." "The Supreme Court was caught in a fraudulent appeal by a person with no identity. Please review the appeal." The court said: "We have already delivered our verdict." When the judges were about to leave, Dr Kamal said, "You cannot do it." The court said, "Don't create a scene." Dr Kamal took a firmer stand. "I won't leave this place until a hearing is held again. Let police pick me up. Tell the IGP and AG to come. "I will file a sedition case against those who resorted to fraud. This fraud needs to be investigated." Pointing to the judges, he said: "You gave this verdict. Now sentence me to death. And my last wish is, neither of you attends my janaza." Conventionally, the judges return to the courtroom in 10 minutes of the end of one session. But the judges did not come back to the courtroom long after they left at 10.15am. Attorney general Fida M Kamal went to the chief justice's chamber at 10.45am apparently for mediation. An hour later, he came out of the chief justice's chamber and advised Dr Kamal to appeal for withdrawal of the verdict. Dr Kamal did it—instantly. The four judges led by the chief justice returned to the court at 12.45pm—packed with lawyers. Dr Kamal said: "Hang me to save the constitution. The court has been cheated. "The court has to act as the guardian of the constitution. We have nothing left except for the constitution and the Supreme Court." The court listened. "Acting on the appeal for withdrawal of the verdict, the order not yet signed by the court has been withdrawn." Dr Kamal told reporters: "An investigation found petitioner Abu Safa resorted to fraud." "In the appeal he claimed to be an accomplished and popular person. But an investigation found he was away from his wife and children in Swandip for six years." "Abu Safa said he bought nomination papers. He attended classes up to VIII. If he furnishes information he will face discrepancy," Dr Kamal said. Advocate KM Jabir told bdnews24.com: "The judiciary has been saved by withdrawing the verdict. "We hope to get justice." In his 46 years of his career in law, Dr M Zahir said, he had never seen the court give an order in the morning only to cancel it in the afternoon. "This is unprecedented." bdnews24.com/at/eh/jr/ad/2106 hours
Related Stories