November 21, 2026

Sayedee witness kept from proving identity

The 60-year old witness did not have a strand of gray hair to suggest his age.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 03 Oct 2012, 03:59 PM

Updated : 09 Aug 2022, 04:19 PM

Dhaka, Oct 3 (bdnews24.com ) — The seventh defence witness for Jamaat-e-Islami leader Delwar Hossain Sayedee on Wednesday was kept from answering that he did not have any official document to prove his identity. Prosecutor Syed Haider Ali had asked Jamal Hossain Fakir whether he had any documents to prove his identity to the first war crimes tribunal. Sayedee's defence counsel Mizanul Islam said he objected to the question unless his witness' identity was being challenged. The International Crimes Tribunal -1 Chairman Justice Mohammad Nizamul Huq told the prosecutor, "What you could, however, do in this case is attract the tribunal's attention to the appearance and age of the witness." The defence lawyer had objected to the tribunal suggesting what the prosecutor could or could not do. "Only the prosecutor should decide what his course of action might be." However, the tribunal did take note of the witness' appearance. The 60-year old witness did not have a strand of gray hair to suggest his age. Nor did the witness' posture or movements suggest that he had reached the official retirement age. Earlier, the witness had also hinted as much when Haider Ali asked the witness whether he had anything to prove his age. He said he did not and was about to say that people often remarked about his 'young' looks but that part was not taken in the records since it was not asked of him. The tribunal indicted the Jamaat executive council member, Sayedee, on Oct 3 for 20 war crimes charges that include murder, rape, arson and loot in and around the Parerhat area of Pirojpur. The witness, hailing from Nalbunia village of the area, said he witnessed the murder of Ibrahim Kutti at a different location, time and manner from that of the indictment order. The witness also said that Shaheb Ali was taken away with his hands tied at the back. He later came to hear that Shaheb had been taken to Pirojpur and shot dead. This was also different from charges that say that Sayedee had led Pakistani Army to Azahar Ali's house from where they abducted Shaheb and murdered him in Pirojpur. The prosecutor, however, put an end to the matter with a suggestion, "You are not of the age you claim to be and you were only a minor during the war." The witness vehemently denied. The witness had said that he had seen Ibrahim Kutti's body being dragged away by several Razakars early one morning at the house of one Azahar Ali Howladar, who was his neighbour. The indictment order states that on May 8, 1971 at about 3:00pm, Sayedee and his accomplices accompanied by Pakistani Army raided the house of Manik Posari of Chithalia and caught his brother Mofizuddin and Ibrahim Kutti. The order also states that upon Sayedee's instance, his accomplices burnt the house. On their way to the army camp, Sayedee instigated the Paki soldiers and they shot and killed Kutti and dumped the body by the side of a bridge. While Fakir's testimony at the tribunal conformed to some of the details of the indictment order as regards Shaheb Ali's murder, he gave an almost entirely different account of Kutti's murder. This had the prosecutor in a fix, and he mentioned as much too when at the end of the morning session, tribunal member Justice Anwarul Haque asked if he was done. "This is a very complicated matter with two charges intertwined," said prosecutor Haider Ali. Tribunal Chairman Justice Nizamul Huq said, "The question is very simple. And you need only say 'yes' or 'no'." The prosecutor said he would need to ask a few more questions. The prosecutor asked how many Pakistani Army soldiers there were at Azahar Ali's house, and the witness said there were none. "Only Razakars were there." Razakars were a group of vigilante militia actively collaborating with the Pakistani Army during the Liberation War. The prosecutor suggested that the witness had not seen the events unfold as he claimed. The witness said it was all true. Re-examination sparks discussion Defence counsel Mizanul Islam requested that he be allowed to re-examine the witness regarding his age. The seemingly innocuous request triggered a serious discussion among the three judges of the tribunal. The judges first perused the relevant section of the law that allows for witness re-examination and tribunal member Justice Jahangir Hossain said, "As per the section, re-examination requires an application first." The defence counsel quickly pointed out that the tribunal had previously dispensed with that formality and even granted prayers on oral applications before. The tribunal chairman seconded the counsel and began a discussion with his colleagues for several minutes. After a while, the defence counsel said that he withdrew his plea. The tribunal chair replied that they needed to decide on the matter first. After several minutes more, the Justice Huq said, "We have decided. No application is required." The counsel said he would not re-examine the witness but would submit an identity document. "That is of course if I am allowed to." That brought an end to the matter at hand. Defence witness list The tribunal chair then asked whether the defence had further witnesses and Mizanul Islam indicated that he did not. Prosecutor Haider Ali then stood up to repeat a complaint he has been making for a quite some time. "I was informed about the witness the night before around 10pm. It becomes rather difficult to proceed with the cross-examination." Haider Ali also pointed out that the kind of information that he was given was not enough and was about to proceed to show the tribunal that the defence was not abiding by the tribunal's order. Justice Huq said, "This is a matter of law. Although the Act does not say as much we have brought it in the rules of procedure and while we are ignoring some deviations. Now that has all bundled up in your case, since this is the first case. It will not be the case in the cases to come." He then said that the defence had gotten sufficient time to prepare the list of defence witnesses but the defence team were only giving one witness at a time, which the tribunal chair indicated was not desirable. The defence said that the witness had become ill, all of a sudden. Justice Huq said, "Don't make this ground too weak." Justice Jahangir Hossain said, "You know what happened to the boy who cried 'wolf' too many times?" Justice Anwarul Haque, the other tribunal member, said that generally in other criminal cases, there were seldom any defence witnesses. "In case there are, the witnesses are brought by the defence themselves." He said, "But in this case, you can't produce the witnesses on one hand while on the other you want a provision of more witnesses. That is contradictory." The tribunal chief said, "It may be the case that we proceed with just your case putting the other cases on hold and get done with it." Prosecutor Haider Ali said that he needed to have the names of witnesses a day or two before. Justice Huq then cautioned the defence that the tribunal might pass an order that bars it from producing further witnesses. "Don't give us that opportunity." He then had prosecutor fetch Zead-Al-Malum, conducting the war crimes case against Jamaat chief Ghulam Azam. Malum came in several minutes later to say that he did not have his witness ready to be produced in court since the man had left for a hospital for an appointment. This sparked off another round of exchanges with the court expressing its disapproval that there were no witnesses and before rising almost an hour and a half before general closing time, Justice Huq said, "I had said before there would no adjournment on lawyer ground. Now I am saying there will be no more adjournment for sickness ground." First case to trial Sayedee's is the first case to proceed to the trial stage at the war crimes tribunals. The prosecution on Sep 4, 2011 proposed framing of charges against him on 31 counts of crimes against humanity and genocide. The tribunal also sent Jamaat's former chief Ghulam Azam to jail on Jan 11. His indictment hearing began on Feb 15 and the court charged him on May 13. Jamaat chief Matiur Rahman Nizami, Secretary General Ali Ahsan Mohammad Mujaheed and assistant secretaries general Mohammad Kamaruzzaman and Abdul Quader Molla are also behind bars on war crimes charges. Jamaat financier Mir Quasem Ali has been recently arrested for war crimes charges too as investigation continues into allegations against him. BNP MP and standing committee member, Salauddin Quader Chowdhury, also behind bars, was indicted for 23 charges on Apr 4. Former BNP lawmaker and minister Abdul Alim is the only one out on bail. All cases have already entered the trial phase. bdnews24.com/ta/bd/2017h
Related Stories