Published : 21 Nov 2012, 07:25 PM
Updated : 09 Aug 2022, 04:32 PM
Jamaat-e-Islami leader Delwar Hossain Sayedee's lawyer argued on Wednesday that his client was not involved with the torture and murder of one Bhagirathi Saha during the Liberation War.
Presenting his arguments, senior defence counsel Mizanul Islam deliberated on the testimony of Bhagirathi's son Ganesh Chandra Saha and other defence witnesses and pointed to, what he said, inconsistencies in the prosecution's case.
The gruesome execution of 18-year old Bhagirathi, dragged naked around town by a jeep for an hour before she was killed at, what is today called, Bhagirathi Square is one of the 20 war crimes charged that Sayedee has been indicted for.
The three-judge International Crimes Tribunal-1, set up to try crimes against humanity during the 1971 Liberation War, indicted the Jamaat executive council member on Oct 3, 2011.
His charges include murder, rape, arson and loot in Pirojpur where Sayedee has been elected twice as MP.
The defence counsel first pointed out that the witness, originally listed as a prosecution witness, had turned up for the defence after the prosecution claimed that he had gone into hiding, became traceless and thus could not be tracked down or produced.
The prosecution had thereafter been granted a plea whereby it had statements of 15 witnesses received in evidence because some could not be found, while others had apparently fled to India.
Their witnesses, according to police reports submitted by the investigator, had gone into hiding allegedly in fear of reprisals of Sayedee's goons.
Mizanul Islam said that Ganesh's statement did not in any way incriminate Sayedee, although in the statement he had mentioned that people had told him about the Jamaat leader's involvement in his mother's killing.
The prosecution had pointed to Ganesh's age, who could not have been more than four or five years old but according to his own testimony at the court, he would have been around the unlikely age of 12 when his mother died.
This, the prosecution said, was because the witness had been 'gained over' and therefore should be ignored. The prosecution said that Ganesh was being made to say something that might not be completely out of his free will but at the behest of others.
The defence had contended that it could have been a simple mistake and she might not have been 18 but 28 actually. Mizanul Islam said on Wednesday, "It is possible to distinguish between 14 and 24 but not so easy between 18 and 28."
The defence counsel also pointed out that the court had added two cautionary observations when it granted the prosecution's appeal to have the 15 witness statements received as evidence. "The court had mentioned that these people were not under oath when they spoke to the investigator. Neither had they been cross-examined."
He said Bhagirathi must have been dragged around for miles if it were by a vehicle for one hour. "In that case there must have been hundreds of people who saw it. Have all those witnesses gone into hiding that the prosecution could not produce anyone else?"
The counsel then also referred to a website that listed Sayedee as a Razakar, a band of notorious vigilante groups that, along with other similar groups like the Al Badr and Al Shams, is held responsible for widespread atrocities to thwart the liberation effort amounting to war crimes.
The counsel pointed out that the said website did not have the name of Pirojpur Razakar chief, which was a glaring omission especially given that this man was a noted person.
Mizanul Islam questioned the author's honesty, sincerity and thereby the document's authenticity.
"But that person is not before us," said tribunal Chairman, Justice Mohammad Nizamul Huq.
"But the document is before and the prosecution is relying on it," said the defence counsel.
"Then criticise the document, not the person," urged Justice Huq.
The defence counsel said that the list could not be depended upon since it showed obvious flaws while the tribunal said that omission of certain names did not necessarily mean those left out were not Razakars.
That website, Mizanul Islam pointed, listed one Maulana Abdur Rahim as a Pirojpur Razakar. The unlikelihood of East Pakistan Jamaat-e-Islami's founder being on that list was left unsaid, however.
First case to trial
Sayedee's is the first case to proceed to the trial stage in the war crimes tribunals. The prosecution on Sep 4, 2011 proposed framing of charges against him on 31 counts of crimes against humanity.
The tribunal also sent Jamaat's former chief Ghulam Azam to jail on Jan 11. His indictment hearing began on Feb 15 and the court charged him on May 13.
Jamaat chief Matiur Rahman Nizami, Secretary General Ali Ahsan Mohammad Mujaheed and assistant secretaries general Mohammad Kamaruzzaman and Abdul Quader Molla are also behind bars on war crimes charges. Jamaat financier Mir Quasem Ali was also arrested recently on similar charges as investigation continues into allegations against him.
BNP MP and Standing Committee member, Salauddin Quader Chowdhury, also behind bars, was indicted for 23 charges on Apr 4.
Former BNP lawmaker and minister Abdul Alim is the only one out on bail. All cases have already entered the trial phase.