Sayedee counsel hit with embargo
Tajul Islam and two more of his colleagues will have to explain on Nov 22 why legal action should not be taken against them, Tanim Ahmed reports
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
06 Nov 2012, 02:41 PM
Updated :
09 Aug 2022, 04:28 PM
Tanim Ahmed
Dhaka, Nov 6 (bdnews24.com) — The first war crimes tribunal on Tuesday barred defence counsel Tajul Islam until Nov 22, when he and two more of his colleagues have been told to explain why legal action should not be taken against them.
The tribunal's order drew an elaborate picture of what had gone on in the courtroom on Monday outlining the actions and statement of the defence counsels.
Tajul and the two counsels — Mizanul Islam and Tanvir Ahmed Al-Amin — are on the team of defence lawyers for Jamaat-e-Islami's top leaders facing war crimes charges.
Tajul represents the entire Jamaat leadership at both the tribunals, while Mizanul Islam has been handling the trials of Jamaat leaders at the three-judge International Crimes Tribunal-1.
He has also been leading the trial of Jamaat-e-Islami leader Delwar Hossain Sayedee who has been indicted on 20 war crimes charges by the tribunal, set up to deal with crimes against humanity during the Independence War in 1971.
The order came a day after Sayedee's lawyers boycotted the tribunal in, what they said, protest against the tribunal's inaction over 'abduction of witness'.
The three defence counsels will have to give their reply by Nov 22, when Tajul Islam is also expected to submit another reply to a similar show-cause notice for professional misconduct.
Former Law Minister, and currently top leader of BNP, Moudud Ahmed stood on behalf of the Jamaat counsel and prayed for more time at the start of the day. The court allowed him until Nov 22.
Sayedee's counsels had on Monday alleged one of their witnesses —Sukharanjan Bali who was previously listed as a prosecution witness — had been abducted by plainclothesmen and whisked away in a RAB vehicle.
Malum leads the charge
Prosecutor Zead-Al-Malum took the podium before the day's business could begin and urged the court to initiate contempt proceedings against Tajul Islam and Mizanul Islam for their statements and actions of Monday.
He said the abduction of a witness and subsequent actions of the defence were all staged. "Their actions and statements maligned the tribunal and also obstructed the course of justice."
"We, the prosecution, urge the tribunal to initiate proceedings under 11.4," said Malum mentioning the relevant section that provided for punishment for maligning the tribunal or obstructing the proceedings.
The court had been a scene of wild tantrums and derogatory interjections just as it went into lunch recess on Monday. The tribunal had said it would itself look into the alleged abduction after lunch while the defence lawyers, excited and animated, pleaded that the court decide on the matter instantly.
Jamaat's chief counsel Abdur Razzaq and the senior counsel Mizanul Islam had both told the court that they expected the court to direct authorities to produce the abducted witness in the court.
When the tribunal was about rise, Mizanul Islam was trying to submit to the tribunal and point out that the lunch recess may be too long a time for the witness.
In his bid to stress on immediate action, Abdur Razzaq had said about the witness, "He might have been taken to a torture cell by this time."
After hearing the matter the tribunal had directed the chief prosecutor and lead investigator to probe what had actually happened.
Chief prosecutor Ghulam Arieff Tipoo returned sometime later and said he had spoken to a number of senior police officers. And he said according to those policemen no such incident had taken place.
The grumble among the defence lawyers that had been low through the morning had become even more audible at this point with some of the lawyers saying that this was a lie.
The prosecution had said some of its witnesses could not be traced as they had gone incognito in fear of reprisal from the Sayedee's goons around Pirojpur where the accused has been elected an MP twice.
Some others, according to police reports submitted by the investigator, had apparently fled to India and thus could not be produced before the court within a reasonable time.
As a result, statements of 15 witnesses given to the investigator were received in evidence by the tribunal. Sukharanjan Bali was among them.
Razzaq replies
Abdur Razzaq stood up to reply to Malum. He said referring to Malum's citation of media reports that the media reported on a lot of things. "But not all of it is true."
Razzaq went on that Mizanul Islam did not violate any laws and neither did Tajul Islam. He also said that Tajul Islam's statements were not directed at the judges at all.
Tajul Islam had said on Monday, while addressing the press venting his disappointment at the tribunal's actions over the witness abduction, "The tribunal could be involved with the incident in some way."
Another defence counsel explained that the sudden decision to raise security measures around the tribunal premises and the witness abduction on the same day might not have been entirely the workings of chance.
Abdur Razzaq said, "Tajul Islam did not mean the tribunal in any way."
Tribunal Chairman Justice Mohammad Nizamul Huq asked the senior lawyer, "Alright tell me one thing, if Tajul Islam has indeed said what is being said he said, does it amount to contempt?"
Razzaq tried to defend his colleague saying that Tajul could not have said it but Justice Huq stuck to his point and Razzaq said that it would be the court's decision even if he had.
"Does it mean that he had indeed made the statement?" inquired Justice Huq.
Razzaq said, "It is your place to try him but you also choose to ignore a lot of things."
Justice Huq then went on to say that he had seen the CCTV feed of the courtroom and had seen the actions of the counsels.
He then asked Razzaq, "When the Chief Prosecutor stood here and reported back what the police had told him, defence counsels called him a liar. Does that not warrant contempt proceedings?"
Razzaq stood silent.
"You are mum Mr Razzaq. And you must be mum," said Justice Huq.
Razzaq replied, "I say 'much obliged my lord'."
Justice Huq announced that he would give an order at 2pm.
The order
After lunch recess, Justice Huq began to give the order in a rather serious manner and became evidently angry at certain points of the unprecedented order.
He said that besides perusing newspaper articles and clippings, the tribunal had also gone through the CCTV footage and got an idea about what had gone in the court the day before.
Noting Mizanul Islam's submission about the allegedly abducted witness on Monday, the tribunal said in its order that the tribunal, on the counsel's submission, notified the chief prosecutor and the lead investigator of the matter. "They were ordered to go and come back and inform all they could find out."
But during the proceedings, the order noted, "Many black coats — meaning lawyers, not all of whom had the power of attorney or directly involved in any of the cases — stood up. Mr Tajul Islam was standing up every one minute and showing his back to the tribunal."
Justice Huq had noted on Monday that he could see a number of lawyers on the defence side that the tribunal did not really know and were not concerned with the cases.
After the chief prosecutor and the lead investigator returned and reported that the police officers had told them 'no such thing had happened', "At that time Tajul Islam was shouting and said he wanted an order."
"The tribunal said they would also try to get more information and pass an appropriate order after the lunch. At that moment all the black coateers stood up and started shouting," said the order.
"We can at least mention one such name here, Tanvir Ahmed Al-Amin." The order said that there were a number of other such counsels but the tribunal could not identify them.
The order noted that both Tajul Islam and Mizanul Islam called chief prosecutor Ghulam Arieff Tipoo a liar when he reported back what the police had told him.
The order then went on to note Tajul's comment that the tribunal may have been involved with the abduction. "This is nothing but a straight allegation against the tribunal without any basis and amounts to high grade of contempt."
The order noted Tajul was already facing a similar notice and was scheduled to reply in person on that very day. But the counsel had become involved in a more serious and grievous matter.
Justice Huq, delivering the order, said in a stiff voice, "Stern action should be taken against the liable persons for contempt for tarnishing the image of the tribunal."
"We direct Tajul Islam, Mizanul Islam and Tanvir Ahmed Al-Amin to show cause within [Nov 11] as to why [contempt proceedings] shall not be brought against them and dealt with accordingly. We are sorry we could not identify the other but we caution them."
Regarding Tajul's behaviour even while another matter for professional misconduct was pending with the same court, the tribunal said "some more stern action should be taken".
"He is barred from appearing before this tribunal until [Nov 22]."
The order went on to caution Masud Sayedee for walking up and down the court room and said that he was being let off with just the caution because he was not a lawyer.
Justice Huq then said that another line would have to be added to the order saying, "Yesterday was a date for argument and not for witness recording."
The judge had said on Monday, as he went through one of the petitions to allow a witness examination, that had already been stopped in Sayedee's case and the case had moved on to the next phase. The tribunal summarily rejected a few such petitions on Monday.
On Tuesday, prosecutor Syed Haider Ali managed to sum up his case for the fifth charge against Sayedee and was partially through the sixth one.
He is set to resume his argument on Wednesday.
First case to trial
Sayedee's is the first case to proceed to the trial stage in the war crimes tribunals. The prosecution on Sep 4, 2011 proposed framing of charges against him on 31 counts of crimes against humanity.
The tribunal also sent Jamaat's former chief Ghulam Azam to jail on Jan 11. His indictment hearing began on Feb 15 and the court charged him on May 13.
Jamaat chief Matiur Rahman Nizami, Secretary General Ali Ahsan Mohammad Mujaheed and assistant secretaries general Mohammad Kamaruzzaman and Abdul Quader Molla are also behind bars on war crimes charges. Jamaat financier Mir Quasem Ali was also arrested recently on similar charges as investigation continues into allegations against him.
BNP MP and Standing Committee member, Salauddin Quader Chowdhury, also behind bars, was indicted for 23 charges on Apr 4.
Former BNP lawmaker and minister Abdul Alim is the only one out on bail. All cases have already entered the trial phase.
bdnews24.com/ta/bd/1940h