November 21, 2026

Sangram convicted for court contempt

A war crimes tribunal sentences editor-publisher and reporter to token jail terms and fines them both Tk 5,000. Full Story

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 26 Apr 2012, 07:27 AM

Updated : 09 Aug 2022, 03:43 PM

Tanim Ahmed Dhaka, Apr 26 (bdnews24.com) -- In its first conviction, the war crimes tribunal on Thursday sentenced the Daily Sangram editor-publisher and the newspaper's Feni correspondent to a token prison term and fined them Tk 5,000 each. The prison term, however, lasted a few minutes, since the order stated that the two journalists "suffer simple imprisonment till the rising of the court". The International Crimes Tribunal-1, set up on Mar 25, 2010 to deal with crimes against humanity, gave the order convicting the two persons of contempt. The Bengali daily, a mouthpiece of Jamaat-e-Islami, had published a statement of some lawyers in Feni. The court found that the statement, as published in the newspaper, was "highly contemptuous", calling the tribunal a "partisan court" and demanding that it be dissolved and replaced by a neutral one. The Feni lawyers were excused because the tribunal said they could not be directly linked with the statement and therefore, were given the "benefit of doubt". But the Sangram editor Abul Asad or the daily's Feni correspondent A K M Abdur Rahim could not escape from the liability of being party to contempt. Both were given 15 days' time to deposit Tk 5,000 each to the exchequer, by May 13. In default, both the journalists are liable to suffer simple imprisonment of 15 days. Chairman of the three-judge tribunal, Justice Mohammad Nizamul Huq started giving the order around noon after adjourning the case against Jamaat executive council member Delwar Hossain Sayedee until May 7 as the defence counsel had requested earlier. The affability in his voice vanished the moment he began giving the contempt order. Justice Huq, in his stiff voice, outlined the arguments put forward by all the parties involved in the case – Asad, Abdur Rahim and nine lawyers of Feni court. What happened! A report of Sangram, dated Apr 2, said certain lawyers of Feni Bar Association had stated that the tribunal, by accepting statements of 15 witnesses given to the investigation officer in the case against Sayedee, had proved that it was a partisan tribunal. The report had them demanding that the partisan International Crimes Tribunal (1) be dissolved immediately and replaced with a more neutral panel of judges. The report cited the lawyers saying that the Evidence Act did not allow any statement given to police to be admitted in court as evidence. The court stated in its order that these statements were indeed contemptuous and further stated that the law of the tribunal, the International Crimes Tribunals Act (ICTA) of 1973, in fact, allowed the court to receive as evidence such statements given to the investigation officer, who may or may not be a policeman, if it takes unreasonably long time or requires high costs to produce those witnesses before the court. This provision, Section 19.2 of the ICTA, allows this measure if witnesses have died since they spoke to the investigation officer. The prosecution had moved the court to receive statements of 46 witnesses, but the court only approved the prayer for 15 witnesses who were either very ill, traceless or had moved to India, according to local police reports. Appearing for the first time after being elected as president of the Supreme Court Bar Association, Zainul Abedin on Apr 16 had submitted by way of an explanation that the Feni lawyers had not even issued the statement in the first place. Second, he had submitted that Sangram's Feni correspondent did not file the report, but someone had apparently hacked into Abdur Rahim's account and sent the report "purporting to be" the correspondent. Thus, Abdur Rahim's plea was that he was not at all involved with the report. As such, the reporter said that he be discharged in light of his unqualified apology. Abedin argued that publication of the report in question was an honest mistake and none of the respondents meant to lower the dignity of the court or obstruct the functions of the tribunal. Judge A K M Zaheer Ahmed had then asked the counsel that such an explanation was not enough. "This leaves a lot of questions unanswered." The tribunal member then asked the counsel whether the reporter had subsequently blocked the account, or how someone else could have secured the password for his personal mail account. The tribunal member had also pointed out that this report was then posted on social media network Facebook, further spreading the contemptuous material. The counsel pleaded that he did not have sufficient knowledge about technology and would not be able to answer those questions. "I am not conversant with this technology," he repeated several times defending the reporter and the newspaper editor and said that both the reporter and the editor were apologising unconditionally. In case of the editor, Abul Asad, the counsel said that publication of the report was an honest mistake since the source was used regularly. As such, the newsroom did not have any reason to suspect foul play when the report landed up. The tribunal chairman, however, got to the crux of the matter saying that whether the source was genuine or not was not the point. "Was the content of the report contemptuous?" To this, the defence counsel reiterated his point that the parties were apologising unconditionally and had the highest respect for the court. Verdict The tribunal noted that the Feni lawyers, through Zainul Abedin, stated that they had neither issued nor signed any such statement that was attributed to them in the report. They maintained that they held the court in high esteem and did not mean to lower the tribunal's dignity or create any obstruction in its function. The Feni lawyers also pleaded that they were apologising unconditionally to the court for any omission or lapse. Accordingly, the lawyers had issued a rejoinder on Apr 2, seeing the report of Apr 1. The rejoinder, however, was published after the court's order, on Apr 6 along with Sangram's statements. The court observed that the lawyers could not be directly linked with the report and could be given the "benefit of doubt". Thus the court did not punish them for contempt although the judgement stated that like the Sangram editor and its reporter, the lawyers "had not come with clean hands". As for the editor-publisher of Sangram, the order said there was nothing presented before the court that stated Abul Asad was not on duty on Apr 1 and thus could not escape from the contempt charges. Furthermore, the order noted, the reply from Sangram's editor and reporter had included the rejoinder of the Feni lawyers, but left out Sangram's own statements, which were part of the same item. The court found this "intentional" and concluded that the editor or the reporter had "not come with clean hands". The order then mentioned what Sangram had actually stated in the rejoinder from a copy of the paper of that date. The tribunal did not find the explanation satisfactory or convincing in light of the defence the counsel had presented. In addition, the tribunal said that an unqualified apology was acceptable only with the admission of guilt. "Defence and unqualified apology cannot go on simultaneously." Thus, their apologies were not acceptable to the court. The order, reiterating Justice Huq's oft-repeated position, stated that the court's decisions could certainly be criticised but within the ambit of law and fair comment. The sentence had confused the respondents and some of the lawyers, from Sayedee's defence team approached the bench to clarify. Justice Huq said regarding the guilty parties, "They are free as soon as we leave the court." bdnews24.com/ta/bd/1710h
Related Stories