November 23, 2026

Sajeda, Matia contempt call on Nov 13

The second war crimes tribunal will decide whether to initiate contempt proceedings against two senior Awami League leaders.Full report with updates

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 07 Nov 2012, 02:37 PM

Updated : 09 Aug 2022, 04:29 PM

Dhaka, Nov 7 (bdnews24.com)—The second war crimes tribunal of Bangladesh will decide on Nov 13 whether to initiate contempt proceedings against two senior Awami League leaders. The International Crimes Tribunal-2, set up in 2012 to expedite trials of crimes against humanity during the Liberation War, heard both the cases on Wednesday. The defence of Jamaat-e-Islami assistant secretaries general Abdul Quader Molla and Mohammad Kamaruzzaman petitioned the court to start contempt proceedings against the ruling Awami League's Deputy Leader in Parliament Syed Sajeda Chowdhury and Agriculture Minister Matia Chowdhury respectively for their statements. The court had fixed Wednesday for hearing the replies of both the politicians and had said earlier that their physical presence 'could be dispensed with' at this point. People's reaction Abdul Baset Majumdar stood for Sajeda Chowdhury with a reply to the statements she had allegedly made as reported by the Bengali daily Amar Desh. A BNP-leaning daily newspaper, Amar Desh had reported that Sajeda had said in a public meeting, "If one or two of them are hanged, then it will shut them up. There won't be any legal debates anymore." Referring to the Jamaat leaders in jail facing war crimes changes, she reportedly said, "The Razakars did not bother with laws when they tortured in 1971. So we should not either." Majumdar said on Wednesday that the comments were not reported in full and a vital part was omitted. He said that the Awami League MP had said, "When I go to the people they say this farce has gone on for long enough." And she continued with the statement which was in fact what people had told her, said the counsel. "She was only reporting people's reaction." The defence had also filed a supplementary application which had a slightly changed version of the statement and included the part where Sajeda referred to 'the people'. He said the defence had distorted the statements with malafide intentions solely to obtain the notice that they had, which by itself had maligned the politician in the public eye. Sajeda's lawyer also told the court that the newspaper brought to the court had dubious standards of journalism and went on to criticise someone, who could only be the newspaper's editor, without mentioning the name. Tribunal member Justice Obaidul Hassan inquired if the lawyer was meaning the editor but Majumdar indicated he would rather not mention it in so many words. He said, given that the application was false and frivolous, the case did not stand any more. The first question that defence counsel Tajul Islam faced when he stood up was, why the application had been filed in Quader Molla's case. The defence counsel replied that the application could have been filed in any of the cases. "But we had to file under some case. It touches upon all the cases in fact." Tajul Islam pointed out that Sajeda Chowdhury was not denying having made the statement at all and in turn offered a full version of the statement, verbatim, that had been recorded by other news outlets. He also went on to explain that the entire length of Sajeda's statements did not report the people's sentiments but included her own statements as well. Tribunal member, Judge Shahinur Islam, asked, "But how does that interfere with the proceedings of the court?" The defence counsel answered that the Awami League leader was saying that the tribunal need not follow the laws when she had said that the collaborators did not abide by the laws when they murdered and plundered. "She is telling the tribunal not to adhere to the laws." Tajul Islam also read out from the Sajeda's statement about hanging a couple of the Jamaat leaders and said that the ruling party leader even gave a judgement and was in a way directing the tribunal to do so. He said, "She holds a very important office of the ruling party and this has to be taken seriously." However, the counsel said, whether the tribunal would choose to take the Awami League leader seriously was something it would have to decide. Tajul Islam said that if Sajeda denied having made the statements then he was ready to provide the court with a full recording of her statement from the day. Majumdar replied that the newspaper headline was 'intentionally sensational' and linked that with the paper's opposition leanings. He said Sajeda was herself a freedom fighter and did not by any means intend to malign the tribunal or interfere with the proceedings. Sajeda's lawyer said the statements she made, merely reporting what people had said, did not come under the purview of the tribunal's provision for contempt proceedings. Tajul Islam said that there was 'sufficient material' to the contrary. Tribunal chairman Justice ATM Fazle Kabir fixed Nov 13 for order. Matia Chowdhury M Qumrul Haque Siddique argued for Matia Chowdhury and said that the statements made by the Agriculture Minister were in fact public reaction. The influential Awami League leader had been quoted by an online news portal barta24.net and a pro-Jamaat newspaper Naya Diganta as saying that whoever comes to the tribunal "as defence witnesses for the war criminals are Razakars". Razakars were an infamous band of vigilante militia who, along with the Al Badr and Al Shams, are alleged to have perpetrated widespread crimes against humanity in their bid to thwart the liberation efforts during the war in 1971. The Naya Diganta report, originally filed by the state-owned agency Bangladesh Sangbad Sangstha (BSS), quoted Matia as saying, "And we all know that these Razakars were also the ones who murdered, raped and plundered during the Liberation War." The two outlets covered the minister's statements from two public rallies in Sherpur and in Nalitabari, her own constituency in northern Bangladesh from Aug 7 and Aug 8, where Matia had gone to distribute relief materials. Matia's lawyer Qumrul Haque said that reports did not reflect the statements in their entirety since they were often 'edited version' of what had actually been said. Thus, the lawyer said, it might not have been wise to issue a notice on the basis of such a report. Qumrul Haque said Matia's comments only reflected 'pious demands of complainants' and thus did not warrant contempt. He also said the defence application filed under Jamaat leader Kamaruzzaman's case did not state what her intention was. The lawyer said, "These were casual remarks that had no specific intent." Apparently the rallies were not formal meetings and rather impromptu affairs, which the lawyer appeared to suggest showed that the statements did not have malafide intentions. He pointed out that the statements were followed by a statement where Matia says that she stands for a fair trial. Ehsan Siddiq, the younger son of Abdur Razzaq who leads the Jamaat defence team at the tribunals and himself an Assistant Secretary General of the party, said he found it rather interesting that both the counsels had the same defence saying that the politicians were merely reporting people's reactions. The young lawyer said his application clearly stated that the Agriculture Minister had deliberately made those comments in an area where Kamaruzzaman is alleged to have committed crimes. Thus Siddiq said his application clearly said that the minister intended to discourage and prevent potential witnesses from coming forward. "Therefore, she obstructs the course of justice." He said that the tribunal had not in fact issued any notice but merely sought the minister's reply regarding her position about the statement and under what circumstances those were made. Ehsan Siddiq said several times that the Matia Chowdhury's reply was a rather poor one, so poor that the minister's lawyer should explain why he had sought time from the tribunal. The counsel said that the Naya Diganta merely carried a BSS report and it was according to that report filed by the government-controlled agency that quoted the minister making certain statements. But, he said, his opponent did not have any basis for making the statement that he was making that the minister was reporting public reaction. Qumrul Haque replied that it did not matter that BSS was a state-owned agency because essentially it was still a news outlet covering events just like any other. "Ten people may be hearing the same thing but they end up reproducing 10 different versions." He said the ability to report exactly what had been said depended on the reporter's perception and thus reports should not be the basis of a criminal procedure such as the one at hand. He also replied to Ehsan Siddiq saying that his reply might have been 'poor' as Kamaruzzaman's lawyer had suggested. "But that is my reply and the question is acceptable to the tribunal." The tribunal Chairman then fixed the same date for ruling on the petition to initiate contempt proceedings against Matia Chowdhury. Currently the entire Jamaat leadership is in jail on war crimes charges. Among them are Jamaat guru Ghulam Azam, former party chief during the Liberation War, the current Jamaat chief Motiur Rahman Nizami, who headed Jamaat's student wing during the war, currently the Jamaat number two Ali Ahsan Mohammad Mujaheed, who succeeded Nizami in 1971, the party's assistant secretaries general Abdul Quader Molla and Mohammad Kamaruzzaman, and its executive council member Delwar Hossain Sayedee. More recently the Islamist organisation's financier Mir Quasem Ali, Abdus Sobhan and A T M Azharul Islam have been arrested for war crimes charges while investigations continue against them. bdnews24.com/ta/bd/2059h
Related Stories