November 20, 2026

Ruling on contempt plea Sep 2

The fate of a contempt petition filed against the New York-based Human Rights Watch (HRW) for questioning Jamaat-e-Islam leader Ghulam Azam’s verdict and the fairness of the judges will be decided on Sept 2.

Staff Correspondent

bdnews24.com

Published : 22 Aug 2013, 03:14 PM

Updated : 09 Aug 2022, 11:02 AM

The International War Crimes Tribunal-1, headed by Justice ATM Fazle Kabir, set the date for the ruling during Thursday’s hearing.

Prosecutors Zead Al Malum and Tureen Afroz along with others had filed an application to the tribunal registrar on Tuesday.

Afroz, Sultan Mahmud Simon and Tapas Kanti Bal said the HRW statement was aimed at eroding people’s confidence in the tribunal.

They alleged that the rights organisation had taken a similar stand in several other countries including Afghanistan and Iraq.

The petition has sought a ruling on why order should not be issued for action against HRW for contempt of court under the International Crimes Tribunal Act.

It has also sought a ban on such statements and their publication in future.

HRW’s board of directors, its Director for Asia region Brad Adams and associate Storm Tiv have been named as the accused in the petition.

The tribunal sentenced Azam to 90 years in prison on Jul 15 for his role during the nation’s Liberation War considering his age and physical condition, though, it said, he deserved death for his offences.

In a statement on Friday, the rights body had said the government had ‘ignored warnings’ despite it pointing out that ‘the law and trial process were deficient’.

The statement titled ‘Bangladesh: Azam Conviction Based on Flawed Proceedings’ listed five ‘flaws’ on the Ghulam Azam’s trial.

It said: “Among the most serious problems is the fact that the judges stated that they conducted an investigation to make up for deficiencies in the case presented by the prosecution. Judges in Bangladesh are only empowered to examine the evidence placed in front of them by the parties to the case.”

“The defence counsel was not aware of this investigation and was thus unable to comment on or challenge the evidence obtained by the judges, which constitutes a serious violation of article 14 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, to which Bangladesh is a party. The investigation calls into serious question the impartiality of the court,” it added.

The rights body believes the tribunal lacked evidence to convict the former Jamaat-e-Islami chief.

The prosecution application submitted to the tribunal said the Ghulam Azam case was pending with the Appellate Division following the ICT-1 verdict delivered on July 15.

But HRW issued the ‘biased’, ‘false’, ‘baseless’ and ‘ill-motivated’ statement on Aug 16, questioning the neutrality of the tribunal judges, it said.

During the hearing, Simon said the Liberation War was waged for protecting the human rights of the people of Bangladesh.

“Three million people were martyred, chastity of 0.2 million mothers and daughters were outraged during that war. The tribunals have been constituted to try those war criminals,” he said.

Terming the rights organisation’s statement biased, he said: “HRW didn’t send any observer to watch the tribunal proceedings. We are unable to understand the basis of their statement.”

“Verdicts of the courts in our country are criticised. But judgments of no other courts in the sub-continent are questioned that much. The criticism needs to be bridled.”

Turin Afroz said Bangladesh was a country that tried crimes against humanity with its own laws. “Few countries in the world could do it.”

She said: “These are international crimes committed against mankind. That’s why we’ve set an example in the world by trying the criminals.”

Also Read:

Contempt charge brought against HRW

Also Read:

US envoy upset with HRW prosecution

Also Read:

HRW questions Azam verdict
Related Stories