Published : 29 Jan 2016, 10:02 PM
Updated : 19 Oct 2022, 05:05 PM
The Implementation, Monitoring and Evaluation Division (IMED) has even questioned the quality of the work done so far.
The box culverts constructed under the project have been of such poor standards that the division had recommended taking up new project to repair them.
The IMED in a report attributed the lapses to irregularities, inefficiency of contractors, and frequent change of project managers.
It said in Dhaka zone, only 60 percent of the road development work under the project was completed in Dhaka, Narayanganj, Munsiganj, Manikganj, Gazipur, Narsinghdi, Mymensingh, Jamalpur, Tangail, Kishoreganj, Sherpur and Netrokona districts.
For the three-year project, Tk 3.74 billion was earmarked for the zone but finally Tk 2.14 billion was spent over the span of five years and six months.
There was no cost overrun, but implementation time was stretched.In Rajshahi zone, only 85 percent of the project was completed before its closure.
For the development of the roads within the zone, Tk 2.25 billion was earmarked for the project that was supposed to be completed within three years. But only Tk 1.66 billion was utilised in five years and six months.
The IMED said people had been made to suffer due to the failure to properly implement the twin projects.
“No project can go on forever. Work for the projects could not be completed even after the expiry of the extended deadline, so the government has been compelled to close them without the job being done,” IMED Secretary Md Shahid Ullah Khandaker told bdnews24.com.
“IMED has given a report after inspecting and evaluating some work done under the project. The report identified the drawbacks. But we don’t have the power to take action against implementing authority. We can only tell the relevant ministry about the problem,” he said.
Chief Engineer Ibne Alam Hasan of the Roads and Highways Department, the implementing authority of the projects, refused to comment on the issue.And Secretary to the Ministry of Road Transport and Bridges MAN Siddique would not give much importance to the IMED’s report.
“It is normal for the IMED to give a report after completion of any project. But its report is not the Bible,” he told bdnews24.com.
“Even its reports contain several lapses because there is no engineer in its inspection team. The truth will come out if an audit is done through a third party.”
A senior official at the Planning Commission said the two projects with an implementation time-frame of three years were approved in 2009.
As the work could not be completed within time, the project duration was extended by another two and a half years fixing June 2014 as the new deadline.
In the meantime, sub projects were taken up to develop 40 important roads in 12 districts in Dhaka zone and 29 roads in six districts in Rajshahi zone with a total cost of Tk 6 billion.
The IMED went for inspection after the projects were declared completed and gave the report to the relevant ministry and officials.In the report, it said lots of time were wasted in selection of contractor as project manager cancelled the tender and called fresh ones several times by indulging in irregularities.
It also said due to the inefficiency of the contractors, 40 percent of the work remained incomplete in Dhaka zone and 15 percent work in Rajshahi zone.
It questioned the quality of the work citing several faults.
The IMED said the frequent change of project managers also delayed the projects to a certain extent.