November 21, 2026

Rethink medical entry rule: experts

They say the decision comes 'hastily and should be revised'. Nurul Islam Hasib reports.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 14 Aug 2012, 06:16 PM

Updated : 09 Aug 2022, 04:07 PM

Nurul Islam Hasib bdnews24.com Senior Correspondent Dhaka, Aug 14 (bdnews24.com) – Experts and stakeholders feel that the decision to enrol students at medical institutions solely on the basis of performance in public examinations came 'hastily and should be revised'. The government decided on Sunday that GPAs in Secondary School Certificate and Higher Secondary Certificate examinations will be the sole criteria to ensure, what the Health Minister said, 'quality admissions'. The decision triggered off howls of protest from the admission-seekers preparing to sit the test to secure seats at the medical and dental colleges. A former education advisor to the caretaker government, Dr Hossain Zillur Rahman, said: "There must be an additional effort to judge the merit of the students before admission to higher studies." "You will see it in many countries," he said, adding that business by coaching centres could not be a point of argument for scrapping medical admission test. The advisor said the government should have more arguments to build up confidence in the new move. "Transparency would be an issue in the new system," he said adding that the government could have made the decision after setting criteria of GPA-based admission. Hossain Zillur was not convinced by Health Minister A F M Ruhal Haque's argument that the secondary and higher secondary-level examinations were the benchmark by which students can directly enrol into MBBS and BDS courses. "It's (standard of SSC and HSC exams) still a debatable issue," he said. Dr M Mushtuq Husain, General Secretary of Bangladesh Chikitshak Sangsad, a forum of doctors, feels the decision should be 'revised in light of reality.' "There should have been extensive consultations with all before introducing a new system," he said adding that such decision should come at least a year before. "Students of two sessions – current and previous – can sit the admission test. So if you change the system, you have to decide it at least a year before." He said enrolling in higher studies is highly competitive. "So there should be an examination before enrolment. You can enrol students from schools in colleges based on GPAs, but not in higher education." As officials said coaching centre business was behind the new government decision, Mushtuq said: "School teachers provide private tuition, so what will you do? Will you stop final exams at the end of an academic year in schools?" A leader of the pro-BNP doctors' association was also critical of the move. "This is not a wise decision. The admission test is needed," Secretary General of Doctors' Association of Bangladesh (DAB) Dr A Z M Zahid Hossain told bdnews24.com. He said there should be a competitive test for enrolment to higher education. "It (admission test) provided an average student an opportunity," he said adding that the medical admission test was fair enough. "No-one raised any question against it." He criticised the government for rushing into the decision and said the BNP would restore the pervious system, if voted to power, after discussing with all stakeholders. Zahid, who was also a Dean of Dhaka University's Faculty of Medicine, said the coaching centre issue could be addressed. "There is no point in chopping off the head because of a headache." He said the admission test was a tested system. "Once there was 20-mark viva voce, but it was scrapped in 1992 to make the admission process even more transparent and ensure quality." A guardian, Montazul Hoque, who is also a physician, said he was taken aback by the decision. "They could have made the decision at least a year before," he said mentioning that the 'creative examination system' now in force was developed gradually. "They (the Ministry of Education) did not enforce it in one go." He said if the government did not want to take admission test, they would have to enforce it at all institutions including universities. Hoque's daughter had been preparing to enrol at a medical college under the guidance of a coaching centre. As different education boards take exams in different questions, Hoque felt that it was not possible to judge a student on the basis of the public examination results. He said before making the decision the government should have ensured uniform question papers in SSC and HSC tests in all boards. The agitating students who have been demonstrating for the last two days against the new admission system said they would gather again at Central Sahheed Minar on Aug 27 after the Eid vacation. The Health Minister, however, told the agitating students on Tuesday that they would follow the court order. Hours before, the High Court asked the government to explain its move to enrol students based on SSC, HSC GPAs and not test them for admission anymore. bdnews24.com/nih/sk/bd/2345h
Related Stories