Published : 24 Aug 2018, 10:33 PM
Updated : 19 Oct 2022, 02:18 PM
“Future will tell us what is possible or not. Today we cannot completely say that ‘yes, return will not happen’. All the indications so far show that process goes towards the return,” Head of the Delegation in Bangladesh Ikhtiyar Aslanov told bdnews24.com in an interview on the anniversary of the crisis.
“And even it (return) starts today based on the Jan 16th plan between the two countries, it will need another seven years on top of the one year,” he said.
He argued in favour of his mid-term plan, referring to the deal when Myanmar agreed with Bangladesh to start repatriation with around 2,000 refugees a week.
But it has not started yet, raising concerns about the prospect of the return of those stateless Rohingya people, more than 1 million of whom are living in Bangladesh now.
Rohingya crisis is a decades-old problem as Myanmar has been denying them citizenship since 1982. The former UN secretary general Kofi Annan-led commission said that the root cause of problems lies in Myanmar.
The commission also recommended giving their citizenship back.
But the intensity of the violence on Aug 25 last year, just after the Annan Commission report, drew massive global attention as it was marred by killings, rapes, and arson and resulted in 700,000 fleeing ‘ethnic cleansing’ and taking shelter in Cox’s Bazar.
The UN Security Council, which is divided on Myanmar, later sent for the first time a delegation to Bangladesh to hear their plight.
Bangladesh also responded to the International Criminal Court’s letter saying that The Hague-based court has the jurisdiction to try Myanmar for the atrocities committed to Rohingyas, despite the fact that the Southeast Asian country is not a party to the court.
But Myanmar keeps blaming Bangladesh. State Counsellor Aung San Suu Kyi recently blamed Bangladesh for the delay.
The international community, however, has continued to ask Myanmar to create conditions for the safe return of the Rohingya refugees as they continue to come into Bangladesh.
On Aug 11, a Bangladesh delegation led by Foreign Minister AH Mahmood Ali visited the Rakhine State to see their preparations to repatriate the refugees.
The year passed very quicklyThe ICRC, which as a neutral, independent organisation has access to the Rakhine State, has provided 95,072 Rohingyas in Cox’s Bazar with food and non-food items. Of them, 42,770 people received repeat monthly food ration.
Host communities affected by the influx have also received livelihood support and are benefitting from micro-economic initiatives. Some 77,052 patients received mobile health-services and 45,985 people benefited from water, sanitation and shelter interventions as of the first week of August.
“It has been a very busy year for all of us – not only for the government of Bangladesh, but also for the humanitarian organisations,” the ICRC’s local chief Aslanov said.
“The year has passed very quickly in a sense that we have always been trying and running behind the scale of the crisis,” he said, recalling Aug 25 when the first report emerged that about “tens, then hundreds, then thousands and then tens of thousands people massing along the border”.
“Basically from August and end of January, the figure exponentially increased. In the meantime, we were trying to put together emergency response. From January onwards, we all rushed to prepare for the monsoon season arriving very fast.
“And now we are into one year. It shows how fast one year was. We continue to be as busy as we were,” Aslanov said, calling for a change in the approach of meeting humanitarian needs as the situation continues to remain as usual.
“People are more ‘settled’ now. Like other emergencies, they have passed the immediate shocks. They are now adapting to the camp life, and it comes with different challenges.”
Rohingya refugees scrambled for relief materials at Palongkhali in Ukhia, Cox's Bazar on Sept 15, 2017 as aid workers threw clothes from a truck. Photo: muhammad mostafigur rahman
Referring to the visit of the ICRC president to both Cox’s Bazar and Rakhine State, Aslanov said responding to the urgent situation cannot be longer on both sides.
He said in the current situation, even people on the other side of the border in the Rakhine State are depending on humanitarian aid.
“Humanitarian response is always for a first and urgent response after which more durable situations are to be sorted out.
“There needs to be a comprehensive reconciliation process as well to answer to the need of safety and security when they return.
“So (Myanmar) needs a comprehensive approach, political process, economic process and of course, then negotiations in terms of return,” the ICRC’s Bangladesh chapter chief said.
In the case of Bangladesh, he said, continuing humanitarian aid is “not sustainable process”.“Not sustainable from the perspective of the donors and the government as well. It is putting pressure on the Bangladesh government itself, and also on (Rohingyas).
“If people are only reliant on humanitarian aid, they lose their productive capacity. They become dependent.
“Then even for them to go back to and then to integrate and get into activity would be more difficult.
“The longer they depend on humanitarian aid, the more difficult it will become for their reintegration when they go back,” Aslanov observed.
“I know that it is a very sensitive question. There would be valid questions of whether they are being integrated in the society be engaging them into activity.
“But what we need is humanitarian community and the authorities to sit together and look at a protracted situation where the return, if it starts today, is going to take some time.
“In that process, how best the situation can be managed without again jeopardising the return process, without jeopardising the move of negotiations to return them.
“And not also make people completely dependent on aid because it’s also not sustainable for Bangladesh.”
“We can just share our international experiences,” he said, “But there is not one size that fits all.
“But if you continue to help them for a long time, people become dependent. They lose their initiatives. They lose their capacities to take care of themselves.
“As the situation evolves, local communities get saturated and they lose part of their resources and the government also becomes challenged with their resources and the humanitarian efforts also slow down.
“(But) If you allow people gradually and in a controlled manner to engage in a productive activity, you have a better management of the situation than today,” the ICRC local chief said.
“I am not saying that we all have solutions. We all hope and we want to believe the return process will begin sooner rather than later. How soon is difficult to answer,” Aslanov added.