November 23, 2026

Reality test of new budget hinges on its implementation: CPD

The fiscal and external balance of the country will be in jeopardy if the implementation of the proposed budget for fiscal 2005-06 follows the previous track record, the Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD) said Friday.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 09 Jun 2005, 06:00 PM

Updated : 17 Aug 2022, 08:49 PM

Advisory: With Photo Dhaka, June 09 (BDNEWS) – The fiscal and external balance of the country will be in jeopardy if the implementation of the proposed budget for fiscal 2005-06 follows the previous track record, the Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD) said Friday. "If the implementation behaviour (of the budget) pursues its earlier track record, then both the fiscal and external balance will be in jeopardy, ultimately undermining the savings-investment prospect," the CPD said, insisting that the "reality check" of the budget will be in its implementation. It added: "under such a scenario, the poor will be affected more than the rich." The observations of the CPD, a private think-tank, on the proposed budget for next fiscal were made public at a press briefing Friday at its conference room. Dr Debapriya Bhattacharya, Prof Mustafizur Rahman, Uttam Kumar Dev and Fahmida Khatun attended the briefing. The CPD identified some "not so pro-poor trends" in the public finance basket of the budget, which include faster growth of revenue expenditure than that of revenue earning and development spending, increased contribution of VAT in incremental contribution to the total revenue intake and extremely poor level of utilisation of resources allocated to some of the social sectors, such as primary healthcare and education that essentially benefit the poor. As a result, it added, the economy is already under-performing in contrast to the targets set by the three-year Medium Term Macro economic Framework (MTMF) of the Poverty Reduction Strategy Paper (PRSP). CPD Executive Director Debapriya Bhattacharya said: "It's budget for caring ... a budget for compromise ... and a budget of collusion." The CPD analysis admitted that there had been a conscious effort to expand and deepen the social safety net programmes, but added that without a proper poverty audit, it would be difficult to say what is the actual pro-poor intensity of the new budget. It also said the budget has made a number of compromises to provide support to investment and employment generation against the backdrop of limitation of available resources. This has been reflected in the recasting of the tax holiday provisions, continuation of a number of cash incentive schemes for selected export sector and rationalisation of tariff and para-tariff structure, it added. The CPD also said the fiscal measures in the budget were in fact generated through "collusive behaviour." The extreme manifestation of this was the extension of the time period for tax amnesty for undisclosed income, it said, adding the measures, such as tax on mobile SIM card, would also invoke suspicion. The CPD said the Finance Minister extended block allocations targeting the next general elections, but remained unclear about the allocations for the poor putting the implementation capacity to test. "The minister did not elaborate how many projects, sectors and the amount of allocations are specifically for poverty reduction," said Debapriya. "Conciseness (of the budget speech) held hostage transparency," he said, "This cannot be clearly said if the allocation is for poverty reduction." Debapriya criticised the growing public expenditure against the backdrop of lower revenue collection and dependence on foreign aid, and said the total revenue earnings grew by only 7.9 percent as against 12.7 percent growth in public expenditure. Average annual growth of revenue expenditure was 12.6 percent as against only 4.8 percent growth in development expenditure, he added. The CPD said the measures on income tax would have adverse impact on the middle and higher middle class groups. They criticised the proposal on raising tax for non listed companies and said most of the small and medium enterpises (SMEs) don't have the capacity to go public. The CPD praised higher allocations for education, health, agriculture, and social safety net schemes. It also praised extension of the tax holiday facility for some thrust sectors. BDNEWS/1810 hrs
Related Stories