Prosecution argues for ICT chief
The prosecution has continued with their argument against removal of war crimes tribunal chief Nizamul Huq.
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
13 Nov 2011, 09:14 AM
Updated :
10 Aug 2022, 05:47 PM
Dhaka, Nov 13 (bdnews24.com) — The prosecution has continued with their argument against removal of war crimes tribunal chief Nizamul Huq.
Justice ATM Fazle Kabir and judge AKM Zaheer Ahmed heard the submissions.
Syed Haider Ali was arguing why Huq's previous actions as part of a people's enquiry commission, formed in 1993, does not disqualify him to preside over the proceedings at the International Crimes Tribunal when the court went into a recess for lunch.
The proceedings began with defence counsel Abdur Razzaq arguing for the removal of Justice Huq in a crowded courtroom that had almost as many people standing on the two sides as were sitting with a large number of lawyers from both prosecution and defence.
Moudud Ahmed, a former law minister of BNP, and Khandkar Mahbub Hossain, an advisor to BNP chief Khaleda Zia, also argued for Huq's recusal.
Haider pointed out that the commission was not among either of the parties to the only case underway at the tribunal. He said the two parties were the chief prosecutor and the accused, Delwar Hossain Sayedee, an executive council member of Jamaat-e-Islami. Sayedee has been indicted on 20 counts of crimes against humanity including murder, rape, arson, genocide and loot.
Abdur Razzaq said that as a member of the secretariat of the enquiry commission Huq was involved in the investigation of war crimes allegations against Jamaat leaders including its chief Motiur Rahman Nizami, secretary general Ali Ahsan Mohammad Mojaheed, Sayedee and BNP leader Salahuddin Quader Chowdhury.
Huq was also involved in the process of obtaining statements of witnesses, many of whom are likely to appear before the tribunal to give evidence.
A written statement handed out by Tajul Islam, who regularly argues on behalf of Sayedee, states, "In his capacity as a member of the secretariat, he also recommended that [those persons] be tried for war crimes by the International Crimes Tribunal."
The statement reads that in view of Huq's direct involvement with the people's inquiry commission, "he has no right to perform the functions of the chairman of the International Crimes Tribunal."
Razzaq referred to other cases where judges had been disqualified for much less including one case relating to a similar case in Sierra Leone.
He concluded saying that the sooner Huq removed himself the better. But in case he did not, Razzaq said, "Our submission to your lordships would be that you come out in favour of justice."
Moudud Ahmed said it was rather unfortunate that such a hearing had to take place in the first place.
"I am sure this would be awkward for the judges too," he said observing that the remaining two judges of the tribunal would have to decide on the fate of their chairman.
On Oct 30, the war crimes tribunal adjourned Jamaat leader Sayedee's trial until Nov 20 after a heated argument with the defence.
The tribunal head ordered the defence to submit its list of witnesses on Nov 20 when the court would hear opening statements and record witness statements.
Before that, the court would hear a petition on Wednesday to review Sayedee's indictment order of Oct 3.
Charges against Sayedee, who was known as 'Deilla Razakar' in his area during the war, relate to involvement in killing of more than 3,000 unarmed people, rape of over nine women, arson, forcing Hindus to convert their religion, looting and other crimes against humanity. The crimes were committed in Pirojpur district.
Sayedee on Oct 3 denied the accusations brought against him.
Sayedee is the first man facing a formal trial among the five Jamaat leaders and two others from BNP facing similar charges.
Sayedee was arrested on July 30 last year. Apart from him, Nizami, Mojaheed and assistant secretaries general Mohammad Kamaruzzaman and Abdul Quader Molla have been arrested on war crimes charges.
Senior BNP leader Salahuddin Quader Ch and Abdul Alim, a minister in Ziaur Rahman's cabinet, have also been arrested on similar charges.
Of the seven Jamaat and BNP leaders facing the war crimes charges, Alim is on conditional bail while the remaining six are behind bars.
bdnews24.com/ta/bd/1347h