November 20, 2026

Opening statement against Sayedee finishes

The prosecution will finish its opening statement on Monday.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 20 Nov 2011, 08:11 AM

Updated : 10 Aug 2022, 05:49 PM

Dhaka, Nov 20 (bdnews24.com)—The prosecution has finished their opening statement against Jamaat-e-Islami leader Delwar Hossain Sayedee in the first war crimes trial being held at the International Crimes Tribunal. Prosecutor Syed Rezaur Rahman continued from where he had left off the previous day after the tribunal reconvened on Monday morning. Jamaat's executive council member Sayedee has been charged on 20 counts for war crimes that he allegedly committed during the War of Independence. Earlier on Sunday, chief prosecutor Ghulam Arieff Tipoo began the statement with the historic context that led up to the Liberation War in 1971. After about an hour, the 82-year-old chief prosecutor asked his colleague Syed Rezaur Rahman to continue with the opening statement. But Rezaur Rahman could not get through the 88-page document either, when the tribunal said it would hear the remainder on Monday. The tribunal asked the prosecution to give its opening statement minutes before going into lunch recess after having heard two applications filed by the defence. One of the applications sought explanation from the tribunal chief Nizamul Huq, why he had not removed, or recused, himself from the tribunal. Barrister Abdur Razzaq argued for Sayedee on the first application of the day. The other application sought adjournment of Sayedee's trial until. He has been indicted on 20 counts including genocide, murder, rape, arson and loot. Lawyer Tajul Islam urged the tribunal to delay the trial to prepare its case and the list of witnesses. Nizamul Huq, presiding over Sunday's proceedings, said in his order that the first application, asking for his explanation to stay on as head of the tribunal, would be disposed of on Wednesday. In response to the second application seeking adjournment of the trial proceedings, he fixed Dec 7 for the defence to submit its list of witnesses. Nizamul then directed the prosecution to begin its opening statement in the ongoing trial against Sayedee. Nizamul then directed the prosecution to begin its opening statement in the ongoing trial against Sayedee. Razzaq stood up and urged the tribunal to begin with the opening statements later since Nizamul Huq will explain his reasons for staying on as the tribunal chair on Nov 23 and had already directed to the defence to submit its list of witnesses and other material on Nov 7. "Let this come on Nov 7," he told Huq and pointed out that it would be 72 hours before the judge had explained himself. "What is the harm?" asked Huq, to which Razzaq only said, "There is harm my lord, there is harm." Much of the time before lunch was taken up by Razzaq's deliberation on the first application, when two other lawyers also addressed the court. The defence had filed its application seeking removal of the tribunal chief, recusal in legalese, stating that his neutrality has been compromised due to his earlier involvement with a people's inquiry commission. As part of that team, he collected evidence against Sayedee and thus has already formed an opinion about the accused who will be tried under him, the defence had said. Razzaq drew the court's attention to the matter that since the two other judges of the tribunal had left the matter of recusal entirely upon the good conscience of the tribunal chairman. Moudud Ahmed began his saying that he had utmost respect for Nizamul Huq as a member of the bar as well as the bench. He said the case had a political undertone and therefore suggested all the more prudence. "This is an ethical issue, more than it is a political or legal issue." Referring to Huq's role with the enquiry commission, Moudud wondered how well the justice might be able to extricate himself from the past and adjudicate fairly. Razzaq said the application was a rather difficult one for him to move too. "But I only do it in the interest of justice." The attorney general, Mahbubey Alam, had been sitting with the prosecution from the beginning and stood up to address the court once the defence was done. Abdur Razzaq intervened saying that he would like to in what capacity the attorney general addressed the court and whether he was there on behalf of a certain party. Nizamul Huq said that he assumed the lawyer was speaking in the capacity of the attorney general. "But let us hear him first." Mahbubey Alam then began saying that at first the defence had an objection about Nizamul Huq being the tribunal chair, "And now they have an objection about the attorney general addressing the tribunal." The top government lawyer said the defence had not made any specific point or brought any tangible evidence that convincingly indicated that the judge's bias. "The mere appearance of his name in a list does not mean anything. Even I was not aware that my name is on a list." Alam went on to say that he doubted very much that the tribunal chief had ever been to any of the locations of occurrence where Sayedee is alleged to have committed his crimes. He began his statements saying that he had never seen such an application in his 35 year's of service and went on to state that 'such an application was rather contemptuous of the court'. "The accused cannot ask the judge his reasons for participating in the trial." Since there was no such proof that the chair had compromised his neutrality, the attorney general contended that the application be rejected straightway. Razzaq began his rebuttal saying that the attorney general had made a political speech. "But I will stick to the legal points, and only the legal points." The senior defence counsel also said that despite the top law officer of the country the attorney general had completely missed the point. "This is no more a recusal hearing, although the points he made pertained to that." Razzaq said the hearing was regarding the defence asking the judge officially state his reasons for staying on since the two other judges had left the matter up to the good conscience of the chairman. Upon conclusion of the first hearing the tribunal asked Tajul Islam, if his application for adjourning the trial was because the defence did not want to proceed before disposing of the first application. Tajul Islam said it was not just that. "There is also the matter of preparation. We are in the process of gathering material from within the country and abroad." He said the defence was also gathering its witnesses which would take some time and requested three months' time pointing out that the prosecution was given more than a year. Justice Huq said the work was quite different for the two sides and also accepted upon the defence's insistence that it may turn out that the defence should rightly need more time. He noted that the trial had begun with Sayedee's indictment on Oct 3 and according to the laws of the tribunal the defence would be allowed at least 21 days from that day for preparation. "It appears that six weeks have already passed." But in view of the defence application, Huq ruled that the tribunal was 'inclined to given the defence more time'. He fixed Dec 7 as the date when the defence would submit its list of witnesses and other materials. Huq then ordered the prosecution to begin with the opening statement as had been scheduled before the defence had filed its recusal application. The defence had filed its application seeking removal of the tribunal chief, recusal in legalese, stating that his neutrality had been compromised due to his earlier involvement with a people's inquiry commission. As part of that team, he collected evidence against Sayedee and thus has already formed an opinion about the accused who would be tried under him, the defence had said. Only four days back, Sayedee's lawyers stormed out of the court after the tribunal chief joined proceedings. They also filed the two applications before walking out of the tribunal. The tribunal fixed Nov 20 for disposing of that application, but when urged to continue with the scheduled hearing of a review petition of Sayedee's indictment, the defence refused to proceed and walked out demanding that the tribunal chief explain himself first. The tribunal said the conduct of the defence lawyers had been "unwarranted" and "unbecoming". As for the review petition, the court said it was rejected since it was 'not pressed'. The defence had told the press later that they would wait until the disposal of application was disposed of on Sunday. On the other hand, the prosecution claimed that the defence had violated all ethics, code of conduct and customs that behove lawyers. The prosecution raised a legal point and said the petition was not maintainable or in form. The prosecution further pointed out that the commission in question was not in any way part of the ongoing trial. Nor did it have any legal coverage. The other two judges of the tribunal, ATM Fazle Kabir and AKM Zaheer Ahmed, held a hearing of that petition on Nov 13 in a crowded courtroom. They ruled the following day that the laws did not provide for the tribunal judges to remove a co-judge. They also pointed out that the previous cases cited by the defence counsel Abdur Razzaq where judges were recused had the privilege of such laws. In conclusion, they left the matter of recusal to the 'good conscience of the judge' in question. On Sunday, attorney general Mahbubey Alam sat with the prosecution team and addressed the court, while former law minister Moudud Ahmed, Supreme Court Bar Association president Khandker Mahbub Hossain addressed the court from defence, besides Abdur Razzaq and Tajul Islam. Former speaker Jamiruddin Sircar was also present in the court among the defence lawyers. bdnews24.com/ta/rn/bd/1328h
Related Stories