No action against TIB: Inu
Information Minister tells Parliament the Berlin headquarters will be notified about the government decision to reject the report. Full Report
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
20 Nov 2012, 12:44 PM
Updated :
09 Aug 2022, 04:32 PM
Dhaka, Nov 20 (bdnews24.com)—Information Minister Hasanul Haq Inu on Tuesday said the government will not take any action against Transparency International, Bangladesh (TIB) for publishing the report which he said has 'slighted' Members of Parliament.
Inu made the comment while answering a question in Parliament, a day after MPs berated the Berlin-based anti-graft watchdog's Bangladesh chapter.
He, however, said TI's head office in Germany will be notified about the government decision to reject the report.
A TIB study published on Oct 14 said that 97 percent MPs were involved in 'negative activities', evaluating works of 149 MPs – 136 from ruling Awami League and 13 from the opposition, including 27 ministers and state ministers.
Opinions of the people from half the Parliament seats were taken for the study.
On Monday, MPs, mostly from the ruling party, harshly criticised the anti-graft watchdog in Parliament and asked the Speaker to call TIB's high officials including Executive Director for explanations. They also demanded that activities of the organisation be banned.
"There is no necessity for taking any action (against TIB), the people will decide on their own," said Inu on Tuesday as he replied to the question asked by MP Fazilatunnesa Bappi.
"We are rejecting the report and we will inform the headquarters of Transparency International about it so that they publish a full-fledged report," he added.
After hearing the MPs demand, Speaker Abdul Hamid on Monday had said the decision over the issue would be taken after discussions with the senior MPs.
The Information Minister examined the report earlier and said TIB's assessment on the activities of the MPs was not 'objective' and did not follow 'proper process'.
TIB had to send its report to the ministry and answered over 30 questions it had asked.
Inu said, "Overall it can be said the research was conducted on some specific negative ideas."
"TIB intentionally and consciously published this report just to undermine the MPs in the eye of the people."
The ruling MPs had also came down hard on TIB for drawing such a conclusion by taking opinion of only 600 people in a country of 160 million. They said publication of such a report a year ahead of next election may have other intentions.
The minister said it was clear after examining the report that the TIB tried to reach a specific negative goal by choosing respondents and taking the opinion in a specifically negative and indicative questionnaire.
"We found that there was no information and data on the report based on which measures can be taken against the MPs. We were surprised as to why such a weak report has been published."
"Many people are involved in corruption. But it has become fashionable to call the politicians corrupt. TIB has done the same," Inu, also the JaSaD President, said.
He also questioned TIB's survey process. "On what basis did the TIB choose five daily newspapers from the 320 newspapers?"
"Their data have been derived from five dailies, Parliament Watch and a group of conscious people who were chosen and defined by themselves [TIB]."
Inu said the focus group discussion of this survey was moderate by Sacheton Nagarik Somaj (SoNaK), which is directed by TIB. The survey was not done anywhere where SoNak did not have presence, he added.
"It is observed from the questionnaire that the TIB did not properly follow the methodology used in social researches to prepare this much-discussed report."
"The TIB chose a system of their choice to establish the predetermined outcome by not using the method that would be best for the topic."
Meanwhile, TIB Executive Director Dr Iftekharuzzaman on Tuesday said the MPs demanded a ban on the organisation's activities due to 'lack of perception'.
Reacting to the criticisms, he said the report was prepared and published to create opportunities for strengthening the MPs' role, not to insult them.
It is not "our intention to undermine Parliament", he added.
He said answers to the questions raised by the minister regarding the report were available on the TIB website.
bdnews24.com/sum/eh/trb/bd/1912h