Published :
14 Jan 2013, 08:25 AM
Updated :
09 Aug 2022, 10:06 AM
The war crimes tribunal appears plagued by mobile phones that disturb proceedings once too often.
Just two days after her appointment to the Chief Prosecutor’s office, Prosecutor Farah Khan found she had forgotten to mute her phone after lunch when it rang out on Nov 15.
Prosecutor Syed Haider Ali was minutes away from concluding his final argument of the first war crimes case at the International Crimes Tribunal.
Several minutes later it was Farah’s senior’s turn. Prosecutor Zead-Al-Malum was listening to Haider Ali’s arguments when his mobile rang.
It was rather conspicuous with the prosecutor sitting in the front bench and the tribunal relatively quiet due to low attendance.
Tribunal member Justice Jahangir Hossain chose to acknowledge the ring. Indicating the prosecution’s side, he said, “There are just a little too many rings from that side.”
Tribunal chairman Justice Mohammad Nizamul Huq’s frustration was evident. “All the rings are from that side. That is the only side that has phones ringing.”
Nov 7 marked a first when Sabina Yesmin Khan Munni’s phone played a familiar Nokia tune. A junior of Prosecutor Mukhlesur Rahman Badal, Munni quickly turned it off, obviously embarrassed.
This happened when Prosecutor Syed Haider Ali was delivering his final arguments in the war crimes against Jamaat-e-Islami leader Delwar Hossain Sayedee, who has been indicted for 20 charges by the International Crimes Tribunal – 1, set up to deal with crimes against during the 1971 Liberation War.
Earlier on the day, Prosecutor Altaf Uddin Ahmed’s phone rang out and he had to seek help from a fellow prosecutor to silence it.
On Nov 6 Mir Iqbal Hossain’s mobile phone was heard ringing which the tribunal took notice of and asked him to turn the phone off.
The tribunal chairman had categorically said on Dec 15 that his order barring people from carrying mobile phones into the court applied to everybody – including security personnel and the lawyers.
But despite the order not to carry mobile phones into the court room, the first war crimes tribunal on Oct 2 heard a handset ring out four times.
It was all the more conspicuous because the loud chime seemed to be coming out of the pocket of a prosecution witness testifying at the stand.
Gopal Chandra Das, the 14th witness against BNP MP Salauddin Quader Chowdhury, quickly took it out and silenced it.
However, upon a second ring, while he was still at the stand, tribunal Chairman asked a prosecutor to silence the mobile phone, which the prosecutor failed to do and there was a third ring.
By this time, the witness was being cross-examined and defence counsel Ahsanul Huq objected strongly pointing out that the court's bar on electronic devices did not seem to apply for the prosecution.
The set was handed to the investigation officer in whose hands it appeared to ring for a fourth time.
Counsel Ahsanul Huq was even more voluble this time along with the audible grumble in the defence benches.
Tribunal Chairman Justice Mohammad Nizamul Huq, referring to his order said, "We have said that no one would be allowed to carry mobile phones in."
But, he noted, a mobile has been found on a witness and it might have been because he was not checked properly. The tribunal chief indicated that whatever the reason it was not acceptable.
Prosecutors at the tribunal have been flouting this order quite brazenly taking advantage of the court's evident lenience.
The only other time that the tribunal Chairman acknowledged a ringing mobile and mildly admonished a prosecutor was when Prosecutor Zead-Al-Malum's phone rang out on Jul 10 during cross-examination of a witness.
Justice Huq said, "If you have to answer that, go out. The door is always open."
Malum happens to be the conducting prosecutor of the case against BNP leader Salauddin Quader Chowdhury and he was sitting at the front row when his call came.
Embarrassed, the prosecutor stood up and said, "I have silenced it my lord."
There was no further discussion and proceedings continued.
Mir Iqbal Hossain's cell phone rang out on Jul 2 when he stood up to apologise to the court but it rang a second time on Sep 3 when Mizanul Islam was cross-examining Misbahur Rahman Chowdhury, the first witness against Jamaat chief Motiur Rahman Nizami. The tribunal did not take note of it the second time.
Mir Iqbal happens to be the conducting prosecutor of Nizami's war crimes case.
Prosecutor Altaf Uddin Ahmed's phone rang on Aug 23 while Abdur Razzaq argued for bail of ATM Azharul Islam. Altaf Uddin was initially the conducting prosecutor for Nizami's case but has been replaced by Iqbal Hossain since the case entered trial phase.
The prosecutor was seen fiddling with his mobile for several minutes afterwards conspicuous at the front row while Jamaat's chief defence counsel laboured through his submissions.
Visitors and journalists are only permitted to carry pen and paper for note-taking.
And officially the only electronic equipment inside the courtrooms are those of the tribunal's which include the stenographer's computer with displays for the accused, defence, conducting lawyer and the judges.