November 20, 2026

Minister under attack over cholera comments

Health rights activists say ICDDR,B pushed the government to say 'cholera is widespread in Bangladesh' to facilitate its vaccine tests

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 14 May 2011, 09:36 AM

Updated : 10 Aug 2022, 04:48 PM

Dhaka, May 14 (bdnews24.com)—The government has fallen into the trap of oral cholera vaccine on which the ICDDR,B is conducting a feasibility study in the capital's Mirpur area, health rights activists say. They told a press conference on Saturday that there were no government records of cholera outbreaks in Bangladesh at least in the last decade. But, the health minister put forward a proposal on cholera control saying 'cholera is widespread in Bangladesh'. Minister AFM Ruhal Haque presented a proposal to the WHO board meeting in May 2010 that mentioned 'Bangladesh sees cholera peaks twice a year – before and after monsoon.' Leaders of Health Rights Movement National Committee at National Press Club said such comment can have 'serious impact' on the country's economy, particularly on shrimp as well as frozen food export. "But the health ministry might not be aware of that," said Dr Lenin Chowdhury, member of the committee, and added the ministry was 'misguided by ICDDR,B.' "ICDDR,B has been pushing Bangladesh to speak about cholera in global meetings since they started the vaccine test in November 2009," he said in a written statement. The statement added they were concerned about the government's move that, they believe, could 'divert the attention from improving water and sanitation system in the country.' Paediatric Association of Bangladesh's secretary general Dr Mejbah Uddin also expressed his concern. Due to Bangladesh's stance, cholera issue found a place in the upcoming May 16-24 64th session of the World Health Assembly's agenda for discussion. "Once the issue is accepted, cholera surveillance will start in the country and the oral cholera vaccine might find a way into the national vaccination programme," said Prof Rashid-e-Mahbub, president of the citizen's committee. "We strongly believe that it's unnecessary and will only serve interest of the research organization." He added safe water and improved sanitation can keep the organisms away. However, the United Nations panel led by ICDDR, B's executive director Alejandro Cravioto recently concluded that Haiti's 2010 cholera outbreak that killed nearly 5,000 was a result of inadequate sanitation facilities and a series of circumstances that included the poor water and sanitation infrastructure of the island nation followed by earthquake. Prof Rashid-e-Mahbub told bdnews24.com that these were also the facts in Bangladesh for perennial diarrhoeal diseases. "But the ICDDR,B are not telling the Bangladesh government to improve its water and sanitation, rather they try to force vaccines on it," he said. "And this is because diarrhoeal diseases have become the financial lifeline of the institute (ICDDR,B)," he said. He pointed out that the institute had been working for the last 40 years in Matlab of east-central Chandpur, but diarrhoea is still prevalent there. "Now that they have started working in Mirpur, the preventable disease will never be prevented," he said with a tinge of sarcasm. Earlier, a Sweden-based vaccine scientist, Shahjahan Kabir, told bdnews24.com through e-mail: "ICDDR,B tried another cholera vaccine 'Dukoral' in 1985, but that did not come to the system because of ethical issues and high prices." He suggested 'impartial observers' for testing vaccines. However, health minister Ruhal Haque told bdnews24.com earlier that they took it as an opportunity as many South African countries were facing cholera and WHO was looking for prevention mechanisms. "It was a milestone for Bangladesh as WHO had for the first time accepted its resolution," he maintained. bdnews24.com/nih/bd/1450h

Related old stories

Govt raises false cholera alarm
Related Stories