November 21, 2026

MANMOHAN IN DHAKAVisit leaves major issues unvisited

With some of the key disputes, including Teesta and Feni water sharing, remaining unresolved, the Indian prime minister's visit loses some of its sheen Full story

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 06 Sep 2011, 05:00 PM

Updated : 10 Aug 2022, 05:23 PM

Dhaka, Sept 6 (bdnews24.com) – The supposed 'historic visit' of the Indian prime minister seems to have turned into a 'goodwill visit' as the much-anticipated agreements on Teesta and Feni water sharing failed to see the light of the day. All that Bangladesh has managed to get in the bargain is duty- and quota-free market access to 46 readymade garment-related products and signing of a protocol on land boundary agreement. Manmohan Singh arrived in Dhaka on Tuesday on a two-day trip, accompanied by the minister for external affairs and four chief ministers of the bordering states. He is reciprocating the visit of prime minister Sheikh Hasina to India in January last year. Indian water resources minister Pawan Kumar Bansal and Paschimbanga chief minister, who were in the list of the entourage of the Indian prime minister, did not come as Mamata was apparently testy over the proposed modalities of the Teesta water sharing. The prime ministers had one-on-one meeting before and after the official talks on the Day-1 of his tour. After the meeting, both the prime ministers signed framework agreement on cooperation for development, and witnessed signing of one protocol, addendum of one protocol and eight memoranda of understanding. TEESTA, FENI AGREEMENTS However, following strong opposition from Paschimbanga chief minister Mamata Banerjee, Bangladesh and India could not sign the agreements on Teesta and Feni water sharing. Manmohan in his speech said, "Our common rivers need not be sources of discord, instead can become the harbingers of prosperity to both the countries. "We have decided to continue discussions to reach a mutually acceptable, fair and amicable arrangement for the sharing of the waters of Teesta and Feni rivers." Hasina, however, in her speech did not mention anything about Teesta water sharing. International affairs adviser to the prime minister Gowher Rizvi, one of the key coordinators of the Indian premier's visit, said some consultations were needed in India before the agreement was signed. "We have agreed in principle on the modalities of the agreement and are hopeful of signing the deal within couple of months," he said. When asked if Bangladesh sought any explanation from India, he said, "There is no need to seek explanation. We understand the reality." "We had landmark success in the visit and now it is time to celebrate," he said. Hasina hosted a banquet in the honour of the Indian premier after the meeting. Indian foreign secretary Ranjan Mathai in Delhi on Monday said any agreement between New Delhi and Dhaka on sharing of the Teesta water would have to be acceptable to the West Bengal government as well as to Bangladesh. He, however, said the proposed deal on sharing of the water of Feni between Bangladesh and India was on track. But he was non-committal on the deal on Teesta. "Water is a very sensitive issue. Nothing is done or will be done without the consent of the state government," Mathai told journalists, in response to a query whether the deal on Teesta would be signed during prime minister Manmohan Singh's visit to Dhaka. On Saturday, water resources minister Ramesh Chandra Sen confirmed the bdnews24.com that the Teesta agreement would be signed, no matter who liked it or not. At a press briefing on Sunday, foreign minister Dipu Moni also said that Teesta deal was in the list of signing. LAND BOUNDARY AGREEMENT The government signed a protocol to implement the land boundary agreement signed in 1974. Manmohan said, "We have signed a Protocol to the Land Boundary Agreement (LBA) of 1974. With this, both the countries have now demarcated the entire land boundary as well as resolved the issue of status of the enclaves and adversely possessed areas." He continued, "As the prime minister (Sheikh Hasina) just announced, we have worked out 24-hour access to the enclaves of Dahagram-Angarpota through the Tin Bigha Corridor." Hasina earlier in her speech said "I would like to announce that from now on, our people in Dahagram and Angorpota will have 24-hour unfettered movement through the Tin Bigha Corridor." The land boundary problems have persisted since 1947, and to resolve the issue, a joint headcount was conducted recently that found about 51,000 people live in these enclaves – 34,000 in Bangladesh and 17,000 in India. Bangladesh has 111 Indian enclaves and India houses 51 Bangladeshi enclaves. Undemarcated land boundary of 6.5 kilometres and adversely possessed land issues also form part of the protocol. The 1974 LBA said, "The Indian enclaves in Bangladesh and Bangladesh enclaves in India should be exchanged expeditiously." About Berubari and Dahagram-Angarpota, the LBA specified, "India will retain southern half of South Berubari Union No. 12 and the adjacent enclaves, measuring an area of 2.64 square miles approximately, and in exchange Bangladesh will retain the Dahagram and Angarpota enclaves. India will lease in perpetuity to Bangladesh an area of 178 metres X 85 metres near Tin Bigha to connect Dahagram with Panbari Mouza (PS Palgram) of Bangladesh." TRANSIT LETTER Dhaka and Delhi did not exchange any 'letter' on transit to pave the way for smooth movement of goods through Bangladesh. Asked if Bangladesh did not agree on transit as India did not sign water agreement, Gowher Rizvi said, "Our relationship is based on trust. We don't believe in such relationship where if you don't get anything you will reciprocate by not giving other things." Dipu on Sunday at a press briefing said Dhaka and Delhi would exchange a 'letter' during the visit of India premier. "There will be an 'exchange of letter' under which both the countries agree to formulate legal instruments including protocol and standard operating procedure to provide smooth transit facility," she said. "The existing agreement and protocol will be the basis for providing the transit service through Bangladesh," Dipu added. TEXTILE GAINS On Tuesday, Delhi agreed to provide duty-free access to the Indian market to 46 textile tariff lines, as per the request of Bangladesh, with immediate effect. "India is fully alive to the problem of trade imbalance between India and Bangladesh," Manmhoan said. "We have embarked on a series of measures to improve border infrastructure. These will facilitate Bangladesh's exports to India and provide it greater opening to India and other neighbouring countries." "We are addressing issues relating to non-tariff barriers together with Bangladesh," he said. Hasina in her speech said, "India would allow duty-free access to 46 items from Bangladesh to the Indian market that were on the sensitive list of India previously." Dhaka has a growing trade gap with Delhi, and therefore, Bangladesh sought duty-free access for 61 major exportable items to India. India maintains 480 products of Bangladesh on the negative list, but it allows import of 10 million pieces of RMG products a year duty-free. But local exporters demand there should not be any condition attached to trade. FRAMEWORK AGREEMENT The two prime ministers also signed a framework agreement on cooperation for development of a contemporary blueprint to encompass all forms and sectors of cooperation. "We have agreed on a new architecture for our partnership. This will open new vistas of bilateral cooperation, strengthen regional cooperation within South Asia and set an example of good-neighbourly relations," Manmohan said. "Relations between India and Bangladesh enjoy our highest priority. There is a national consensus in India that India must develop the best possible relations with Bangladesh," he added. Hasina said, "We have signed a framework agreement on cooperation for development – a visionary document that looks at not only the realities today, but also the potentials of tomorrow." POWER PURCHASE Manmohan said India was committed to assisting Bangladesh in its development efforts. "We will supply bulk power to Bangladesh by connecting our national grids. We will assist in setting up of a 1320 megawatt joint venture power plant in Khulna," he said. Projects worth over $750 million under the $1 billion line of credit announced last year had been identified for implementation, he said. India has relaxed its conditions of procuring 85 per cent Indian manpower and machine under $1 billion line of credit. New Delhi approved two construction projects where the conditions have been relaxed. The two construction projects are Khulna-Mongla port rail line including feasibility study, and second Bhairab and second Titas bridge including feasibility study with approach rail line. India has, so far, agreed to finance 13 projects that involve $746 million, and two loan agreements involving about $41 million have already been signed. The signed projects are procurement of 165 broad-gauge tank wagon for an estimated $17 million and procurement of 280 buses involving $23 million. The other seven projects are procurement of 10 broad-gauge diesel-electric locomotives with $21 million aid, 50 metre-gauge flat wagon for $2.9 million, 100 bogie tank with $7.43 million aid, 170 metre-gauge flat wagon for $9.49 million, 264 metre-gauge passenger carriages for $$98.72 million aid, 30 broad-gauge diesel electric locomotives with $60.95 million aid and procurement of six dredgers worth $102 million. Eleven railway, one dredger and one bus-related projects had already been concurred from the Indian authority. The Indian LoC bears 1.75 per cent interest per annum and it will be repaid in 20 years with five years' grace period. Besides, Bangladesh and India also inked an addendum to the MoU between India and Bangladesh to facilitate overland transit traffic between Bangladesh and Nepal, an MoU for cooperation in renewable energy, another on conservation of the Sundarbans, a protocol on conservation of the Royal Bengal Tiger of the Sundarbans, an MoU on cooperation in fisheries, one on cooperation between Doordarshan and Bangladesh Television, an MoU on cooperation between Jawaharlal Nehru University and Dhaka University, and an agreement of cooperation between the National Institute of Fashion Designing, India and BGMEA Institute of Fashion Technology, Bangladesh. bdnews24.com/ssz/nir/2340h
Related Stories