November 21, 2026

Mamata testy with Teesta, 'won't come'

Mamata apparently not happy with final draft of Teesta, writes to Manmohan expressing her reluctance to accompany him to Dhaka Full story with foreign ministry comment

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 04 Sep 2011, 01:18 PM

Updated : 10 Aug 2022, 05:23 PM

Baby Moudud with New Delhi correspondent, bdnews24.com Dhaka, Sept 4 (bdnews24.com)—West Bengal chief minister Mamata Banerjee is not accompanying Indian prime minister Manmohan Singh on Tuesday as she is believed to be not happy with the final draft of the interim Teesta river water-sharing deal The deal was set to be inked during the high-profile visit of Manmohan beginning Tuesday. A source close to Mamata, quoting the chief minister's Secretariat, told bdnews24.com on Sunday that she conveyed her displeasure over the proposed deal to Singh in a letter, pointing out that the final draft is quite different from the earlier versions. Mamata also reasoned floods in her state and upcoming Durga Puja for her not being able to fly down to Dhaka, the source added. She had been likely to accompany Manmohan in Dhaka with chief ministers of four other states during the two-day visit. Foreign ministry's director general (external publicity) Shamim Ehsan told bdnews24.com that they had no confirmation that Mamata was cancelling the visit. Sources in Indian government, however, said that the government would continue to try to allay concerns of all and take all political parties onboard about the deal on Teesta. Mamata purportedly believes that the final draft might not be in the interest of West Bengal and that is why she is reluctant to accompany Manmohan to Dhaka and witness signing of a deal, which her political opponent Left Front might use against her. Chief secretary of the state government in West Bengal is believed to have written to the prime minister's office on Sunday, although the content of the letter is yet to be known. Her All India Trinamool Congress is an ally of the Indian National Congress, which leads India's central government. The Revolutionary Socialist Party, a constituent of the opposition Left Front in West Bengal, earlier expressed reservations about the proposed Teesta deal. The RSP leader and a member of Indian parliament, Prashanta Majumder, said that his party would oppose the deal, if it failed to protect the interests of the people of the northern region of West Bengal. Teesta flows through Sikkim and northern part of West Bengal before entering Bangladesh. As West Bengal is also largely dependent on Teesta for irrigation and hydropower generation, India's central government has been factoring in the views of the state government while negotiating the interim treaty with Bangladesh for sharing of the water of the river. Mamata is one of the five Indian state chief ministers who were set to accompany Singh in his visit to Bangladesh. Indian railway minister Dinesh Trivedi, who belongs to Banerjee's All India Trinamool Congress, expressed some reservations about the planned interim deal on Teesta in a meeting of the Cabinet Committee of Political Affairs chaired by Manmohan in New Delhi Manmohan next day sent his national security advisor Shiv Shankar Menon and a top official of the Indian government's Ministry of Water Resources to Kolkata to brief Banerjee about the interim deal. Menon on Saturday also visited Dhaka and met prime minister Sheikh Hasina's international affairs advisor Gawher Rizvi and economic affairs advisor Mashiur Rahman. This was Menon's second visit to Dhaka ahead of the India premier's visit to Bangladesh. He was in Bangladesh capital on Aug 28 and 29 to lay the ground for the visit. Apart from Mamata, chief ministers of four other Indian states bordering Bangladesh – Tarun Gogoi of Assam, Lal Thanhawla of Mizoram, Mukul Sangma of Meghalaya and Manik Sarkar of Tripura – are also likely to accompany Manmohan. Manmohan invited all the chief ministers of the five Indian states bordering Bangladesh to accompany him to Dhaka, ostensibly to keep them in the loop on the deals that New Delhi and Dhaka would sign during his visit. Apart from the interim deal on Teesta, the two countries are also likely to sign a similar water sharing deal on Feni River, which flows through Tripura before entering Bangladesh. Bangladesh and India are also likely to finalise deals to resolve the issues related to enclaves, adversely possessed land and un-demarcated borders between the two countries during Singh's visit to Dhaka. But the opposition Asom Gana Parishad and Bharatiya Janata Party too launched a campaign in Assam against the proposed deal to settle issues related to land boundary. The AGP president Chandra Mohan Patowary said that people of Assam would "oppose tooth and nail" any move by India's central government in New Delhi to give away even "an inch of land" of the state to Bangladesh, even if such an initiative was endorsed by the state government headed by Gogoi. The AGP – a regional party – staged a protest demonstration in Guwahati last Monday, denouncing the purported move by New Delhi to strike a swap-deal with Dhaka to resolve the issues related land boundary. Patowary said that any such a move on the part of the governments in the Centre and the state could lead to serious turmoil in Assam. Even the BJP – the principal opposition party in Indian parliament – strongly opposed New Delhi's purported plan to strike an exchange agreement with Dhaka to settle the issues related to enclaves and adversely possessed land between Bangladesh and India. Pradyut Bora, the general secretary of the BJP's state unit in Assam, said that the party would oppose Indian Government's plan both legally and politically. But chief minister of Congress-ruled Assam Gogoi too told media-persons in Guwahati that India would benefit from the proposed deal that New Delhi and Dhaka would ink to settle issues related to land boundary during Manmohan's visit to Bangladesh. He said that Assam would not only gain more in the proposed India-Bangladesh deal, but it would also help the State check illegal influx from across the border and barbed wire fences would be erected even on those stretches where it could not be done so far due to bilateral dispute. Manmohan was trying to evolve political consensus on the deals ahead of his visit and discussed with BJP leaders L K Advani, Sushma Swaraj and Arun Jaitley about those in a brief meeting in Parliament House in New Delhi last Friday. Anandabazar, a vernacular daily of West Bengal, reported on Sept 1 that Mamata was anxious about some issues of the draft. She did not want the deal to harm her state's interest in any way, the report said. The newspaper also said that Mamata cleared the draft when national security advisor Shiv Shankar Menon removed her anxieties at a meeting. Mamata said she had a long-term relation with prime minister Sheikh Hasina. "The relationship had not been harmed even when she was not in power," the newspaper quoted Mamata as saying. Referring to the draft, Anandabazar reported that the water of Teesta would be shared by measuring the amount of water flowed through Gazaldoba point, 25 kilometres away from Shiliguri, India. "India will take 52 percent and Bangladesh 48 percent after preserving 460 Cusec (cubic feet per second) Teesta water." But a Congress MP hinted that the planned Teesta water-sharing treaty will see Bangladesh get 25 percent water "We had a meeting today [Sept 1]. National security advisor Shiv Shankar Menon told me that India will get 75 percent of the Teesta water and Bangladesh will get the remainder," Lokshobha member from West Bengal Abu Hasem Khan Chowdhury told BBC Bangla. bdnews24.com/bm/corr/ost/bd/1938h
Related Stories